3 ms·
> But for people who don't, what is the functional difference between a SSN today and a national ID, apart from SSNs being broken for such a purpose? There ha
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> But for people who don't, what is the functional difference between a SSN today and a national ID, apart from SSNs being broken for such a purpose?
There have actually been requirements enacted prohibiting SSNs from being used for anything other than social security, but they haven't been enforced, and that's the problem with SSNs.
The answer isn't to have a national ID, it's to get rid of SSNs, or at least restrict them to social security.
You shouldn't need a SSN to open a bank account. The bank should issue you a bank ID (i.e. a debit/credit card) which allows you to get/spend the money you've deposited. You have a credit card number, you have a bank routing number, what do you need a SSN for? Only surveillance, nothing else.
If you stop using SSNs for anything other than social security, you can't have Equifax. Databases tracking everything about everybody are not required to exist, do not benefit people, and national ID numbers only exist to enable them.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWhat do you need an SSN for? Taxes. (There was a time when bank accounts actually paid enough interest to matter on your taxes...)
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat should only be required for an interest-bearing account and only if the interest exceeds the reporting threshold. It should at least be possible to have an account without providing the SSN. They could still withhold the interest until you provide the SSN in the uncommon case that both of those are satisfied, but that should be very uncommon indeed because if you have enough money to reach the reporting threshold, you would make more investing it in even low risk securities, so only foolish or extremely conservative people should ever have done that. (And if we want to go into a different policy discussion, you wouldn't need SSNs at all if we would switch to VAT+UBI, because then there is no income tax, the UBI handles making it progressive, and the VAT is handled by the selling business, so there is no need to track anyone's personal dealings whatsoever.)
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> and only if the interest exceeds the reporting threshold. That would lead to the bank needing to get your SSN on an existing account when you made a deposit. That seems... messy.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWhy would they need it for you to make a deposit? They're just making sure you pay your taxes, which as long as the money is still in the account, would be there and remain available for that purpose until you fill out the form. They wouldn't even need to restrict withdrawals provided there was still enough in the account to cover the taxes.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWow, you're sure free with new procedures to impose on the banks...
- ohithereyou 7y agoThe drug war in the 1980s and the focus on money laundering also motivated this - the seeds of the 'know your customer requirements were planted here.