4 ms·
I find it extremely disingenuous to say that because the Canadian (or British) Constitution can easily be re-interpreted in different contexts, that it will alw
by pyre 16y ago
I find it extremely disingenuous to say that because the Canadian (or British)
Constitution can easily be re-interpreted in different contexts, that it will
always be interpreted in 'the correct way.' You seem to be pointing to examples
of the US Constitution being interpreted poorly, making the implication that a
'dead tree' constitution can only be interpreted poorly, and a 'living tree'
constitution can only be interpreted in a good way.
A constitution that can be easily re-interpreted may allow for your government
to 'turn on a dime,' but it makes no claims to whether your government is
turning in a good or bad direction.
As to the US Constitution:
* The US Constitution can be re-interpreted by the US Supreme Court through the
setting of legal precedent.
* The US Constitution can be amended by Congress. (Prohibition was a
Constitutional Amendment).
* The current interpretation of the commerce clause could be overturned by the
US Supreme Court should a case come before them, and the make-up of the
justices leans towards overturning the current state of affairs.
- daxelrod 16y agoThere are other basic protections built in to attempt to prevent turning on a dime in a bad direction, as decided by the legislative and executive branches. Since the Court has no enforcement powers of their own, an unpopular turn away from the appearance of consistency could result in a toothless ruling and a constitutional crisis. Let's use your example, the Court suddenly ruling to overturn the current interpretation of the Commerce Clause. Assuming "current" means "1964 and later", this would also overturn the Civil Rights Act. The CRA was based upon the Commerce Clause, and Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States (1964) upheld its broad definition of interstate commerce [1]. I would have a hard time believing Congress would follow along with a ruling that simultaneously overturned a hugely popular law and decreased their powers. (However, I am aware that there have been a few rulings that might be counterarguments.) [1]Epstien, Walker. Constitutional Law for a Changing America: Rights, Liberties, and Justice 5th ed. Page 658.
- runningdogx 16y agoThe U.S. Constitution absolutely cannot be amended by Congress.
- pyre 16y agoAmended by Congress with the approval of the States. It's a slight difference. In the grand scheme of things like checks and balances, it matters, but in the real-world Congress is the only one that has the power to start the process. The States themselves can't float a Constitutional amendment so far as I understand it.
- gthank 16y agoIn fact they can, but it has never happened. The relevant text is here: http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html#Article5 http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html#Article5. The basic idea is that 2/3 of the state legislatures must call a Constitutional Convention, where the Amendment(s) will be proposed and sent to the states for ratification.