7 ms·
> If you banned insurance discounts and insurance had to pay the same dollar to dollar cash price (without kickbacks/incentives) It never occurred to me before
by criddell 7y ago
> If you banned insurance discounts and insurance had to pay the same dollar to dollar cash price (without kickbacks/incentives)
It never occurred to me before that this is an option. That sounds like a good idea.
I also wonder why health insurance should be allowed as an employee benefit. How does it make any sense to tie my access to healthcare with my employment status?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhatever historical reason there may have been to start it, the only reason it exists now is to give big businesses more power than smaller businesses, and individuals.
- thfuran 7y agoThat's reductive. If I have a choice between a job that offers health insurance and one that doesn't, all other things being equal, I'm definitely taking the former. That's also surely a large part of why it continues to exist.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI’m talking about the legal reason for it to exist, since employers can purchase insurance with pre-tax money, and the bigger and more white collar/younger the employer, the less their insurance costs.
- wincy 7y agoRight but the reason large insurers can offer good insurance is they are a much larger risk pool. I work for a Fortune 500 and my daughter has probably cost the insurance $1m. No big deal rates didn’t even raise. Before I worked for a contractor and we cost THEM a million bucks, and they had to get rid of the low deductible plan, and boost insurance rates by $50 per WEEK per employee. We single-handedly destroyed their risk pool from three months of NICU stay, making it so they could no longer offer affordable insurance. Rather than accept the new rates we got cheaper plans on the Marketplace. Unfortunately though those aren’t tax deductible but we still came out ahead. It’d make far more sense to just have a marketplace for everyone and make the risk pool the entire US population, rather than let giant corps get good rates while small companies get devastated when an employee or their children get sick.
- baddox 7y ago> Before I worked for a contractor and we cost THEM a million bucks Was this a large group insurance plan (usually 50+ or 100+ employees depending on the state)? If it were a small group insurance plan I don't believe your utilization would increase the rates, since AFAIK all the small groups in one state/region and insurance provider are combined. If the employer was large enough to have a large group insurance plan, but still fairly small, I suppose one person's utilization could noticeably increase rates at the next plan negotiation. I believe this is why some companies that are too big for small group insurance plans utilize "professional employer organizations" to participate in a larger risk pool.
- wincy 7y agoYeah it was maybe a 50-100 person company. The new company is substantially larger.
- dredmorbius 7y agoYou can literally (if indirectly) blame the Nazis. WWII wage-price controls: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=114045132?storyId=114045132 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=114045...
- gowld 7y agoWWII also motivated universal health care (NHS) in the UK. How does this make sense, though? > "The war economy is an entirely different ballgame," Thomasson says. The government rationed goods even as factories ramped up production and needed to attract workers. Factory owners needed a way to lure employees. She explains that the owners turned to fringe benefits, offering more and more generous health plans. Why is a healthy plan better for employers than paying cash and letting employees buy their own health care / insurance? The 1943 IRS ruling that health insurance is tax free, and the legislature failing to correct that, is more of a problem. This blatant failure isn't an "accident", it's bad lawmaking that biases toward business, against people.
- dredmorbius 7y agoWhy is a healthy plan better for employers than paying cash Wage-price controls prohibited that. and letting employees buy their own health care / insurance? Risk-pooling, information asymmetries, "shoe-leather" frictions (having to shop around, individually, for everyone), bargaining power. Healthcare markets poorly.
- snarf21 7y agoIt doesn't and it didn't used to be that way. During labor shortages in WWII, laws were passed to limit salaries and keep companies working. The workaround was to start offering "benefits" and they just never went away.
- cneurotic 7y agoWish more people talked about / knew this! How a big part of the reason the US healthcare system sucks is just a weird fluke of history!
- howard941 7y agoInertia's definitely important but 75 years is a long time, long enough to discount it as a valid excuse. But if we're allowed to dig into history a contra example is another ~70 year old system, the UK's NHS. That system managed to pull itself up by its bootstraps in spite of the loss of empire, material shortages, and left over war ruins, and a superficially more discouraging class system than our's that turns out to have more upward mobility than our system. Weird.
- credit_guy 7y agoIndeed, it’s too bad this is not more widely known. The NYT has a nice overview [1], the relevant passages below. Wikipedia’s coverage [2] is excellent as well. “In 1942, with so many eligible workers diverted to military service, the nation was facing a severe labor shortage. Economists feared that businesses would keep raising salaries to compete for workers, and that inflation would spiral out of control as the country came out of the Depression. To prevent this, President Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9250, establishing the Office of Economic Stabilization. This froze wages. Businesses were not allowed to raise pay to attract workers. Businesses were smart, though, and instead they began to use benefits to compete. Specifically, to offer more, and more generous, health care insurance. Then, in 1943, the Internal Revenue Service decided that employer-based health insurance should be exempt from taxation. This made it cheaper to get health insurance through a job than by other means.” [1]https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-the-us-has-employer-sponsored-health-insurance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/05/upshot/the-real-reason-th... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance_in_the_United_States#The_rise_of_employer-sponsored_coverage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance_in_the_Unit...
- inferiorhuman 7y agoI also wonder why health insurance should be allowed as an employee benefit. It's an excellent way of reducing worker mobility.
- blackflame7000 7y agoIt's also far cheaper, on the whole, to insure a group of people vs an individual because there is less variance in the rates of usage.
- fmihaila 7y agoThe logical conclusion, then, is that the most cost-effective structure is the maximal one (a single risk pool including the entire population, a.k.a. universal coverage).
- nicoburns 7y agoAnd the evidence from countries that have implemented this supports that conclusion!
- blackflame7000 7y agoNot necessarily, people who are unemployed tend to get sick more often with the most common cause being substance abuse. A company with workers that are drug tested is likely to spend less money on substance abuse programs than a group of random individuals.
- BubRoss 7y agoI think you need to back up claims like that with a source. Are companies themselves spending money on substance abuse programs for their employees? Are substance abuse problems the biggest factor in health insurance burden?
- jeffdavis 7y agoNo insurance provider has only one customer. They always pool risk across all of their customers. A company signing up lots of their employees doesn't increase the size of the pool -- it just adds an intermediary. The reason often cited for employer-based coverage is that it avoids some self-selection problems, but that's a different and complex topic.
- balabaster 7y agoThe same way tying work visas to employers limits employee mobility and increases the "slave labour" effect. People end up stuck in jobs they hate just because they have health insurance and will have to go without it for a period if they change jobs. That's utter bullshit.
- blackflame7000 7y agoWell, that's what COBRA coverage is for to bridge the gap between jobs. Also if you lose your job you can usually get insurance from the state at little or no cost while on unemployment.
- FireBeyond 7y agoAhh COBRA. "You've just left your job and have all the regular expenses still, but you won't mind an extra $1500 a month for health insurance, right?"
- SlavikCA 7y agoWell, without COBRA you'll have to pay $2500 for the same coverage.
- blackflame7000 7y agoIt's definitely a terrible system, but if you have a pre-existing condition how fair is it to the next insurance company to take you. That's like taking your crashed car to Geico and saying fix it. There has to be some way that the insurance company can make money on the odds.
- FireBeyond 7y agoIf you have insurance and a pre-existing condition, it's probably going to be a net-neutral to the insurer (for every one coming on to their system, there's one leaving to another). The preponderance of a given condition is not a function of having insurance (though complications thereof can certainly be increased by NOT having insurance). And has already been factored in by actuaries into policy pricing. The biggest issue is that we see health insurance AS insurance, not amortized healthcare costing. > There has to be some way that the insurance company can make money on the odds. That's the thing, they see an opportunity to increase profit. A few comments on that, as someone who has worked in the industry of developing software for health insurance claims management and benefit processing: 1) insurers are incentivized to deny claims, often talking about how "unfair" it might be for "them" to have to pay for a treatment. The irony is that "they" are not paying for anything - the risk pool is. Those premiums were calculated based on actuarial assessment, plus insurer overhead calculated in. What they mean by "them" having to pay out is that we cut into their profits, as they don't refund money to risk pools if the entirety of the pool is not used - they keep it, in addition to the admin overhead. 2) insurers have been known to be outright unethical, if not illegal in denying claims. Some prurient examples: denying Heli EMS for car accident victims from the scene to a trauma center because of "lack of pre-approval" (sorry, as a paramedic I am not "hold[ing] for a nurse consult" as I call an insurer to decide whether they are going to deign to pay for this patient's transport, and retroactively canceling coverage for "failure to disclose a pre-existing condition" that was actually unknown at the time of disclosure, i.e. "You were seeing a physician for maladies X, Y and Z. You had not been diagnosed with anything at that point, but later were, and maladies X, Y and Z were symptomatic of that. Ergo, you had that condition at that time, though you did not have a formal diagnosis, and failed to disclose that you had it. Accordingly we are voiding your coverage for breach of contract".
- baddox 7y agoAs far as I can tell, the main advantages of getting health insurance from an employer are 1) the tax deduction and 2) favorable group insurance plans. For 1, it's just completely insane that all medical expenses aren't automatically tax-deductible. It's silly that it's advantageous to have my employer pay $200 a month for my insurance plan rather than just pay me an extra $200 and let me use that on whatever plan I want. For 2, that may be a little trickier politically. Group insurance gets more efficient the larger the group, assuming there's a mechanism to prevent adverse selection. So obviously, we want to increase group size. That was one of the claimed justifications for the individual mandate.
- cheald 7y agoIt does seems like an artifact that after-tax premiums aren't always deductible. We already have a model for how to do that in the homeowner's mortgage interest deduction: insurers (banks) report the total of your premiums (mortgage interest) to the IRS, you get to deduct that value from your AGI. If you're paying for insurance with after-tax dollars, you can deduct it as long as you're a) itemizing, and b) have total medical + premium expenses >7.5% of AGI, but given that people who pay for insurance with pre-tax dollars get that benefit regardless of those criteria, it seems like it'd only be sane to relax the rules so that people paying with post-tax dollars get the same break.
- nicoburns 7y agoIsn't 2 a great argument for nationalised healthcare insurance?
- baddox 7y agoAt the bare minimum it could be an argument for a public option, which was initially part of the Obamacare proposal until Lieberman threatened to cooperate with the GOP to block it.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoFor 2 the simple solution is to make the whole country the risk pool.
- astura 7y agoIt really bothers me that some employee compensation is lower because of health insurance being a standard employee benefit. An employer saves thousands of dollars if an employee doesn't need to enroll in their insurance (they may get it through their spouse, the VA, or are enrolled in medicare). That savings is not required to be passed down to the employee and its almost never is in practice.