6 ms·
This is a stupid move. The tax is not payed by big tech giants. Not by both, either. It's complicated and depends on who needs whom the more. If there are no a
by csomar 7y ago
This is a stupid move. The tax is not payed by big tech giants. Not by both, either. It's complicated and depends on who needs whom the more.
If there are no alternative to AWS, Google Adsense, or an American SaaS in France; the French people will be paying all of the tax. The big tech giants will just slap them with a 3% surcharge for being in France.
This is different from US-China tariffs. If the US can source from other suppliers, the Chinese will need to lower their prices. Effectively making them pay the tax. It is a complicated and messy situation.
The big tech giants are named that way because they are big and dominant. This makes them able to make the rules and circumvent the current ones. You'll need the whole EU (or maybe the EU/USA) to get them in line.
France has been digging its own graveyard for a while. It seems that they didn't learn their lessons and now going full speed. If you are a French startup, you'll be less competitive. People hate paying more and it's not clear if they can deduct this tax (like VAT).
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThis would incentivize competitors in France. That’s a good thing for France.
- icebraining 7y agoFrom what I can tell, it will incentivize competitors everywhere, as long as they don't have revenues over €750M.
- luckylion 7y agoWhich is a good thing, too, as it incentivizes decentralization.
- cyrksoft 7y agoWith that argument, protectionism will incentivise competition. So why don’t we close the economy a bit?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoWhether you're /s or not, I wholly agree; I both fully support using public policy, tariffs, and other economic mechanisms to support "at home" companies over those abroad, as well as supporting local labor over that outside the country. If internet companies are the future of the economy (see: Stripe's opinion), why wouldn't you do everything you could as a country to support your own companies?
- cyrksoft 7y agoBecause protectionism isn’t only economically bad but also immoral. You can’t force everybody else to pay higher prices. Supporting your own companies at the expense of the rest of the society isn’t good. You’ll be forcing consumers to pay higher prices for a completely nationalist reason. No reasonable economist would favor protectionism.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoMorality is subjective and open to interpretation. Sometimes consumers should pay higher prices to avoid unwanted externalities.
- cyrksoft 7y agoNo, morality is not subjective. What do you mean by unwanted externalities? Unwanted by who?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- effie 7y agoStrawman, nobody is arguing for supporting companies at the expense of the rest of society. The parent is arguing for supporting companies for the benefit of the society. Both can happen, it depends on how and to what extent it is executed. Economists disagree a lot and they have only partial say in policies, countries are not run solely by economists.
- baud147258 7y ago> If you are a French startup … you won't get taxed under this law until you get more than 750M€ of revenue. So, all thing being equal, a French startup would be more competitive (of course things aren't equals, but that's another matter).
- csomar 7y agoI mean a French startup using the American services.
- Vinnl 7y ago> If there are no alternative to AWS, Google Adsense, or an American SaaS in France; the French people will be paying all of the tax. The big tech giants will just slap them with a 3% surcharge for being in France. Just like VAT is passed on to consumers? I don't think the goal is to make specific companies pay; rather, the goal is to have every type of economic activity to contribute a fair share to the society they benefit from. Digital activity currently contributes relatively little due to being more amenable to tax evasion schemes, so this tax mitigates that. How the exact amount is subsequently distributed among the parties in that activity is not that relevant.