6 ms·
Helper agents are dark patterns. Unless installing an always running service on my device is directly related to the intended functionality of your software, s
by colechristensen 7y ago
Helper agents are dark patterns.
Unless installing an always running service on my device is directly related to the intended functionality of your software, setting one up is unwelcome and deceptive. Especially when it is done to work around existing security controls.
- larrysalibra 7y agoAbsolutely. If the user indicates they don't want your software running anymore, it should stop. In Zoom's case, if the user exits the app, the web server keeps running. When the user uninstalled the app, the web server still keeps running. The user twice said "I don't want Zoom's software running on my computer and both times Zoom ignored the user's request. This behavior is both unethical AND malicious. Edit: wrote up more thoughts on this: https://salibra.com/p/viral-growth-doesnt-mean-writing-viruses-ed29689b94d6 https://salibra.com/p/viral-growth-doesnt-mean-writing-virus...
- colechristensen 7y agoI don't want the web server running when Zoom is running either. Video conferencing has nothing to do with a web server or any server listening to ports. When I install a video conferencing client its only function should be me initiating a connection.
- o-__-o 7y agoThen why don’t you switch to webex?
- colechristensen 7y agoI have never been in the position to choose other than voicing my opinion, all video conferencing sucks for some reason or another, and it has never been anywhere near the most important thing.
- xref 7y agoThat’s the meat of it, Zoom wanted an app feature macOS said was a no-no so they coded up an insecure workaround. On iOS that would get your app pulled at the least.
- colechristensen 7y agoI want an operating system with a permissions model which specifically forbids this kind of thing. My Linux desktops are also always full of processes which I have to dig to figure the purpose, unless I build my own distribution it's hard to make anything work which feels satisfactorily under control.
- dannyw 7y agoSo how does your OS differenate between Apache and a local helper?
- o-__-o 7y agoWell windows pops open a huge GD window that allows you to decide firewall rules if it notices a change
- colechristensen 7y agoNon-OS provided applications are installed as packages and given package-level permissions which are easily audited and revokable (without forcing uninstall). Apache has permission to start at boot, run in the background, and listen to 0.0.0.0:80,443. Photoshop has permission to write to files in $HOME, and connect to network services while the application is running optionally with explicit permissions for each access. Adobe's update service can be disabled with a click.
- vinay_ys 7y agoI disagree with declaring all helper agents as dark patterns. From a regular user point of view, it would be acceptable to have a helper agent as long as it follows: - platform provided background process methodology (example: launchd could launch your process when you hit the socket), - and it is made clearly apparent that such a thing is installed on your system (say, via system preferences panel, via status bar icon menu, and via in-app preferences panel), - and it does cleanly uninstall as part of a simple standard regular uninstall. And from a technical/security point of view, it would be acceptable if it: - has minimal necessary privileges and proper separation of concerns. - and does only what it needs to provide a user-expected functionality and doesn't do random egregious things. - has secure ways to allow only expected/authorized caller to talk to it. - does not violate any platform guidelines or tries to circumvent protections.
- colechristensen 7y agoBut for what? My caveat is that a helper service is acceptable when it is doing something necessary for the basic function of the software. Virus scanners, file sync, and things which are obviously servers fit the bill. Not much else I can think of does.
- o-__-o 7y agoLibreoffice has an agent that preloads java bins to make the startup time comparable to MS Office. There are valid uses for startup agents, please get over yourself
- colechristensen 7y agoI don't want that. I don't want installing an office suite to permanently take away a percentage of my computer's resources.
- LaGrange 7y ago> From a regular user point of view, it would be acceptable It would be not, stop pretending acquiring consent from a statistical model counts as acquiring consent from the actual user. Thing you wrote may make it acceptable for you, but certainly ain't sufficient for me.
- supernes 7y agoHelper agents are an integral part of said security controls, e.g. for XPC, privilege separation, etc.