3 ms·
The elephant in the room with any kind of fission reactor is that they are going to need a lot of security. Even when the fuel and waste product is not weapons
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
The elephant in the room with any kind of fission reactor is that they are going to need a lot of security. Even when the fuel and waste product is not weapons grade uranium, it's still highly radioactive and a great source of material for a dirty bomb. Basically anything that goes boom combined with small amounts of radioactive material and a bit of wind is a great way to depopulate e.g. large cities. So, having lots of small molten salt reactors all over the planet, which seems like the key selling point, is not a great idea from that point of view. Having them in or near any kind of conflict zone would be super risky. And according to this article there is actually some weapons grade uranium being produced as well which makes this even more problematic.
The security aspect would make this a lot more expensive than it already is and cost is already on the high side even before you consider that. This is a problem with traditional reactors as well but they have the advantage that they are huge facilities and that there are only a handful of them; so securing them is relatively easy.
People are suggesting this as complementing renewables but the cold hard truth is that renewables are already dirt cheap and on track to continue to drop in price by magnitudes for the next decades. That includes battery storage as well. Already quite cheap, also dropping in price, and typically already factored into e.g. new solar bids that are killing competing bids for coal and gas plants (or in some cases shutting them down prematurely).
Even at the current prices, that's a problem for any kind of nuclear solutions being contemplated right now. At the low end of the spectrum, we are talking 2 cents per kwh currently. Imagine this dropping to something like half a cent or even less. At those prices, the security alone would make nuclear too expensive probably. A 1 mw facility would have basically be generating only about 500-2000$ worth of energy per hour but only at peak demand. There's no guarantee prices won't drop way below that either. Any kind of operational overhead would be a problem. Needing 24x7 intense security would be very undesirable.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoAre you suggesting that variable renewables plus batteries will approach prices that are... too cheap to meter? Looking at current cost VRE trends, when variable sources contribute up to 4% of world energy, and surrounded by massive amounts of cheap but high-carbon natural gas, and assuming that the trends will just continue exponentially downward without serious complication, is optimistic. Cost of integration of variable sources plus batteries is expected in many studies and somewhat intuitively to skyrocket as market penetration increases. When you have enough VRE to cover 100% including the big evening peak with batteries during a clear summer day, the extra generation you build to fill the other gaps gets curtailed. But you have to fill daily and then seasonal gaps, worldwide, including heat in winter and worldwide transportation (not just electricity). Buying that battery that is only even needed at all every third day is 3x the price, yet we prefer if the power doesn't brownout with this frequency. This is difficult. Already we're seeing NIBMYism in large solar installations in california and with transmissions lines. That gets worse with scale. Nuclear today is a hedge against the possibility that deeply carbonizing with variable renewables + storage at world scale will be harder than we all think and hope it will be. That said, nuclear certainly needs to drop capital and O&M cost dramatically if it wants to play the game. And security is indeed a big factor in this. Its competition in the small-footprint dispatchable world is natural gas with full CCS, which is also looking pretty cheap.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoYes. Not indefinitely of course but we've seen nothing yet and there's enough in the research pipeline to suggest clear trends over the next two decades in terms of cost improvements, efficiency improvements, cheaper materials, etc. That 4% you mention was less than 1% not so long ago and will be closer to 40% not too long from now. Such is the nature of exponentials. IMHO 5X cost reduction is basically a done deal even just applying simple economies of scale. You can argue whether this happens in five or ten years maybe but arguing it isn't happening seems futile. Beyond that, 10x is extremely likely to happen as well. There's a lot of research happening that would need to be a complete failure/waste of time for that to not happen. At worst it will happen slower that I might like. Maybe this happens over the next decade. Or two. Or three even. From there, 20x might be quite possible as well. Beyond that we're indeed talking rapidly diminishing returns. 10X would mean 0.2 cent/kwh. 20x would cut that to about 0.1 cent. This indeed gets you in to territory where metering it becomes more expensive than is worth the trouble. The average household uses about 15000 kwh per year, or about 150$ worth of energy at these prices; much less outside the US. Much of that is going to be produced on people's roofs or in their back yards. At that point it turns into a fixed cost. Historically the same sources producing the studies you are referencing have been off by magnitudes predicting current adoption and prices for both solar and wind. So, I'd consider that the pessimist glass half empty point of view. Not to dismiss it entirely but arguing cost increases seems a bit far fetched in light of current trends in the market.
- Mirioron 7y agoAren't roof solar panels very inefficient? They can't track the sun and you can't have good density from them either. Furthermore, they don't work for office buildings and apartment buildings. >Not to dismiss it entirely but arguing cost increases seems a bit far fetched in light of current trends in the market. I think what the parent was saying is that because solar and wind don't reliably produce energy, we will need redundancy. As the market share of solar and wind grows we will need to increase the amount of storage and power generation far beyond what we normally need to operate. Let's say you have a city that uses 1 GWh of electricity per day. If you were to generate all the electricity with natural gas then you need to have 1 GWh plus some extra for redundancy to fulfill the needs of the city. If you generate 5% with solar and the rest with natural gas then nothing really changes. If the weather is bad then the natural gas plant will step in. As the share of your solar power generation grows toil need more and more redundant storage and solar power generation. If you rely 100% on solar power generation and the weather can be bad for a week in a row over the city, then you'll need storage that will last for more than that entire week. Not only that, you'll also need extra power generation capability to be able to fill and maintain that storage. Just to put this into perspective: the US uses about 10 TWh of electricity per day.
- simion314 7y agoYou could say the same thing about any airplane, even small planes or drones could be filled with explosives and hit strategic targets like a chemical factory. You can place the nuclear generators in police stations, military bases, other locations that are already protected, there is no need to have a small nuclear generator in each electronic device like in Fallout.
- javier2 7y agoYou can't run an electrical grid on wind and solar alone and expect it to be stable enough. - The prospect of every household having a battery backup big enough to smooth over spikes and dips is ludicrously wasteful. We are already struggling just mining enough to make batteries for cars and phones. - the sheer scale of the wind and solar farms will leave major environmental impact to wildlife. Look at how massive area solar farms need, and know the area has to be cleared and desolate of life.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoNope, simply untrue. Cars use lithium ion batteries mainly for their energy density. For grid storage, other batteries and ways of storing energy are feasible and probably a lot cheaper as well. Wikipedia has a nice overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage#Grid-oriented_battery_technologies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage#Grid-orien... The wild life impact of solar is relatively minor compared to burning coal, intensive farming, and all the other things we do. We'd need to only cover a relatively small amount of land with solar to produce what we need. And ironically some of the most suitable land for this would be deserts that have relatively little wild life to begin with. Of course the impact of wiping out coal, gas, and petrol usage would be enormously positive. Windmills do indeed kill some birds. Yet, these things seem to have barely any impact on e.g. the seagull populations in places like Denmark that have a ridiculous amount of wind mills.
- achalhp 7y ago(Molten salt reactor is a fluid fuel reactor. Fluid: liquid, gas and plasma.) Molten salt reactor is a stepping stone for fusion reactors. We need to master liquid and gaseous reactors before going plasma. Our civilization should aim for larger goals. We need some form of nuclear power to terraform other planets and spread earth's precious life and conciousness everywhere.
- pfdietz 7y agoWe do not need nuclear for any of that.
- wolfram74 7y agoWell, given how solar has an inverse square relation between watts/area and distance from the sun, by the time you get to mars, solar is getting pretty piddly, the asteroid belts and jovian moons its downright comical.
- pfdietz 7y agoActually, solar still has huge advantages at the distance of Mars. In space (actual space, not a planetary surface), it's difficult for nuclear to dissipate its prodigious amounts of waste heat. Solar, in contrast, can be made much lighter than on Earth, as there isn't wind and rain to deal with. And of course in general the Sun is available 100% of the time in space, further improving the economics. But in any case, the argument wasn't that solar was necessarily better, it was that nuclear wasn't necessary. Solar can provide energy basically anywhere, with power beaming, even out into interstellar space.
- achalhp 7y agoPlanets rotate so backup power is needed during nights. Spacecraft has to avoid obstracles and has to move, so backup is needed. During interstallar journey there is time delay in communication, so it may take hours to adjust the power beam when spacecraft moves a little bit. Fusion is like solar energy just near to us and MSR will be eventually replaced by fusion reactors. MSR and many other fluid-fuel reactors run hot and it makes radiators small: https://www.flickr.com/photos/oakridgelab/31537153147/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/oakridgelab/31537153147/ Stefan–Boltzmann law: Radiation heat transfer is proportional to 4th power of temperature.
- usbseeker 7y agoIt's not an elephant in the room, it's just so obvious that it's not something that needs explained.