7 ms·
I don't necessarily disagree with your theory on design, but every complex war machine ... has some level of controls that if used improperly could be fatal. T
by duxup 7y ago
I don't necessarily disagree with your theory on design, but every complex war machine ... has some level of controls that if used improperly could be fatal. They are inherently dangerous systems.
Designing fail safes for such things has to be a sort of balance between added complexity / options for failure, and safety.
In the military there are plenty of "don't touch that, let the person who knows how to do it touch it" and I suspect that is often the right design.
- jupp0r 7y ago> don’t touch that, let the person who knows how to touch it Practically, how would that work for a toilet?
- raldi 7y agoIt could be designed in such a way that multiple people could use it with reasonable comfort with a small holding tank and then periodically someone comes along and flushes it.
- epicwhaleburger 7y agoThis.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoIndeed, that's more or less the current system!
- davidw 7y ago"So what did you do in the South Sea conflict?" "I was a submarine toilet operator, first class, serving aboard the USS Deuce"
- beering 7y agoSee the comment elsewhere in the thread about how (according to the German-language article) Schlitt ignored the requirement that the specialist flush the toilet, causing the incident: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20410849 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20410849
- magduf 7y agoI have to disagree to an extent about the "war machine" bit. This is about a toilet, not a torpedo. Every boat at sea needs a toilet; this is a basic need for supporting human life unless you want to have people relieving themselves over the deck railings (which of course isn't even possible on a submarine). If you have to have a specialist flush a toilet for you, the design is bad.
- duxup 7y agoIt's a new toilet on a complex machine that can't just dump stuff out in the open ocean all the time. It's not "just a toilet" anymore than a sub should work like a video game.
- magduf 7y agoIt's not new: Germany had toilets on submarines for many years before this. Germany had U-boats back in WWI. Did they have toilet problems like this before? If not, then this is a bad design.
- cr0sh 7y ago> I don't necessarily disagree with your theory on design, but every complex war machine ... has some level of controls that if used improperly could be fatal. They are inherently dangerous systems. I would also imagine that if you make a weapon too safe - then it either can cease to be a weapon, or by the time you remove the controls which turns it from "safe" to "unsafe" - you might already be captured/dead. It's kinda like some initiatives out there to make it so that owners of guns have to store their guns unloaded in gun safes, with trigger locks, and ammo in separate locked containers. In the (hopefully low probability) event that you need that weapon (perhaps a home invasion or such), by the time you are able to get to it and go through all the steps to make the gun usable - you're probably already dead. Of course, I understand the logic and want behind such protections (to protect children, curious adults, to potentially keep the weapons out of thieves hands, etc) - but at the same time, I also understand and sympathize with the arguments against such controls. There needs to be a balance between making such weapons safe, while also letting them become unsafe quickly when needed. In the case of military hardware, this balance also requires thoughtfulness about the destructive capability of the weapons involved; for instance, safety vs usability will be different for a rocket launcher, versus a nuclear missile.
- sunkenvicar 7y agoA valid explanation of the trade-offs between safety and usability. But it seems like HN doesn’t like guns or gun analogies. Too bad.