7 ms·
Honest question: aren't radio waves "physical objects" that represent oscillations of an electro-magnetic field, to the best of our current understanding?
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Honest question: aren't radio waves "physical objects" that represent oscillations of an electro-magnetic field, to the best of our current understanding?
- dschuetz 7y agoThere is an agreement in physics that low energy EM fields are called waves, such as radio waves, and high energy EM fields are called photons or even particles. In any case they are actually both. If they are physical objects I don't know. I think, I wouldn't go that far.
- 100ideas 7y agoLet’s talk virtual particles...
- danbruc 7y agoThey are also just in the models and heads of physicists.
- tsimionescu 7y agoSure, they are both, but my point was - if they have wave-like characteristics, they must be a wave of/in something; if we can have experimental evidence that the wave exists, I would consider that experimental evidence that the field the wave is a wave of must also exist, to the same extent.
- danbruc 7y agoRadio waves are streams of photons, the fields are just a mathematical tool we use to describe this. And there are several of them, the classical electromagnetic field but also an entire set of fields involved in the quantum version.
- kgwgk 7y agoOther people may say that photons are just mathematical tools that we use to describe fields. :-)
- danbruc 7y agoThe fact that gauge fields have redundant degrees of freedom should at least be a strong hint that the fields are not the fundamental description. ;)
- carlob 7y agoI don't think you are correct: you can view the extra degrees of freedom as just a symmetry
- danbruc 7y agoIt is usually called a gauge symmetry but it is kind of a misnomer and should better be called a gauge redundancy. It is artifical and only due to the mathematical formalism we are using. As an analogy, probably not a really good one, is that you could decide to describe temperatures with a complex number and just say temperature is invariant under translation along the imaginary axis. Sure, the symmetry is in your mathematics but it doesn't really tell you anything new or interesting. Besides of course that the imaginary part is actually redundant and you better described temperature with a real number instead.
- mokus 7y agoThat would not work in the same way as a typical gauge theory though - typically the symmetry of a gauge is for shifts of the entire system along the gauge - changes along the gauge locally do have physical meaning. For example, in an electrical diagram you can arbitrarily shift every voltage in the system by a billion Volts (ground rail is 1b Volts, 5V rail is 1b+5V, etc) and the system will behave identically. The gauge quantity is real and not redundant, it’s just that it doesn’t have a known meaningful absolute reference point.