3 ms·
I've never been convinced of the argument that using antibiotics, causes them to be less useful. Does doubling the use frequency increase the probability of a r
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
I've never been convinced of the argument that using antibiotics, causes them to be less useful. Does doubling the use frequency increase the probability of a resistant bug? How much? And how much does that reduce the useful lifetime of the drug? I'm thinking, 10X the application might reduce the useful lifetime by months out of decades. Maybe not the issue its been blown up to be.
- tempguy9999 7y agoIt's a valid question. > I'm thinking, 10X the application might reduce the useful lifetime by months out of decades Possibly, sure. And possibly not. Maybe 1% extra use reduces the drug's working life by 100 times. Without data either claim could be true.
- JoeAltmaier 7y ago...and without data it seems clueless to be castigating folks for using the tools we have now, to accomplish goals we have now. If our current antibiotics are becoming less useful, then create new one. There's nothing magic about the ones we're using now. They were just the first ones we came across. Like VHS vs Betamax. Lets get on with it.
- tempguy9999 7y agoI castigated no-one for this. I didn't suggest not developing new antibiotics. Far from it. Merely that we use new and old ones wisely. That, and make decision based on data.
- BurningFrog 7y agoDo you have an argument for this, or is it just gut feel? The argument for the standard view is simple: The more "bugs" are exposed to antibiotics, the more opportunity/reason they have to develop resistance to it.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBut its a multivariate problem space. Exposure is just one of the variables. Others (mutation rate, types of host, cross-infection rate etc) are also important and highly non-linear. It's a big-data problem - what are the regression stats for each independent variable? And is 'exposure' the important one?