4 ms·
Ok, so you want communities to value work that creates value. Besides, say, actively participating in the production of basic food and shelter, what is valuabl
by colechristensen 7y ago
Ok, so you want communities to value work that creates value.
Besides, say, actively participating in the production of basic food and shelter, what is valuable work?
A follow-up, how would you defend the value system I'm asking for as non-arbitrary?
- wwweston 7y ago> Besides, say, actively participating in the production of basic food and shelter, what is valuable work? Not a perfect signal, but if someone will pay you to do it, your work is probably valuable to them. This gets distorted by wealth inequality and probably half a dozen other factors, which is why it's not perfect. Not everything that's valuable fits neatly into a market context, of course. Exercise and hiking are valuable to me, but no one will pay me to do them. Games might similarly be an opportunity to develop in some way (many games are engaging because they involve some kind of skill) and provide recreation and maybe weave some social fabric. But they're often limited and have diminishing returns compared to some other opportunities...
- galaxyLogic 7y ago> they're often limited and have diminishing returns Right. I think therefore the thing is, to be conscious about the purpose of those games, ask questions about what kind of value they bring to their players and the society at large. Are they opium for the masses?
- vageli 7y ago> > they're often limited and have diminishing returns > Right. I think therefore the thing is, to be conscious about the purpose of those games, ask questions about what kind of value they bring to their players and the society at large. > Are they opium for the masses? Is it wrong to want to devote time to being idle/non-productive? Must we spend every waking moment perfecting our every aspect? Are we afforded no moments of respite beyond sleep?
- hueving 7y agoIt's simple, valuable work is work that people are willing to pay for with currency that can be used for food/shelter/whatever. It seems arbitrary, but if some billionaire pays you a million dollars to bite her toe off, that's still immensely more valuable than the 10 years spent in the article because a million dollars worth of obligations were just released to someone who will (on average) spend them. Money is just a note of a generic obligation (aka debt) from the rest of society in that currency.
- colechristensen 7y agoWe're talking about different kinds of value.
- Matumio 7y agoI don't have the answer, but it's certainly not simple. I'm not willing to pay you anything for participating in this HN discussion. That doesn't make your contributions worthless. Some people pay millions for a useless piece of canvas with some blobs on it, but this crazy minecraft construction or that webcomic that I'm enjoying for free is supposed to be worthless? No way. The need for food and shelter only requires a small percentage of our collective time these days. The much larger part of our economic activity is not grounded in that need, though it may be convenient to make other people think that working 40 hours a week is just barely enough to earn the right to exist.
- wolco 7y agoThe value in HN comments is high. Just because they don't show ads doesn't mean they aren't able to capture that value either. HN is not free in the purest sense. Companies/ideas/agendas are presented to you. It a way it's a platform and platforms are usually free and offer at least some network effect value.
- lazyjones 7y ago> It's simple, valuable work is work that people are willing to pay for with currency that can be used for food/shelter/whatever. So, "valuable work" is just work with financial benefits? If I save 100 poor people's lives it's worth less than if I drive a millionaire around for $10?
- feral 7y agoThis is a fair point; its not easy to objectively define value. But I'd say to a first approximation, economic effort defined towards the pursuit of maximising arbitrary stats in a video game, is less likely to be valuable work. That's really all I'm saying. Just because its hard to define objectively, shouldn't mean its a free-for-all, and that we accept that all activity is equally useful (or un-useful.) We can and should use our judgement here.
- galaxyLogic 7y ago> what is valuable work? People have mentioned food and shelter but also there is much value in KNOWLEDGE and science because that helps us ensure food and shelter. Say astronomy, maybe one day it will give us shelter (in terms of knowing what to do) from an asteroid hitting the earth. My question for myself is, why should I play these games when the real life is like a game too but one which is much more challenging, much more important and much more valuable, from which we can learn much more, if we take our aim to be learning.