2 ms·
> exactly the same security level as NAT. > There's a very small argument for privacy You can't say it has the "same security", while also saying there is a "
by mindslight 7y ago
> exactly the same security level as NAT.
> There's a very small argument for privacy
You can't say it has the "same security", while also saying there is a "small" difference. Privacy is an integral part of security, especially for natural persons.
> we have privacy addresses
AFAIK "privacy extensions" merely pick a random host address rather than naively using the ethernet MAC (!!). This still allows identifying discrete hosts.
The NAT scheme I described is strictly better than this. So yes, I can envision an IPv6 future where we have convenient global addresses for incoming traffic, but outgoing traffic gets NATted to a single address (single probability distribution, really). It's just not going to be a return to the trustful 1970's air-out-your-genitals simplicity that is widely envisioned.
> behind NAT many of your devices are probably already identifiable in many other fingerprinted ways that obscuring the address for this sake would be pointless
Those other ways are also security vulnerabilities. We shouldn't excuse vulnerabilities because other vulnerabilities exist, especially in the direction of the foundation. While it is appropriate for a higher protocol to simply accept a weakness of a lower layer that it is built on, going the other way is unjustifiably throwing in the towel.