5 ms·
Nuclear has effectively zero unit cost, it's all fixed cost. Once you build the reactor, you generate at full capacity all day and night and take whatever the m
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
Nuclear has effectively zero unit cost, it's all fixed cost. Once you build the reactor, you generate at full capacity all day and night and take whatever the market rate is.
That means you get paid less during the day when solar is the cheapest provider, but you still match its price and supply your full generation capacity even then, because you can, because anything is more than nothing and the incremental generation cost is effectively zero. Then you make more at night when solar requires storage, and even more still whenever the day was overcast and energy prices had to rise high enough to suppress demand enough that the depleted storage isn't fully exhausted before sunrise.
The capacity factor is always 100%, it's the price you get at any given time that varies. But price variability in itself is no problem either, as long as the average price is above average cost. And that average includes not only times that it rains for multiple days in a row, but also winter, and that with consideration of people also needing to switch from oil and gas to electric heat.
- Marazan 7y agoNo
- pfdietz 7y ago"as long as the average price is above average cost" And that's the killer. Add enough solar and wind and the average price craters, even if solar and wind cannot handle everything (without help from dispatchable sources and/or storage).
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe problem with that argument is that it proves too much. It applies to everything, because solar and wind are the same as nuclear, their incremental generation cost is effectively zero once the capital is paid, so you take whatever the market price is. Which means you have a problem. It's physically possible to build enough solar and wind and storage to even handle extended periods of low sun and low wind. But if you do that then on a normal day with a normal amount of sun and wind, you have a large oversupply and the price falls to zero and everybody goes bankrupt. That happens less if you add real baseload like nuclear to the mix, because something with a fixed generation capacity doesn't have a periodic shortage requiring you to compensate with an overcapacity which bankrupts everybody on a normal day.
- pfdietz 7y agoSolar and wind will build out until it is no longer profitable to do so. That means: when they have driven the price of electricity when they are operating, averaged over time, down to the point they can't get a return on investment. This price point is far below where new nuclear needs it to be for nuclear to earn back its construction and operating costs. What drives all this is that the levelized cost of energy from solar and wind is much less (a factor of 3 or 4) than the levelized cost of energy from new nuclear plants. Nuclear, or at least many existing nuclear plants, has an additional disadvantage: it cannot cut output rapidly. If power from renewables suddenly floods the market, prices can go negative. Renewables can just stop selling in that situation, but nuclear is forced to continued to run and eat the negative revenue. The low power density of the renewables sources, usually depicted as a negative, is the source of this advantage: sunlight absorbed in PV modules can just be allowed to dissipate as heat there with no negative effects. (In fairness, I should also mention that there are subsidies in the US that encourage renewables to keep generating even at negative prices. These subsidies will have to go at some point, and perhaps that point is now.) What will be the final death knell for nuclear will be when short term storage gets cheap enough that the times when that's discharging will also be economic death zones for nuclear plants. I expect few of the existing operating nuclear power plants to survive after that.