5 ms·
The most interesting part of this announcement, I think, is the new capabilities and restrictions they disclosed for AlphaStar. It is now playing the latest ver
by modeless 7y ago
The most interesting part of this announcement, I think, is the new capabilities and restrictions they disclosed for AlphaStar. It is now playing the latest version of the game, with all three races unrestricted, on multiple maps.
It also has much more realistic limits on its capabilities. Restricting the bot to one screen of information at a time is great. There's not much detail on the APM restrictions, but "designed with pro players" is a good sign. Hopefully they've designed some realistic restrictions more complex than just a cap on APM.
Of course the anonymous nature of the testing is interesting as well. Big contrast to OpenAI's public play test. I guess it will prevent people from learning to exploit the bot's weaknesses, as they won't know they are playing a bot at all. I hope they eventually do a public test without the anonymity so we can see how its strategies hold up under focused attack.
- vinaybn 7y agoIt'd be even more interesting to see the kind of builds and strategies it would come up with if they capped APM to average or below-average levels.
- woodgrainz 7y agoYes, totally agree. Creative Limitation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_limitation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_limitation When trying to solve problems, if you add constraints in certain areas, you can sometimes come up with really creative solutions you wouldn't have thought of before.
- drchewbacca 7y agoAPM is an interesting question I think. Like what is the relative importance of APM to strategy? If I have 20% more APM than you do I beat you even if I totally pick the wrong units and build order? Could a super smart bot win against pro's even if it's limited to 20% less APM? So yeah it might be interesting if the bot gets superhuman to trail several versions with progressively lower APM caps to see how much you have to limit it before humans can beat it again.
- KKPMW 7y agoAPM ranges change the whole game. If you have low APM - one kind of units are superior. When APM get's higher - another unit might become superior. That is also why amateur players copying pro-players can loose to a "weaker" unit combinations. Because when you do things at 50 actions per minute you will not get the advantages of certain unit types. In the context of AlphaStar it was clearly visible in its first games. The AI chose ranged units and every commentator during that game was saying that AI has an inferior army. However when within the battle its APM were allowed to reach 1000 that type of unit became the best possible unit to have.
- mipmap04 7y agoNot only unit movement (micro), but your ability to macro (manage your economy, produce new units, expand your base) will be great affected if you have low APM. In that sense, APM is very important. I'm confident I can beat any bronze league (lowest tier) player with nearly any unit composition (even when they pick a build that is a direct counter to me) simply because I will way out produce the bronze player since I'll be able to stay on top of my macro due to superior APM.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- opportune 7y ago>If I have 20% more APM than you do I beat you even if I totally pick the wrong units and build order At 20%, no. Pro players beat other pro players with 20% more apm all the time, even if they pick reasonable unit comps (this is especially common when terran players do tank focus builds against zerg). At 200%, especially if it's effective and not spamming, maybe. There are videos of bots microing marines at very high apm to beat big baneling balls, which cost much more resources and are supposed to directly counter marines. Protoss players could have perfect blink micro or immortal dropping, etc.
- ajuc 7y agoAlphastar restricted to lower average APM than MaNa beat MaNa's mass archon-immortal with mass blink stalkers :) He blinked stalkers at once from 3 sides of MaNa army (which was several-screens-wide). Such micro wouldn't be possible for a human player, because you would need to know to move the screen to see a particular stalkre just in time to blink it when he has almost 0 hitpoints, and immediately move the screen so you see another stalker on other part of the map to blink it, and so on. And the bot did this, making the strategy part of the game irrelevant (blink stalkers are supposed to lose vs immortals).
- noego 7y ago> "Restricting the bot to one screen of information at a time is great" I'm actually curious on the details of this, because it makes for a huge difference. The pro players spend most of their time looking at the mini-map, which shows you what's happening all over the map, in areas where your units/buildings have field-of-vision. You can't see exact units/buildings on the mini-map, but you can make out unit movements as well as expansions. Not giving AlphaStar access to the mini-map would be a severe handicap.
- bllguo 7y agothe minimap is always on the screen, no?
- eric-hu 7y agoThe earlier version of AlphaStar viewed the map as one giant screen. That gave it an advantage with flanking blink micro that human players couldn't reasonably do. This was with an average pro APM restriction.
- tryptophan 7y agoI'm also curious if they capped "screens per second". Humans cannot absorb all there is to see on the screen in .2 seconds and then switch to the next screen. Without such a cap, limiting the AI to "just see one screen" doesn't really do much. It would be interesting to see how the AI distributes it's views if it were capped in some significant way. Also, can the bot only issue commands on one screen at a time?