3 ms·
That's amazing and awesome. Pro-tip: do not get caught deliberately lying to judges. It makes them twitchy. The article was short, but the TL;DR is that Prenda
by kstrauser 7y ago
That's amazing and awesome. Pro-tip: do not get caught deliberately lying to judges. It makes them twitchy.
The article was short, but the TL;DR is that Prenda made porn videos, uploaded them to torrent sites, then sued everyone who downloaded them. $6M worth of defendants settled quickly because they didn't want to have "lost lawsuit from porn producer" on their records.
They set up byzantine shell companies to obfuscate that they actually owned the videos, and flat-out lied saying that they represented people other than themselves. When that came out, it also followed that it's not really possible to infringe copyright from someone who is seeding the torrent themselves, as they're literally publishing that content for anyone who asks for it.
I literally LOLed when I saw this headline. It took a while, but wow, the karma hammer hit hard today.
- wil421 7y agoSomehow I missed the part about them making their own videos until now. Which makes it that much more ridiculous.
- rolltiide 7y agoPartially explains why porn videos are so ridiculous and hilarious now, when they aren't just being demeaning. I recently found this musician who just posts youtube videos of his music, but also films himself in threesomes on pornhub. The watermarked url in the video to what one might think is a paysite just redirects to his latest youtube music video. Its fascinating how this is monetizable now, because in the past these seemed to be all separate trades that were incompatible with broader society. Makes me kind of jealous, since the point for me was to watch someone else marginalize themselves doing what I wish I could do without marginalizing myself or having any consequence really. Now it might be the move!
- pessimizer 7y agoNow that porn is free, it has to serve as an ad. You can be Mindgeek and paste ads all around it and between it, or you can innovate like this guy and use the content itself as an ad to advertise something else. There's got to be an opening[sic] for a company to market lingerie and sex toys through porn distribution. Hell, why not furniture, too? edit: honestly, with the high-end fashion photography aping of Greg Lansky product (Vixen, Blacked, Tushy) I'm surprised this isn't already a thing.
- rolltiide 7y agoThats actually not a bad idea. There are a lot of videos that try to focus on sensual side of things instead of the cheek clapping, they could easily double as furniture ads. The technology on Instagram now allows for products to be tagged in and around video. (I've seen much older startups do this and fail to gain traction) Could be added to porn sites as a different form of affiliate marketing. Let the ad track you to Facebook and around the net for more furniture or home decoration. Might be a good time to do it since other video sites like youtube are marginalizing their entire population and many people just post to porn themed sites since they don't actually care whether a video is sex related or not. They have almost no content restrictions.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoRealistically, there's so much porn online that you could post your own home made movies and no one you know would ever see them. You're a tiny drop in a massive ocean.
- djmips 7y agoUnrealistic once face recognition really takes off since your could just search for someone. In fact this has already been happening.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoSeeding your own torrents doesn't nullify your copyright on the content. Absent a license, nobody else can legally redistribute them.
- kstrauser 7y agoCan you prove that the client wasn't a leech? I mean, yeah, it is possible to do that, but I bet that this law firm specifically, using the tech of ten years ago, could not.
- jandrese 7y agoThey could run their own clients and collect a list of people seeding the video. It wouldn't be hard. A slightly smarter client could download one chunk from every client that ever connects to the torrent and log it. I don't know if they bothered, and it seems a bit of a moot point since they just lost bigtime on the whole case. This case is really incredible because you so rarely see copyright holders lose these cases. It might matter that they were a tiny asshole law firm and not a giant media cartel. The DMCA usually lets copyright holders get away with murder.
- pessimizer 7y agoNot exactly relevant, but their account (sharkmp4 on TPB) also uploaded files that they are very unlikely to have had a license to distribute (to add veracity to the entrapment), not only their films.
- egwynn 7y agoDon’t forget about the part where they didn’t pay taxes on their settlements!