4 ms·
The article notes: "Achieving this degree of control and information capture is very challenging." This is an extreme understatement: for anything but the simp
by pdonis 7y ago
The article notes: "Achieving this degree of control and information capture is very challenging."
This is an extreme understatement: for anything but the simplest quantum systems in the simplest, most tightly controlled configurations, it's practically impossible. That's not to say that the QTT experiments described aren't impressive achievements; they are. But they should not be oversold either.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI think it's more than that. If I understand correctly (and I may well not), this kind of thing isn't possible within classical QM, even in principle. The fact that we can do it at all, even in perfect circumstances, is enough.
- pdonis 7y ago> classical QM There is no such thing as "classical QM". If you mean pre-quantum classical physics, this kind of "information capture" certainly is possible in classical physics, regardless of how complicated the system is. It's only in quantum physics that it becomes an issue.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYes, I know that QM is not "classical". By "classical QM", I meant regular, Schrodinger-equation QM, not "quantum trajectory theory" QM.
- pdonis 7y ago> By "classical QM", I meant regular, Schrodinger-equation QM, not "quantum trajectory theory" QM. "Regular" QM is not limited to the Schrodinger Equation. You also have to use the collapse postulate and the Born Rule where appropriate, i.e., whenever measurements are made. QTT is basically just a reformulation that makes it easier to see how to make use of the information revealed by measurements. The "Schrodinger" viewpoint referred to in the article is not the Schrodinger Equation, but Schrodinger's personal take on QM.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoAre you saying that the Schrodinger Equation, the collapse postulate, and the Born Rule are mathematically equivalent to QTT?
- pdonis 7y ago> Are you saying that the Schrodinger Equation, the collapse postulate, and the Born Rule are mathematically equivalent to QTT? Yes.