3 ms·
I'll start this by saying that I'm highly in favor of universal health care. Seems like the best insurance company would be the one with the most patients, whi
by godelski 7y ago
I'll start this by saying that I'm highly in favor of universal health care. Seems like the best insurance company would be the one with the most patients, which can thus negotiate the best deals. So with that out of the way...
Doesn't this bill completely undermine the insurance business? If a hospital can't charge more than the median value that in network patients are charged, why would you buy insurance? I must have misunderstood or misread something.
I would think this would make it substantially more difficult for insurance providers to make negotiations and cut deals with hospitals. I would imagine they would just pass off the cost to the consumers, as they typically do.
It always seems to me that these half way positions between universal health care and commercial end up being worse than either. From a very high level it sounds like a fantastic thing, preventing patients from getting screwed, but isn't the cost that those with insurance pay more? I would assume that there's far more people paying insurance than the number of people that get these surprise bills. Though I'll admit the whole system feels rigged at this point and is likely intentionally convoluted to make consumers uninformed (by level of difficulty).
- bhelkey 7y ago> If a hospital can't charge more than the median value that in network patients are charged, why would you buy insurance? You would buy health insurance for the same reason anyone buys any kind of insurance (above legal minimums). Suppose a thousand people have a 1% chance of owing $10,000. Their EV is -$100. If a company offers insurance for $120, the company benefits by making $20 * 1000 and the individuals benefit by removing variance from their life.
- michaelmrose 7y agoA massive portion of medical expenses presently paid for by insurance are predictable costs that the insured knew going into the year. You can find affordable car insurance because your actual payout from your insurer is very likely zero this year. If your actual payout this year is certainly 10-100k this year depending on what actually goes wrong this year how on earth do you affordably insure that individual. Remember also that sickness stunts family income. Insurance only makes sense for large hard to predict expenses.
- singron 7y agoIt makes sense for insurance to incentivize preventative care (e.g. by paying for it or requiring it), since it reduces future large claims. Otherwise it can be cheaper for individuals to forgo preventative care and wait for insurance to cover the large claims.
- godelski 7y agoI wouldn't say our insurance system even remotely promotes preventive care. My insurance plan gives me one official a year and to teeth cleaning. That physical does not cover even basic testing that the doctor may want to do (this is ridiculous for people with family histories of problems). While I'd say this is better than just seeing a doctor when you're not okay, I wouldn't really call this preventive or actively incentivising people on the plan to get preventive treatment or testing (other than those things are already cheaper, but that's by the nature of the disease/problem not because the insurance is doing anything to incentivize this behavior)
- perl4ever 7y ago"It makes sense for insurance to incentivize preventative care (e.g. by paying for it or requiring it), since it reduces future large claims." This is a popular thing to say, but the trouble with the logic is that the cost of preventative care, albeit small, is multiplied by everybody, while the cost of the large claims is multiplied by a small fraction of everybody. So whether it is actually profitable to prevent problems is very sensitive to the cost of the prevention, and the likelihood of the consequences without prevention. I think a lot of people are familiar with the scene in the movie Fight Club where the guy is talking about the cost-benefit equation for initiating an automotive recall. If prevention was automatically profitable, then that scene couldn't exist or make sense.
- perl4ever 7y agoHealth insurance in the US generally has large deductibles in my experience, so they wouldn't normally be paying out. If you have no deductible, it's basically just your employer giving you a tax-exempt bonus, I think.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>If a company offers insurance for $120, the company benefits by making $20 * 1000 and the individuals benefit by removing variance from their life. More like they offer you the insurance for $99.99 and make money by having $99.99 * num_customers sized chunk of money to play with (i.e. invest into things). But yeah, your general comment is correct.
- duxup 7y ago>why would you buy insurance? Insurance is just there to offset risk, the risk being more (or massively more) medical bills than what you would pay if you paid out of pocket. If your insurance company gets a lower or higher rate, really doesn't matter to you directly.
- godelski 7y ago> If your insurance company gets a lower or higher rate, really doesn't matter to you directly But it does indirectly because this influences the price of that insurance and how many networks your provider is part of. There's definitely a feedback loop here (network effect) where the larger the provider the better deals. If my out of pocket is the same by having insurance and not having insurance, why get insurance? Or maybe why get a better plan (which I assume are more profitable)?
- duxup 7y agoI wonder if there really is a reflection on the price of insurance that an individual pays as far as the prices at hospital, there are lots of steps between those two things.
- luckydata 7y agoIn a sane world health insurance wouldn't have a reason to exist. This is one aspect of life where market forces don't work and never will, and where a single payer system makes a whole lot more sense.
- godelski 7y agoThis is the way I think. That it'd be cheaper to cut out the middle men. Take the total costs of procedures then distribute that back to the public weighted by their income levels (i.e. taxes). Everyone benefits from a healthy society: one with strong herd immunity and where less people are taking time off of work because they are sick. Health isn't even close to an individual practice.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoDoesn't this bill completely undermine the insurance business? Good. I'm all for taking profit-by-default out of health care. It always seems to me that these half way positions between universal health care and commercial end up being worse than either. ... Though I'll admit the whole system feels rigged at this point and is likely intentionally convoluted to make consumers uninformed (by level of difficulty). It's pretty damn bad right now so it's hard for me to imagine something worse. Let me give you my tangentially related anecdote. I don't currently carry insurance for a variety of reasons and I ended up in the ER earlier this year. Upon being discharged they left me with an estimated bill. The paramedics (SFFD) were very prompt about billing me (ouch). The hospital, part of a private chain, was not. Eventually I got inquiries from their patient outreach (or whatever) department — not billing, but a whole department dedicated to seeing if uninsured people qualify for a variety of government programs. Eventually I got an initial bill with a due date and three different "total due" dollar amounts (full price, their goodwill discount, and a further discount if I paid in full by the initial due date). So I navigated their ambiguous web site and paid it, and was prompted to take a survey asking how clear I thought the bill and payment system was (lol). Then I got a bill demanding the middle dollar value with a due date earlier than the initial bill (I'd already paid it well before both dates). Then I got another bill claiming I hadn't paid anything. I finally created an account to actually view my billing statements. The site claims that I owe the difference between the lowest and middle "total due" values from the initial bill. As an added bonus because I'm not carrying insurance it's not like I can complain to the state insurance commissioner.
- godelski 7y ago> Good. I'm all for taking profit-by-default out of health care. 100% on board >>It always seems to me that these half way positions between universal health care and commercial end up being worse than either. > ... It's an issue if consumers have to pay more. Those affected the most are those that have the most to lose. I'm all on board of getting money out of the business and making health care about people. But my worry is that these "small step" methods is just causing worse coverage at higher costs. I mean look at how Blue Cross is making record profits but coverage is going down (and they blame Obama Care the whole way). Really I'm saying stop with the small steps and just get along with it. Sometimes small steps is the way, other times there's a chasm in-between and you have to make a leap to cross it. I feel our health care system is in the second category.