3 ms·
> So please, tell me again how AMP is "democratizing technology". Your whole rant ignored the fact that people other than Google get to use AMP pages. That's h
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
> So please, tell me again how AMP is "democratizing technology".
Your whole rant ignored the fact that people other than Google get to use AMP pages. That's how.
> So what started as a partnership between content and distribution, where everyone is happy, has degraded into the distribution channel completely owning the audience and taking every bit of control from the creators of the content.
This was always the case. AMP doesn't change the fact that the search engine's ranking determines how well the publishers do.
> users ALSO can't opt out of this - they can't even get to my site to download the game anymore even if they want to.
That's a problem with the search engine's ranker, not with AMP. If a publisher publishes separate mobile and desktop pages but cripples the mobile page in a way that makes it useless, a good search engine should prefer to show the desktop page even to mobile users. The same should happen with AMP. If the search engine doesn't rank properly, users will choose a different search engine. For example, there is a broad range of queries where I prefer AMP results because they load instantly, and I want them to appear first. If there is some feature in a web page that I want that I know won't appear in an AMP page, I will skip the AMP results, and the search engine should update its ranking model accordingly.