4 ms·
Large amounts of "hoarded" money causes a deflation, already a structural issue with a system like bitcoin, and can compound itself by reducing liquidity. In f
by gumby 7y ago
Large amounts of "hoarded" money causes a deflation, already a structural issue with a system like bitcoin, and can compound itself by reducing liquidity.
In fact that was the bigger, more dangerous consequence of the 2008 financial crisis. So when I saw opposition to the bailouts I was annoyed: not because those opponents' arguments were necessarily wrong (some were, some weren't) but because mostly even the people whose theory was correct were working about the wrong problem.
- tuesdayrain 7y ago> Large amounts of "hoarded" money causes a deflation, already a structural issue with a system like bitcoin It feels wrong to call deflation an issue with bitcoin when that is arguably the main reason anyone buys it.
- Retric 7y agoThe problem is people buy but rarely actually use bitcoin. This means the price collapses whenever a major holder tries to cash in. The basic math is you only get a net ROI across all users when someone derives some value from the act of using bitcoin. As a currency that’s either from efficient transactions or as a stable store of value. Otherwise it’s an inefficient pyramid scheme where case inflows = cash outflows - mining costs. PS: By contrast bonds can retain a high percentage of their value after a massive sale because they become more appealing as the price drops as they have some underlying value.
- Nasrudith 7y agoWell frankly that in itself should be be a huge red flag to the buyers as it doesn't add up. Everybody who does the math gives stock investors shit for doing worse than random strategy but then you see what the amateurs do when they play at "investing" (really speculation but it is considered rude to call it what it really is) like beanie babies or baseball cards. And even they are geniuses compared to those who try lotto tickets, race tracks, and slot machines.
- thinkloop 7y agoWhy is it a structural issue? Decimal places can be added if it's a question of having tradeable units, and over time avg losses will be predictable and not affect price much.
- Nasrudith 7y agoBecause the prior division means that allocation becomes increasingly disalligned with actual values. If "once accepted a pizza for bitcoin and forgot to convert it" quanities becomes worth a luxury car later no matter how much you sub divide it people are discouraged from actually using it as a currency and instead exchanging directly to avoid the future losses. Except that when everyone does that it becomes worthless because nobody is using it to exchange anything - the source of its value.
- thinkloop 7y agoPredictable and known price fluctuations are not an issue for commerce. Their effects can be reliably factored into the transaction. Only wild and unpredictable changes in price create challenges.
- sytelus 7y ago> Large amounts of "hoarded" money causes a deflation That’s interesting statement. In modern economy there is no such thing as “hoarded” money. Even if you are all cash, you have that money in bank which is landing it out and putting it to work. So I am not sure how this statement could make sense.