4 ms·
Because it uses glas as a substrate and light as a information carrier? Most of what we call “AI” today also uses prelearned weights for their neural networks
by atoav 7y ago
Because it uses glas as a substrate and light as a information carrier?
Most of what we call “AI” today also uses prelearned weights for their neural networks and in many use cases these weights are not touched after deployment.
I don’t see why a neural network encoded in glas should not be an AI while the same neural network on a computer is one — either you have to call both AI or neither.
- silveroriole 7y agoAt least the neural networks were at some point self-assessing and self-modifying, and plausibly could be said to “learn” something. Here it seems more plausible to say that the humans learned what structure to produce than that the glass did. But you’re right, I think many “AIs” shouldn’t really be named that either!
- prashnts 7y agoI skimmed the paper linked there. They did use a digital model for glass-impurity substrate, to adjust the location of the impurities. This doesn’t sound much different than training with activation weight propagation — except, here one can literally see those weights. I don’t see why it wouldn’t fit usual definition of a neural network.
- Voloskaya 7y agoIt may have been designed using AI, but it's not AI. The impurities are not the weights, they are the output of the design software. It is the design software that has been learning something, not the pane of glass. It is like using AI to design, say, the most aerodynamic plane. Only here they used an AI to design something that performs a task that we traditionally use as a benchmark for AI models. But this piece of glass, just like the plane mentionned above, is not learning anything and it's not an AI.
- kolinko 7y agoOut of curiosity - did you ever work with neural networks? (as in - the algorithms, not the high level abstractions?)
- Voloskaya 7y agoYes, pretty much every day.
- prashnts 7y agoThanks for giving this analogy, It made more sense than my imagination above. If I understand correctly, it’s the design process, not glass, that used learning. Along the same analogy, I guess the sculpture in London (glass, here), which was designed using random walk (neural nets), would be the same: the sculpture in itself isn’t “random walk”, but the design process was. (I couldn’t recall what was the name of the sculpture. Here’s the wiki link: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Cloud https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_Cloud ) Edit: I read the other comments and it’s getting more confusing! AI, from my school courses, would be implementation of algorithms like Hill climbing where a system is online: it takes some input, and tries its best to find a solution. Now if I take the output itself for use in, say, signal processing — that “output” would be a “device” to do something and won’t be an “AI device”. Does this make any sense at all? I’d love to get some pointers on this to read.
- yorwba 7y agoThey didn't manually adjust the glass until it worked (which would be infeasible), they wrote a differentiable simulator and used it to determine the material to use at each point via gradient descent, which is quite a feat. That's exactly as self-assessing and self-modifying as a neural network implemented using any other kind of computation substrate.
- dkersten 7y agoMost of what we call AI can learn and update to an extent, in order to be able to match a wider verity if I puts or to improve accuracy on existing inputs, this is a hardcoded solution. If this counts as AI, then every bit of software ever written also counts as AI, which makes the term even more meaningless and marketing buzzwordy than it already is. I suppose the question is, if an AI has learned and you export that final learned state to use in a now-hardcoded classifier, is that classifier still AI (or part of the overall AI) or is it simply the output? I can imagine arguments on both sides. If you accept that as AI, then sure, this fits the bill!
- dodobirdlord 7y ago> Most of what we call AI can learn and update to an extent Most of what we call AI are hardcoded solutions once in production. There may be ongoing offline improvements being made, but once the improvements are established the production AI is replaced with a point-in-time snapshot of the AI undergoing offline training. Self-learning in production causes all kinds of problems, but most significantly it's a security issue since it gives an attacker the ability to manipulate behavior by curating examples.
- hueving 7y agoThe AI generates the solutions. The solutions are not AI.
- darpa_escapee 7y agoAI is gradient descent?
- voxl 7y agoIt's comical how little people understand about machine learning, no one calls an ODE solver artificial intelligence but gradient descent on an interesting equation is somehow now A.I.
- eklavya 7y agoAn equivalent in neural nets would be some model trained and then after the results are satisfactory, burned into an FPGA, that FPGA is not AI and so is this glass. Or both are.
- electricslpnsld 7y ago> either you have to call both AI or neither FWIW having worked with some serious ML heads at Google and Facebook in the past, none of them referred to ML as AI.