3 ms·
What does "actual ID system" mean? SSN is literally a national ID system. Assigned at birth/immigration/residency. Used by national government to pay benefits,
by paulddraper 7y ago
What does "actual ID system" mean?
SSN is literally a national ID system. Assigned at birth/immigration/residency. Used by national government to pay benefits, track Medicare membership, receive taxes, etc.
If you're talking about adding photos and fingerprints and stuff to SSN or equivalent...that's not a cost thing. That's 100% a privacy thing.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoActually, the SSN is an account number, solely intended for tracking money paid into and paid out of an account. It isn't meant for identification, and the method it's used for identification is terrible. (Largely: If you know the number, you are identified.) It's treated like a secret, but as a 9-digit number you give to dozens of organizations in your life which follows a predictable and partially guessable pattern, it is an absolutely terrible secret. Absolutely good explainer video about how this travesty took place historically: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- paulddraper 7y agoSSN is absolutely an identifier. It's like given name & surname (also identifiers), but actually unique. The problem is that SSN is not only an identifier, it's also the means of authentication, which is "the process or action of verifying an identity." --- To draw an analogy, username is an identifier. Password, SSH key exchange, etc. are mean of authentication, i.e. the process of verifying a username identifies the user. SSN is both a username and a password; it needs to be one or the other.
- reaperducer 7y agoAssigned at birth/immigration/residency A common misperception. A SSN is not assigned at birth. A child doesn't have to have a SSN unless the parents want to use him as a tax deduction. I didn't get mine until I was 17 and needed one to get a driver's license and passport.
- paulddraper 7y agoYes, you are correct. A person is eligible for a SSN upon birth/immigration/residency. The federal government requires it for Social Security benefits, and states may require it for driver's licenses, birth certificates, etc. Practically speaking, between state laws and banking requirements, virtually every U.S. citizen has one.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> SSN is literally a national ID system. That'd be weird, considering for decades the cards specifically said otherwise. https://www.ssa.gov/history/hfaq.html https://www.ssa.gov/history/hfaq.html > Beginning with the sixth design version of the card, issued starting in 1946, SSA added a legend to the bottom of the card reading "FOR SOCIAL SECURITY PURPOSES -- NOT FOR IDENTIFICATION." This legend was removed as part of the design changes for the 18th version of the card, issued beginning in 1972.
- paulddraper 7y agoIf I understand you correctly, it used to not be an identifier, but 40+ years ago that changed?
- Jach 7y agoI suppose the word "system" is doing the bulk of the work here. An ID as a platonic thing is just something that uniquely identifies me, and we have an infinity of integers that would work just fine for that, SSNs being a subset of the integers too. As part of a system, though, this ID should not just only identify me and only me, but no one should be able to identify themselves with any other ID. You can probably classify this into a complete system as a form of authorization to identify, or a process of authentication to be done on ID usage, or a process of verifying an ID or ID derivative (like a signature) which may or may not require authentication. There are many ways of implementing this from photos to fingerprints to passwords to (my preference) smartcards that never expose the real ID and rely on asymmetrical encryption.