2 ms·
To be frank, this study likely did not debunk anything. Even 30 years ago, psychologists had outlined the criteria by which the bystander effect does not occur
by BeetleB 7y ago
To be frank, this study likely did not debunk anything.
Even 30 years ago, psychologists had outlined the criteria by which the bystander effect does not occur. A well known criterion (seen in many comments on HN) is to direct your plea for help to a single individual amongst the bystanders ("You! Call 911!" as opposed to "Someone call 911!"). Another aspect that's been known for over 30 years is that if someone in the crowd feels (s)he is an outsider, that person is a lot more likely to intervene.
Did they account for these in the study? How will they determine if a particular person thought of himself as an outsider? If they did not account for these, then the article is attacking a strawman.