4 ms·
This overlooks the longterm impact of a new type of company that has been greatly enabled by technology: predatory revenue omnivores. These are companies that h
by jandrewrogers 7y ago
This overlooks the longterm impact of a new type of company that has been greatly enabled by technology: predatory revenue omnivores. These are companies that have figured out how to identify large revenue flows outside their current business or sector and systematically capture that revenue successfully, over and over (Amazon is a good example). In the past, revenue growth was not sector-agnostic in this way because sector expertise created insurmountable advantages for incumbents such that revenue growth was more a function of sector growth and competition came from within that sector. Attempts to materially expand outside a company's native sector almost always ended in failure. Now it looks like a repeatable business model that a minority of companies have figured out.
More and more, you see alien companies successfully colonizing established sectors and stripping them of their revenue. Few value companies are prepared to handle the scenario when these alien companies show up because historically it has never been a realistic threat. I've seen this play out across several industrial sectors over the last decade and almost without exception, companies retreat to niches that the predator hasn't turned its eyes to yet. That's a strategy for being eaten last. The threat is so far outside their experience that they struggle to see a path forward.
If I was going to invest in "value" these days, I'd invest in the revenue predators. They are going to capture much of the best value revenue eventually but this will give them the appearance of "growth" companies in the short term due to the scale of organic revenue growth this business model creates for them.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoWho are these predators? Among FAANG I'd guess only the acquisition of YouTube has been a success, and only modest at best.
- akkartik 7y agoI don't think GP is referring to acquisitions. Acquisitions signal failures of predation. Predation here = putting incumbents out of business. Quickly ramping up to competitiveness in a whole new sector. An extreme case of "software eating the world," basically.
- tiredyam 7y agoInstagram? Twitch? WhatsApp? Github? I know there are more
- jandrewrogers 7y agoA hallmark of the predators is that they often enter markets without doing any material acquisitions within that sector. They capture revenue organically. This has been reduced to a repeatable system. That is what makes them so difficult to defend against. They don't behave like market incumbents and they compete with a very different set of skills than are seen in the markets they enter. They also tend to narrowly target the most profitable parts of the sector first instead of the entire value chain and expand from there, which rapidly reduces the profit incumbents could use to invest in a defense. And in fairness, a lot of sectors are gravy trains for the incumbents. They haven't had to work hard for profits, never mind survival, in a very long time. They also spend the first few years in a state of total denial about the threat when one of these companies shows up.
- mlevental 7y agocan you give an example of such a predator? how many sectors does Amazon operate in? 2? retail and cloud services. they don't make cars, they don't farm, they don't provide Telecom services, they don't develop real estate. which revenue flows have fallen prey to them? note digital distribution of media (Amazon video and music) is an extension of retail not a different sector. their independent production of said media does count as a wholly new venture but as far as I can tradicional media conglomerates have not fallen prey either.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoAmazon, to use that example, is involved in the production supply chain long before products gets to retail. In many verticals, vendors now use Amazon both as an upstream supplier for their production process and a retail channel for the finished product. If you buy a physical book from a major publisher, there is a significant probability that the book was manufactured by Amazon. They have built up all kinds of just-in-time manufacturing facilities and services that supply all kinds of businesses at very competitive rates. These companies are usually not called "Amazon" so you likely don't realize Amazon owns them. In sectors where this has been iterating the longest, it has slowly turned classic industries into IP holding companies that are barely involved in the physical execution of their business. This is an invisible part of Amazon's business. They've built all manner of manufacturing and production facilities that are further and further up the supply chain. At no point is a business required to retail on Amazon but once you are in their workflow it sure makes things easy for the vendor, and over time Amazon replaces more and more of the supply chain you use. I've watched this from the inside for the entire lifecycle of Amazon entering a couple different "boring" industries and the process has been as impressive as it has been unstoppable. Amazon is not the only company doing this by any means, they are just the most obvious and there are a few different versions of this strategy.
- TimTheTinker 7y agoLet’s see... - Apple, Samsung, LG, and Google have supplanted a wide range of consumer products with modern cell phones. Point-and-shoot cameras, some prosumer cameras, low-end document scanners, household telephones, PDAs, small flashlights, small voice recorders, portable tape and CD players, car CD players (via wired or BT connectivity), portable DVD players, boom boxes (via Bluetooth speakers), car GPS navigation systems, compasses (to some extent), pocket notebooks, planners (to some extent), a large segment of the wristwatch and pocket watch market, pocket calculators, professional scientific and graphing calculators, walkie-talkies and handheld radios (not completely though), portable electronic games and some game consoles... those are a few of the big ones. - There is no type of brick-and-mortar store in any branch of retail or auction that hasn’t been hit hard by Amazon and eBay. Additionally, all the B2B businesses in the retail supply/service chain have been hit hard as either their clients suffer or they themselves lose business to Amazon. I could go on. The world is a completely different place than what it was 20 years ago.
- imjk 7y agoWhile you're not wrong, I don't think all (maybe any?) of these are examples of specifically targeted markets taken over by the companies you mentioned. Apple probably didn't target the flashlight market and decide to take market share from Maglite. I think you've just identified products that have naturally been supplanted by new technologies, many of them falling to the adoption of smartphones. A more appropriate example may be Amazon moving into the groceries market. But even that, one could perhaps argue that their broad market is general retail, with competitors like Walmart and Costco, in which case it wasn't really that far of an extension at all from their natural market. I guess Amazon and Apple moving into the realm of Hollywood and film studios may be a better example. I'd like to see a broader success like Apple taking market share from Automobile manufacturers, etc.
- pjc50 7y agoGoogle has successfully predated most of the traditional publishing and news industry; Netflix has predated film and TV while not quite having the characteristics of either.
- skybrian 7y agoIt seems like you could instead make an argument that Amazon is just sticking with things they're good at. (Various forms of retail sales, along with cloud computing.) They are not a conglomerate combining unrelated businesses like GE or Berkshire Hathaway. Lots of expansion within the realms they're in, though.
- _0ffh 7y ago>Amazon is just sticking with things they're good at >They are not a conglomerate combining unrelated businesses But they don't and they are. Amazon is monitoring sales of all categories of articles, identifies items that sell well and are easy to knock off, then knocks them off. They held more than 70 private brands in April 2018. [1] https://www.vox.com/2018/4/7/17208804/amazon-private-label-brands-list https://www.vox.com/2018/4/7/17208804/amazon-private-label-b...
- skybrian 7y agoPrivate-label sales don't seem that different from what other retailers do? Unless they are going into manufacturing?
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThis is a superficial view of Amazon's business. They increasingly own the upstream manufacturing and production businesses that companies use to produce their products that are then sold retail on Amazon or elsewhere. Amazon isn't just a retailer, they are the supply chain. Because Amazon is such a powerful force in retail, for businesses that sell on Amazon using Amazon's supply chain to also manufacture their product is the path of least effort. Amazon may not be the cheapest or the best supply chain possible but it is reliable, consistent, and their customer service is good if there is a production problem. Being "hassle-free" is a compelling selling point for many companies, completely independent of the retail considerations. AWS can be viewed as just a particularly large instance of this but Amazon has been building traditional manufacturing supply chains for their retail vendors for a long time.
- 7y ago
- kgwgk 7y ago> will give them the appearance of "growth" companies in the short term due to the scale of organic revenue growth this business model creates for them That’s not the “appearance” of growth, that seems the definition of growth! I also find your reference to “value revenue” somewhat confusing in the context of the usual growth/value classification of stocks.
- TimTheTinker 7y agoI think OP meant “growth” as a category or type of company (as opposed to value companies).
- kgwgk 7y agoYes, and they match the definiton of growth stocks as far as I can see. Saying that to invest in "value" (as opposed to "growth") you invest in growth companies like AMZN is quite confusing to me :-) Edit: For the benefit of those not familiar with the growth/value classification: Top positions in S&P 500 Value index only (over 1%): APPLE INC JPMORGAN CHASE & CO BANK OF AMERICA CORP UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC AT&T INC CHEVRON CORP WELLS FARGO CITIGROUP INC WALMART INC INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CO COSTCO WHOLESALE CORP Top positions in S&P 500 Growth index only (over 1%): MICROSOFT CORP AMAZON COM INC ALPHABET INC CLASS A/C FACEBOOK CLASS A INC VISA INC CLASS A MASTERCARD INC CLASS A CISCO SYSTEMS INC PFIZER INC VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC MERCK & CO INC BOEING NETFLIX INC MCDONALDS CORP ABBOTT LABORATORIES ADOBE INC PAYPAL HOLDINGS INC WALT DISNEY MEDTRONIC PLC Top positions present in both (over 1% combined): BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC CLASS B JOHNSON & JOHNSON EXXON MOBIL CORP PROCTER & GAMBLE WALT DISNEY HOME DEPOT INC INTEL CORP COMCAST CORP CLASS A COCA-COLA PEPSICO INC ORACLE CORP PHILIP MORRIS INTERNATIONAL INC HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC ACCENTURE PLC CLASS A
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]