4 ms·
Not sure why you'd want to start making scientific papers non-copyrightable. The easiest solution is just have scientists publish in open-access journals. Eas
by refurb 7y ago
Not sure why you'd want to start making scientific papers non-copyrightable.
The easiest solution is just have scientists publish in open-access journals. Easy right? Nope, they are judged by the impact of their papers and it's higher in better quality journals.
That's the value these journals offer - exclusivity.
Scientists and universities could solve this issue immediately. Scientists publish in open-access journals and universities stop judging based on the journals "impact factor". However, neither one wants to do that.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoBecause there is no reason they should be, so the decision can be handled at the legal level and not be as subject to the influence of the journals. They would have one chance to fight it before it was cemented into law.
- refurb 7y agoWhy should an author not have rights to their own work, just because it’s scientific in nature? You’re also opening the door to unintended consequences - are scientific textbooks not copyrightable also? If not, why not?
- trolololooo 7y agoYou're making a big assumption that the author of a scientific paper gets to have any rights whatsoever. But that aside - these journals keep valuable research locked up from plenty of long-dead researchers. Their estates aren't getting the money when a grad student is grifted for $90 to view the paper.
- ethbro 7y agoI'd argue we'd be much better off if textbooks weren't eligible for copyright.
- golemiprague 7y agoBecause the researcher is an employee of the university, I don't get a right to my work when working for someone, I get salary instead.