3 ms·
These are exactly the reasons why Netherland stopped using voting machines. Although interestingly, it was the fact that anonymity could be compromised, that wa
by mcv 7y ago
These are exactly the reasons why Netherland stopped using voting machines. Although interestingly, it was the fact that anonymity could be compromised, that was the final nail, rather than the lack of transparency.
With paper votes, anyone is able and allowed to check that every step of the voting process is done fairly. You can see the empty voting boxes before the election starts, you can see that everybody puts their one vote in it, you can be present when they're counted. Dutch law made an explicit exception to these rules to make voting machines possible, and that that was even necessary, should have been a massive red flag. And yet this obvious lack of transparency was not enough to get them banned. Only when hackers proved that anonymity could be threatened, were voting machines banned.
Personally I think transparency is more important than anonymity. Compromised transparency enables much larger scale fraud than compromised anonymity, so I'm surprised proving compromised anonymity was even necessary.
- ddingus 7y agoMany of us, at least here in the US, are not that secure. Votes are very highly politicized, tensions high, establishment vs people, social right vs social left. Here, we have fraud, but we have a high degree of anonymity. People don't seem to really get it. I am confused as to why. I am reasonably secure myself and could make the same trade off you did, but an awful lot of my peers would not. Super interesting observations. Thanks!