4 ms·
No, locking people up in prison does not make them better when they’re released, and often results in them coming out worse than when they went in. Also, putti
by olliej 7y ago
No, locking people up in prison does not make them better when they’re released, and often results in them coming out worse than when they went in.
Also, putting someone with mental health problems in prison costs more than a real treatment facility, where at least there’s the possibly for them to get better.
Here’s a clearer way to describe it:
If putting people with mental health problems in prison is better than having them on the street, why are they being let out again? You’ve already decided that they’re not going to receive any treatment or assistance, so they’re going to hit the streets, commit some crime (violent or otherwise) and then go back to jail.
So why let them out? Prison sentences are intended to be “long enough to correct or discourage future criminal acts”, with life sentences for people we don’t believe can be released safely. Given that we know that people with mental health problem but no treatment or support will reoffend, that seems (by your assessment) like a prime candidate for permanent incarceration.
- djohnston 7y agoit's certainly better to keep violent crazy people off the streets. i would like them to be in a treatment facility, where they have the opportunity to be helped and can be let back out as healthy members of society. that doesn't exist. so, yeah, they shouldn't just be out and about harassing everyone else, right?