4 ms·
Your style of argument fundamentally doesn't work. This comment is no better than your earlier one. 1. Dismissing someone else's personal anecdote because you
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Your style of argument fundamentally doesn't work. This comment is no better than your earlier one.
1. Dismissing someone else's personal anecdote because you have a different personal anecdote is basically broken on the face of it.
2. Saying "Being called smart doesn't hurt anyone, I know because of my personal anecdote wherein I was not called smart" is just not any kind of solid logic whatsoever.
3. Dismissing their anecdote as a single instance with your single instance when there are actually other anecdotes here in this very discussion that agree with theirs and it's the essential point of the article under discussion is not a reasonable claim in the slightest.
4. All research has its critics. Rebutting my comment with "your research has critics" while ignoring the myriad other flaws in your initial position amounts to cherry picking.
If you want to debate this further, let me suggest you address the other points I have made and also go find research that actually agrees with your world view as stronger arguments than your current one. Otherwise, it's most likely really not worth engaging.