3 ms·
I haven't read the paper but I did read the article. I imagine this is a case of reporter not understanding the research. This is clearly about linguistic rela
by godelski 7y ago
I haven't read the paper but I did read the article.
I imagine this is a case of reporter not understanding the research. This is clearly about linguistic relativism. There's a clear difference between how languages like Mandarin and English talk about time but the difference within indoeuropean languages is much smaller. I buy into Mandarin vs English shifting how one thinks about time (this isn't a new concept) but any secondary language changing how one views time (in a significant way) I'm skeptical. English and Spanish (which were used as examples) speak about time almost the same way. And if you're going to talk about Mandarin, there are much better examples than that they use a vertical axis instead of a horizonal (which doesn't mean they use both.)
- alpaca128 7y agoBut the article was written by the researchers, at least that's indicated by the first paragraph: "My new study – which I worked on with linguist Emanuel Bylund"
- godelski 7y agoThis threw me off too so I'm unsure. But it really sounds like much bigger leaps than what is conventionally believed.