8 ms·
Court rules against Oracle in Pentagon 'war cloud' litigation
- the_duke 7y ago> Oracle’s cloud infrastructure 2.0 provides significant performance and security capabilities over legacy cloud providers "Legacy" cloud providers. Nice try... On a more serious note: has anyone used Oracles cloud offerings? I've heard they are very sub-par.
- neom 7y agoIn working with city governments, we occasionally run into their "cloud SOAP apis"...
- jschwartzi 7y agoOh, SOAP, that bastion of high performance and improved efficiency.
- wil421 7y agoAt a previous company they used the Oracle SOA middleware. They suggested using one of their cloud APIs so we could use REST to connect to my app. The Oracle team sold it to them and then said it was at end of life 6 months later after they built stuff.
- oneplane 7y agoYeah, used it in a PoC in the past (because it was supposed to be either equal to AWS but cheaper or better but equal cost; spoiler: it was neither). Problems are mostly bad integration and older style integration where it exists (think: older API types, very little code generation, unpolished SDK, mostly targeted at integrating with their own non-cloud stuff). Performance was not so bad, but equal performance somehow always came at a higher cost when compared to AWS or Google Cloud (did no comparison with Azure, wasn't used in that case). Not super much, think 1.2x, but enough to make you scratch your head and wonder if the extra effort for something that isn't making developers happy is worth it. The only thing that in some constructions was cheaper was their database offering, but when you build something that needs to work in a cloud, the same effort (depending on your own control of the stack) can be put in to making it work with Postgres. That's mostly because older style database-driven applications expect 1ms latency and less, and you simply can't do that over the internet or with a layered construction in a cloud. If you were migrating local oracle workloads to a hosted oracle setup (i.e. their cloud instead of an MSP) it would make sense. Otherwise not really. One reason we take into account that others might not: our developers and ops simply don't "like" oracle. Doesn't really matter why, because the portion of people that don't like it is large enough that we'd rather spend more to make our teams work well vs. save a few pennies and make them work with sub-par tooling. Unhappy and unproductive teams costs money too.
- pram 7y agoHaving personally worked on the “classic” infrastructure at Oracle, it was a complete disaster. The end user experience is also what I’d imagine a cloud service would have been like circa 1995 The “new” stuff is better in comparison but that’s really just damning with faint praise.
- SteveNuts 7y agoI guess Oracle finally found someone they can't mess with.
- jascii 7y agoTo bad, I wanted to sue Oracle for not hiring me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chipperyman573 7y agoI have an extension that clears any visible "sticky" element on the screen and I had to activate it THREE TIMES over the course of reading the article. Each time the removed element covered a portion of the article, preventing me from reading it. What a frustrating website to use.
- zigzaggy 7y agoPredictable result. I’ve never seen a protest go well for any company. You can win these protests and still lose the work. The best case scenario is you win the protest and have to rebid the whole thing again. You’ll still probably end up losing. Now you walk away with more money spent, more exposure due to public court records, and a customer who’s pissed off.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> I’ve never seen a protest go well for any company Went well for SpaceX, which won access to Air Force contracts through the courts. (It’s now re-litigating [1].) In any case, this is commercial litigation. Not protesting per se. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-spacex-lawsuit/musks-spacex-sues-u-s-air-force-over-rocket-building-contracts-filings-idUSKCN1SS2ST https://www.reuters.com/article/us-space-spacex-lawsuit/musk...
- jsperson 7y agoProbably the biggest one ever - Boeing successfully protested the awarding of the tanker contract to NG/Airbus [1] [1] https://www.industryweek.com/public-policy/us-gao-upholds-boeings-protest-over-tanker-contract https://www.industryweek.com/public-policy/us-gao-upholds-bo... edit: spelling
- oaiey 7y agoExcept that this was with politics and America first politics involved.
- metaphor 7y ago> In any case, this is commercial litigation. Not protesting per se. By this, what were you referring to?
- jdm2212 7y agoPalantir protested the DCGS-A award successfully, then won the contract.
- wjsetzer 7y agoIs there anyone Oracle won't sue? I think most companies would take that as a signal they need to improve their offerings. Oracle on the other hand says, "Are our cloud offerings sub par? No, it's the customer who is wrong."
- dllthomas 7y ago> Is there anyone Oracle won't sue? Sure. Anyone who is not interacting with Oracle, provided they have sufficiently few resources.
- metaphor 7y agoNot defending Oracle, but in government contracting, it's par for the course and happens a lot more than you might expect. Given the magnitude of this contract and its single award nature, I would be even more surprised if no one protested.
- forgottenpass 7y ago>cloud infrastructure 2.0 provides significant performance and security capabilities over legacy cloud providers >secure hyperscale cloud solutions It's just VMs and hosted services. I wanna gouge my fucking eyes out.
- 420codebro 7y agoTo you, maybe. But others, security in public/rented clouds is a serious concern.
- easytiger 7y agocloud hysteria seems to be representative of some kind of mass amnesia about how computers work. It is only successful because it allows business boys with no real technical understanding to make sweeping infra changes to pad their CV
- cloakandswagger 7y agoDo you really believe that an industry worth hundreds of billions of dollars got to that point purely through hype? No benefit to platforms like AWS and Azure at all?
- easytiger 7y agoI think the idea of being able to soon up instances of VPS is useful and some of the deployment tools useful. I find most "cloud native" crap to be so comically poor in performance that I just can't accept it makes sense to burn that many cpus to achieve so little. Perhaps I'm just a dinosaur
- BubRoss 7y agoUsing your computing resources well is for old people, get with the times!
- wmf 7y agoI wouldn't necessarily blame the business boys. Now that public cloud has existed for a decade, there's a whole generation of devops people who know nothing about infrastructure. (I assume most app developers never needed to understand it.) As long as the stork keeps delivering those VMs, who cares?
- setheron 7y agoI don't get the hate for hearing Oracle challenge another large huge company in court. That's the correct course of action in the US. If you disagree with something you take it to the courts! It's not David vs Goliath here where Oracle is abusing it's deep pockets with lawyers. Worse yet then people get upset at the outcome of the decision if it wasn't to their liking.
- count 7y agoOracle didn't challenge another huge company, they challenged the federal govt. They're well within their rights to do so, or the case wouldn't have moved forward at all. The hate for Oracle is that exactly nobody but Oracle thinks they ever stood a tiny chance, and nobody likes a company who's primary customer acquisition model is lawsuits.
- Analemma_ 7y agoI haven't seen anyone contesting Oracle's right to challenge this in court, we're just saying it was a waste of time motivated solely by sour grapes. Absolutely everyone-- at Oracle, at the other cloud providers, and in the Pentagon-- knows that Oracle's cloud is a joke compared to AWS/Azure and that they didn't have a snowball's chance in hell of winning this case. We're making fun of them for frivolous litigation.
- RHSeeger 7y ago> frivolous litigation Frivolous litigation that WE are paying for. It's our tax money paying for those court cases.
- __jal 7y agoThe hate for Oracle is more about Oracle. Their tech has always been weak, their sales force rabid jerks who manage to be even more annoying that IBM's, and they have always taken an adversarial stance towards their own customers. The best strategy to pursue with Oracle is never speak to them.
- wstrange 7y agoI have no love for Oracle, but I do question the wisdom of awarding such a massive contract to a single supplier. We have one branch of government that pursues companies for anti-trust, while another branch helps those companies cement their monopoly...
- thesuperbigfrog 7y agoI agree that a single supplier is always bad. It is basically walking into a customer lock-in situation. However, among the major cloud computing providers Amazon is definitely one of the best in terms of offerings, maturity, and stability. Microsoft is not far behind Amazon, but I do not have any experience using Azure to know how it compares. For "military-grade" cloud computing, I would choose Amazon.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI agree, but under the condition that controls and governance are put into place that ensure the DoD builds their infrastructure and applications in a way that allows them to move to another provider with little friction (this is less about being multi cloud and more about ensuring that the technology choices you make don't marry you to the provider). We should not be headed down a path where AWS becomes "too big to fail" or considered a systemically important institution (for obvious reasons). Today's underdog is tomorrow's incumbent.
- linuxftw 7y agoI hope that Amazon forces the US Government to renew the contract at a 1000% markup. Don't like it? Too bad, single source, good luck with your migration, we've already amortized the equipment. Oh, you only have X months to migrate before we stop patching security vulnerabilities? Well, you better get to migrating quickly! Whoever thought this was a good idea, shame on them.
- rkeene2 7y agoThat's not how these contracts actually work. Certainly Amazon COULD act against their customer's interests but the customer will be around for a long time, so that would be really short-sighted. The process for re-bidding them starts a long time before the contract ends, and often the incumbent will offer a temporary contract to cover the time between the end of the contract and the beginning of the next contract. The process is unpredictably long because one of the losers -- especially if it is the incumbent -- may protest the award. A similar thing happened with a contract I worked a lot with and the new contract (much smaller than JEDI, but still ~$2BN). The contract was to replace legacy datacenters with cloud services and service management layered on top, and was an IDIQ (Indefinite Delivery, Indefinite Quantity) contract -- it was held up in protest so long after award that the government just ordered nothing, and came up with alternate strategies. The protesting entity was one of the winners of the bid (unlike JEDI, it was awarded to 4 parties, though they were all reselling AWS, Azure, Google, etc) and they ended up with nothing from this very expensive and time-consuming bidding process.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoWith the current administration, despite accusations of the contract originally being designed "with AWS in mind", I'd take a 99-1 bet this goes to Microsoft. No way Trump will let this go to Bezos' company. And I myself find it incredibly sad how the fact that I think that will happen, with no or muted outrage, doesn't surprise me in the slightest.
- johnvanommen 7y ago> With the current administration, despite accusations of the contract originally being designed "with AWS in mind", I'd take a 99-1 bet this goes to Microsoft. No way Trump will let this go to Bezos' company. And I myself find it incredibly sad how the fact that I think that will happen, with no or muted outrage, doesn't surprise me in the slightest. GovCloud is AWS and Azure right? I don't understand why JEDI would be exclusively one provider.
- metaphor 7y ago> GovCloud is AWS and Azure right? Nope[1]. [1] https://marketplace.fedramp.gov/#/product/aws-govcloud/versus/azure-government?status=Compliant&sort=productName https://marketplace.fedramp.gov/#/product/aws-govcloud/versu...
- Causality1 7y agoGood. Oracle tried and is still trying to destroy the foundation of the global software ecosystem by copyrighting APIs. Anything that damages that company or costs it money is a good thing.
- Tehchops 7y agoOracle poached a lot of AWS employees when it was first getting its cloud offering off the ground. Looks like cargo-culting has its limits.
- wmf 7y agoOracle appears to be ahead of IBM Cloud who poached almost nobody.
- unixhero 7y agoTrue, except IBM just poached all of Redhat.
- raverbashing 7y agoYou can poach all the employees you want, nothing changes if the management is still thinking SOAP and XML is the latest in technology and alienating your customers is better than giving them a good product
- urda 7y agoOracle should spend less time suing competitors and focus on actually building products for the modern world. This is the same company that tried to damage the coding world by attempting to copyright API's. I have no sympathy for them.
- TomMckenny 7y ago>Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) on Thursday sent a letter to President Trump’s national security adviser, John Bolton, asking the White House to delay the contract over concerns the procurement process has been unfair and biased toward Amazon. A pork barrel military may not be a good idea. One that punishes political critics might even be worse.
- metaphor 7y agoThis article sure did a shitty, non-existent attempt at citing its references. From the cow's mouth, here's the original JEDI Cloud solicitation[1]--which includes the latest amended SOO[2] and Oracle's pre-award protest[3]--and the actual court order[4]. Doesn't seem like anyone is really talking about it either, but it's worth noting that this isn't some gratuitous "here's $10B, we're locking ourselves in for the next decade, go buck wild" ordeal. This ID/IQ contract has a 2-year base with 3-, 3-, and 2-year options for the remaining years, and a maximum $10B cap iff the government exercises all options. Here's to hoping the government doesn't royally screw themselves over by dropping the ball on CDRLs A007 and A014. [1] https://www.fbo.gov/index.php?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=3860a4f4fe9d9ffc31e722ece82a143c&tab=core&_cview=1 https://www.fbo.gov/index.php?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=386... [2] https://www.fbo.gov/utils/view?id=845d0652768ef4a4749231d39ab778d7 https://www.fbo.gov/utils/view?id=845d0652768ef4a4749231d39a... [3] https://www.fbo.gov/utils/view?id=6cd8017d52d2b832855c41fb7405e4ed https://www.fbo.gov/utils/view?id=6cd8017d52d2b832855c41fb74... [4] https://ecf.cofc.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2018cv1880-99-0 https://ecf.cofc.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2018cv...
- deapu 7y ago:)
- trilila 7y ago“But multiple Republican lawmakers and groups have raised concerns that the JEDI contract was built specifically with AWS in mind, raising concerns over market competition and unfair treatment. “ I am from east Europe. I know corruption when i see it. Suddenly if Oracle is left out of the game, up they pop with unfairness and other smoke grenades for the unaware. Also as a technical person, integration at this scale between two providers can be a PITA exercise. Best to chose one.