4 ms·
So let's go to the root of this. What is it that the funding agencies value in Elsevier publications? That if it's published there it's a mark of high quality r
by im3w1l 7y ago
So let's go to the root of this. What is it that the funding agencies value in Elsevier publications? That if it's published there it's a mark of high quality research.
Assuming Elsevier is killed off, someone else will have to put in the work of sifting good from bad. And that's not an easy problem, especially when many try to pervert the process for ideological gain.
- Vinnl 7y agoIt might not be an easy problem, but it's not a problem that has to be tied to publication, and it's not a problem that has to be pay-to-win. (Disclaimer: I'm part of a project that tries to sift the good from bad without those things.)
- a3_nm 7y ago> Assuming Elsevier is killed off, someone else will have to put in the work of sifting good from bad. All of this work is performed by unpaid reviewers, not by Elsevier themselves.
- im3w1l 7y agoElsevier delegates yes. But the buck still stops with them. They pick the reviewers, for one.