4 ms·
This is ridiculous, along with that judge blocking the order to bring cost transparency to advertised drugs. But here we are in California a self described pro
by mc32 7y ago
This is ridiculous, along with that judge blocking the order to bring cost transparency to advertised drugs.
But here we are in California a self described progressive state, but the pols pull this?
Note, I’m not a progressive as I agree and disagree with many things and am politically all over the map but I think these are things that are good for all of us.
- wrong_variable 7y agoWhen it comes to your wallet - it doesn't matter if you are a progressive or conservative. You are going to protect your financial interests. It's a principal as old as Life itself.
- kyshoc 7y agoThis is a massive oversimplification -- if everyone voted purely to protect their financial interests, "voter-approved tax increases" wouldn't exist.
- ndiscussion 7y agoNot the op, but I believe your statement is also a massive oversimplification. Increasing taxes raises the cost to the individual, but it also raises costs for all their neighbors, and results in community improvement (ideally). Is investing an attack on your financial interests?
- blackflame7000 7y agoMany people see it as "Oh I was paying $500 a month on healthcare but now the government will pay for it by increasing taxes. However, I'm not a 1% so it won't affect me as much as it affects them so I'm getting a dollar's worth of government for 80 cents today." Those same people aren't paying attention to their tax withholdings all they know is that if they don't get a refund then they are upset.
- perl4ever 7y agoI think you are misguided in your assumptions about motivations. Insurance is worthwhile whether you get $0.80 or $1.25 back on the dollar. It's not necessary for people to have a positive expected value from it.
- blackflame7000 7y agoThere will always be a large number of Americans that don't want to pay for other's poor habits. With car insurance people with fewer accidents or tickets get discounts but you can't do that in healthcare because of pre-existing conditions. I propose a 2 part system. One system is government funded and pays for ambulances, ER visits, annual checkups/physicals, and maybe a few other basic services like dental cleaning. When you dial 911, the police and fire department both come for free, so why does the ambulance bill you a grand? Any sort of life or death situation would be covered by this. Abuse of the system can be monitored and the government has plenty of recourse. The 2nd part of the system would cover short and long-term illnesses and conditions as well as prescriptions. Things like orthodontics could also be a part of it. Basically, it pays for any doctor that doesn't work in an ER. This way people who don't use these services a lot aren't burdened by those that do while at the same time eliminating the fear (and litigation) that comes with being bankrupted by a catastrophic accident
- perl4ever 7y agoThe analogy to car insurance comes up over and over, but I think it's flawed. Pre-existing conditions are not defined by the average paid out in claims to a person. It's normal to have a deductible that's over $5K and is not met in a typical year, and one or more pre-existing conditions. So it bewilders me how people keep debating as though the contrary were typical. The question is not whether a person should have their predictable costs paid for through "insurance", but whether a person should be able to get insurance for catastrophic costs, if they are considered to have a non-quantifiable risk. There is a fundamental inefficiency in a market that discriminates against sick people, not just a lack of "social justice" or whatever. If insurance companies are allowed to discriminate against pre-existing conditions, then they have to charge not just enough to cover the true risk of the high risk customers, but enough to cover the risk of being wrong about the risk - insurance against "unknown unknowns", adverse selection. "Fairness" often costs more money.
- tathougies 7y ago> This is a massive oversimplification -- if everyone voted purely to protect their financial interests, "voter-approved tax increases" wouldn't exist. Yes, it would! People always vote to raise taxes on the minority (the 'rich') to give money to the majority (the 'poor'). This is rule by tyranny, a common issue with democratic governments. It is one of the main reasons democracy is not the ultimate value of the United States governmental system.
- davidw 7y agoCalifornia talks the progressive game, but in housing for instance, they've failed and failed. Oregon passed significant housing reform this year - California failed (OR HB 2001 vs CA SB 50). Lots of articles on this: https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/article/San-Francisco-Bay-Area-is-not-progressive-on-13319525.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/article/San-Francisco-Ba... https://marketurbanismreport.com/blog/the-disconnect-between-liberal-aspirations-and-liberal-housing-policy-is-killing-coastal-u-s-cities https://marketurbanismreport.com/blog/the-disconnect-between... And one on Oregon's bill: https://www.sightline.org/2019/06/30/oregon-just-voted-to-legalize-duplexes-on-almost-every-city-lot/ https://www.sightline.org/2019/06/30/oregon-just-voted-to-le...
- blackflame7000 7y agoThere are a lot of NIMBYs in California. It's really easy to signal virtue but to actually follow through takes real work.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoCA is progressive, compared to most of the other states. Just shows how un-progressive the US is. We only have 6 or 7 with paid family leave!
- luckydata 7y agoIn california the democratic party has occupied the space left by the disappearance of the GOP by having a lot of very conservative members. California politics are not particularly progressive, and they look that way only if you compare us to Alabama, otherwise we're a solidly center-right state. We just don't do extreme right (GOP).