3 ms·
A ton of upsides. * The hand does not leave the hone row. * It never by mistake registers your hands as a click or a movement. * Your skin can be extremely w
by nine_k 7y ago
A ton of upsides.
* The hand does not leave the hone row.
* It never by mistake registers your hands as a click or a movement.
* Your skin can be extremely wet or dry without consequence.
* You can continue a motion without being limited by the size of the trackpad, because you don't modulate the position directly, but its first derivative. This removes tension between being precise and having the range.
* It separates motion and clicks by having dedicated hardware buttons, often three of them. (Middle button click on most trackpads is tricky, and middle button drag, impossible.)
* Wheel emulation is generally fine, again without moving your hand off the keyboard.
There are downsides, too, of course.
* No multiple-finger gestures, like the pinch.
* Harder to make extremely flat.
* Does not mimic the mobile phone. I think this is the kicker: a trackpad is more intuitive for newcomers and casual users. Trackpoint is preferred by pros who are much less numerous.
- na85 7y agoHonestly, I disagree with your last point. There may be some "pros" who prefer the clitmouse but I consider myself a "pro user" in that I use my laptop(s) every day for work and for personal stuff, and I greatly greatly prefer a quality trackpad. Apple in particular ships laptops with excellent trackpads. If all you've used is the garbage trackpads that get shipped with most Dell or Lenovo laptops, then sure I can see why a clitmouse would be preferrable, but having used them all I can say that after using my macbook's trackpad I have zero desire to go back to the pointer, and mine is the comically-large one on the touchbar macbook pro. It's enormous, but even so I've never had a spurious click or mouse-movement with this machine, and that's not hyperbole. If I need reliable pointing for a particular workflow beyond what a trackpad can deliver, I have a bluetooth mouse. Or a desktop computer with a corded mouse. The trackpoint/clitmouse pales in comparison.
- nine_k 7y agoI wasn't clear enough. I don't mean to say that the trackpoint is overwhelmingly preferred by pros, and other forms of coordinate input (trackpads, trackballs, mice, etc) are not. If anything, pros is likely the group with most diverse and special preferences. I tried to say that people who prefer trackpoint are mostly pros, not newcomers.
- NikolaNovak 7y agoThere certainly are many pros of various kinds who prefer the trackpad; in fact, I would say that in any given group (however we define "pros" and "amaterus" when it comes to laptops:), most people will prefer trackpad. But I am to this day convinced it's simply the learning curve - until the day I see a video or a person using trackpad that doesn't make me cringe in the same way that a two-finger key-hunter does. I can understand that this seems patronizing, I struggle to put it in a way that doesn't seem personal, but for years I have witnessed colleagues who claim to be excellent with trackpad, they love it, it's great... and then they take 3-5 times longer to get things done as they go swipe... swipe... swipe oh there I am at the other end of the screen... swipe... swipe... oh there's the button:-/
- toxik 7y agoWould these people really do better with a trackpoint? It doesn’t sound like learning issues, but ability issues.
- alanbernstein 7y agoKind of off topic, but is there a standard way to emulate a wheel with a track point? I have a desktop keyboard with a track point and the lack of a wheel is a bigger nuisance than I expected.
- southerndrift 7y agoYou may have to activate this, but generally, press the middle mouse button, then you can scroll with the track point while the button is pressed. Problem on windows is that you have to choose between the middle mouse button click and the scrolling. You need additional software to have both, at least for the lenovo driver. Bonus point for the track point is that you can also scroll to the side.
- saulrh 7y agoAm I the only person that consistently has trouble with trackpoints? Every time I try to make a large movement I get halfway across the screen before the thing decides it's drifting, tries to correct, and sets its new zero at the edge of physical travel. Then I have to take my finger off it, wait thirty seconds for it to re-zero at physical neutral, and try again, this time remembering to zig-zag so it doesn't think that my inputs are spurious drift.
- pjc50 7y agoTrackpoints give me RSI almost immediately. I've not had this problem with other forms of input for a long time. The only one I liked was the Toshiba Libretto, which had it on the side of the screen bezel so you could work it with the finger most adapted for fine movements - the thumb.
- DanBC 7y agoLots of people don't like them. Have you tried a different trackpoint cap? Some people find a different shape (flat vs domed) makes a difference. But some people just don't get on with trackpoints.