4 ms·
That's Apple's closed garden, even when they allow you to sideload application, they still have the ultimate decision. Of course it's not malware, but probably
by vbezhenar 7y ago
That's Apple's closed garden, even when they allow you to sideload application, they still have the ultimate decision. Of course it's not malware, but probably enough users have vulnerable software which could be remotely exploited, that they decided to blacklist it.
- scarface74 7y agoA program that surreptitiously reinstalls software when you uninstall it is by definition malware. A piece of software that lets any website activate your camera without your permission is a security vulnerability.
- vbezhenar 7y agoMalware is a software written to harm user. Their purpose was not to harm user, they wanted to make their service more convenient for users. Bugs are bugs, every product have bugs and many products have security bugs. That does not make them malware.
- scarface74 7y agoIntent doesn’t matter only results. The result is that unless you like for random websites to be able to activate your camera without your permission, it did harm users. It wasn’t a “bug”. They purposefully hacked around a security feature. Do you really think it was a “bug” that it reinstalled itself?
- vbezhenar 7y ago> Intent doesn’t matter only results. Then you should call Chrome a malware because there were vulnerabilities with remote code execution (and there will be similar vulnerabilities), so every website could install anything. But that is absurd. > The result is that unless you like for random websites to be able to activate your camera without your permission, it did harm users. First of all, you need a hard data that this vulnerability was exploited in the wild. Otherwise it did not harm users, it only opened a way for malicious websites to harm users. And, again, every vulnerability could be counted as a malware by that definition which makes malware term meaningless. > Do you really think it was a “bug” that it reinstalled itself? It is intended behaviour. And I don't see anything drastically bad with it. If you're opening their website with corresponding link, you want to use that service. In order to use that service, you have to run additional software and they are making it easier for you to run it. Only a few years ago every browser supported Java Applets and with Java Applets every website could run arbitrary code on your machine. And that feature was actually used a lot. Does it make all services which used that feature to overcome browser weaknesses malware? I don't think so. They probably should have communicated better about that aspect and provide proper uninstaller software for security-concerned users. And not making those vulnerabilities in the first place, of course. But world is not perfect.
- scarface74 7y agoFirst of all, you need a hard data that this vulnerability was exploited in the wild So would it also be okay for a credit bureau to post all of your information to a website? Would that be okay until it was “exploited in the wild”? Are you really saying it’s okay to run knowingly insecure software until there are reports of it being exploited? Only a few years ago every browser supported Java Applets and with Java Applets every website could run arbitrary code on your machine. Java applets ran in a sandbox.
- vbezhenar 7y ago> So would it also be okay for a credit bureau to post all of your information to a website? Would that be okay until it was “exploited in the wild”? I'm not saying that it's okay. I'm just saying that it's an overreaction to call their software malware. > Are you really saying it’s okay to run knowingly insecure software until there are reports of it being exploited? Yes, it's okay. When Windows security team receives some vulerability report, they do not shut down all Windows systems in the world until the bug is fixed. Those systems continue to work insecurely until they got update. > Java applets ran in a sandbox. Signed Java applets do not run in a sandbox and have full access to the computer. That's why they were widely used for things that JavaScript did not have access to, e.g. using USB secure tokens for website authentication.
- hunter2_ 7y agoThere is tons of malware that doesn't harm the user. Take crypto mining for example: it raises the temperature and the electricity bill, but those things aren't per se harmful (albeit financially). Or how about a botnet client that harms some other entity but not the user who owns the machine it's on? Or adware? The list goes on and on... calling this nefarious behavior "harm" is a huge stretch but calling it "malware" is not.
- briandear 7y agoStealing electricity is harm. It’s theft no different than if someone stole your wallet.
- oil25 7y ago> A program that surreptitiously reinstalls software when you uninstall it is by definition malware. Not quite. Malware is short for "malicious software" and malice has a specific legal definition: the intent to harm. By your standard, removing a Mac system daemon only to have it re-installed by a software update would classify the entire OS as "malware" - which is an unfair, emotionally-driven characterization.
- bin0 7y agoMicrosoft could do the same with Windows Defender with jutification, had the windows version exhibited the same malicious behavior.
- Crinus 7y agoWindows Defender wouldn't do it silently though, it would make sure you know what happened and get more information about it - even reverse its actions.