8 ms·
Self-destructing mosquitoes and sterilized rodents: the promise of gene drives
- sadmann1 7y agoAnd of course the elephant in the room, the sterilization of undesirables as decided by the powers that be. Imagine using all that 23andme data to target certain genotypes with diseases.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoAnd of course the highest priority diseases will be those more common in the demographics of the political out-group and/or the marginalized.
- ailideex 7y agoWhat room are you in? Because I'm not in any room where that is even close to be a thing.
- wil421 7y agoSounds like the underlying plot to X Files.
- Nasrudith 7y agoWhile a popular science fiction trope that would be a terrible idea on so many levels even skipping the futilely of racism. Forget even the propagation issues involved with biological weapons. Forget that the - what they consider "race" and genetics don't line up as it is more about their ego than any actual genetics. If they are capable of that sort of meddling by definition would be reversible already.
- lm28469 7y agoFirst they came for the mosquitoes, and I did not speak out because I was not a mosquito. Then they came for the rodents, and I did not speak out because I was not a rodent. ... Then they came for the me. I wouldn't be surprised if our gene editing ego trip blows back. Playing god with things we barely understand the impact of.
- nosianu 7y ago> Playing god with things we barely understand the impact of. Doesn't matter - god doesn't either. That's why it is running this experiment :-) Seriously, since when did anyone ever understood the impact of anything? What the long-term impact of any new development or invention would be? Apart from running the experiment. Unless it is something very specific I don't see how this ever is a valid argument. Had we stayed in the trees we would have to deal with other issues and felt no better.
- coldtea 7y ago>Seriously, since when did anyone ever understood the impact of anything? When the impact was low and localized, and the methods to affect change crude. I.e. for the most part of human history. Now we have surgical methods to edit genes etc, but combined with the knowledge and understanding of a Wild West quack doctor (and their profit motive).
- nosianu 7y agoIt never was, with increasing numbers of humans. Things like agriculture and animal husbandry were spread together with the population across vast distances and changed the landscape, the flora and the fauna. > Now we have surgical methods to edit genes etc I refer back to the comment you replied to... in any case., I don't see how understanding is the main point. We actually understand quite a bit, far more important are the incentive systems that often force us to do stuff against what we actually know. I'm pretty sure companies in the past and present that used landscape (rivers etc.) as garbage dumps knew that that wasn't good, so understanding does not seem to help nearly as much as some think.
- coldtea 7y agoThe "vast distances" were just some places humans could establish cities. 90% of the planet country was untouched for the better part of history, or had very minor alterations (a village and some crops in an area of 100s of square kilometers). Heck, most of the "most advanced" populations didn't even know about other huge continents (Australia, Asia, Americas). Today a modified plant or insect can travel all over the globe, take plane rides, and so on...
- coldtea 7y agoFood shortages, ecosystem mayhem, huge disease toll: the promise of gene drives from an improvising rush-it-for-profit "science" that still e.g. can't eradicate the common cold and misses tons of basics (until recently they thought "junk dna" was useless) but is confident to play the sorcerer's apprentice...
- nosianu 7y agoI'm not sure you want to eradicate the common cold. I myself had had mercury poisoning (I wrote about that in other posts, treated with chelators with great positive effect). I noticed A) that the numbers of colds I had and their severity and duration are greatly reduced down to almost nothing. It was that just before I was diagnosed I was afraid of catching a cold in fall/winter because it would stay with me until May without ever going away. During the recovery and treatment I noticed that every time I had a cold there was especially great activity exactly in the places where I had the most issues (in non-cold times), and that when it was gone I felt a lot better than before. I came to suspect, and now firmly believe after having gone through this a few times, that the colds helped the healing (and getting out whatever needed to get out). I think there are other indications as well that mild disease like the cold has beneficial impacts(?). What if you eradicate a really mild inconvenience only to find out that that was actually a bad idea?
- coldtea 7y ago>What if you eradicate a really mild inconvenience only to find out that that was actually a bad idea? By "eradicate" in my argument one could easily substitute "understand the common cold". My argument was basically about control and understanding -- I mentioned "have not yet eradicated the common cold" as a proxy for "doesn't yet even understand and control something so commonly occurring and heavily studied as that" (including not knowing whether eradicating it is good or not).
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> improvising rush-it-for-profit "science" that still e.g. can't eradicate the common cold and misses tons of basics (until recently they thought "junk dna" was useless) but is confident to play the sorcerer's apprentice Do you seriously believe that? Do you completely ignore all the things the 'rush-it-for-profit "science"' done right in the past centuries, and the benefits you personally derive from that? It's like saying that progress is bullshit because we still don't have hoverboards[0]. It turns out that some of the things we can easily conceptualize are hard, whereas some not immediately obvious things are easy, both in engineering and science. -- [0] - the real kind, not the name-appropriating Li-Ion fire starters on two wheels.
- jddj 7y agoThere are a lot of comments here declaring various versions of "slippery slope!". Looking at history, one would have to conclude that employing science-based methods to improve the natural environment by reversing problems which we have unintelligently created in the past (mosquitoes, rodents, antibiotic resistant bacteria, etc) through our own carelessness isn't necessarily directly linked by a slippery slope to something like eugenics or ecosystem collapse. We have the potential to do good as well as evil, even capable of implementing laws and international treaties which (for example) prohibit CRISPRing embryos. Many ideas are worthy of at least being assessed on their merits and not being discarded purely because they belong to a certain class. If there is a genuine slippery slope (which is somewhat ironically claimed with some measure of certainty in the same breath that says we're incapable of foreseeing consequences), but the idea is good, perhaps we could leverage our legal frameworks and social structures to limit that. It seems crazy that we should be expected to accept the consequences of any negative effects which we have had on the planet to date through our carelessness because approaching them with a scientific method and anything but the crudest tools (pesticides, etc) is labelled "playing god" and totally off limits.
- ses1984 7y agoWhoa whoa whoa, how did we create or contribute to the mosquito problem?
- brohee 7y agoCreating predator free breeding environments for them (any place that can hold stagnant water in an urban environment). And feeding them (by being there).
- xoa 7y agoOf the ~100 genus (around 3500 species) of mosquitos, only a fraction bite humans and only 3 genus are responsible for most disease spread: Aedes mosquitoes (yellow fever, dengue, and encephalitis), Anopheles mosquitoes (malaria, filariasis, elephantiasis), and Culex mosquitoes (encephalitis, filariasis, West Nile virus). All of these are invasive species to much of the world, they're only there because they were brought in by humans in the first place just like other invasives, and often fairly recently. Their spread has been further heavily facilitated by human altered environments, not just in the big picture like global warming but also more standing water, disruption of predators, and so on. And the death toll is actually quite remarkable, around 700,000 people a year die directly due to mosquito transmitted diseases.
- nisten 7y agoAt this point it's nearly becoming unethical not to use a gene drive. Warming climate is spreading more and more diseases via insects. West nile, malaria, zika, chagas, lyme are all very much alive and kicking with no quick effective cure or management method in sight. It's already ruined outdoor camping for example, I would not want my family members to be at risk of an infected tick bite, and the problem is getting worse every year. Lyme disease would mean a lifetime of medication and discomfort. By not using a gene drive and just arguing on the hypothetical dangers of it, we are letting more and more people suffer and inevitably use much harsher chemical methods to manage the problem.
- est31 7y agoYou mean warming climate is bringing diseases that were plaguing humans since centuries to the place you live and now it's suddenly a problem because it could affect you, too. The west where most of medical research is located hasn't been caring about these diseases for a long time, that's where the neglected in "neglected tropical diseases" comes from. It's really sad that solutions are only being figured out once the west is affected as well, but I guess it's better than not figuring out solutions at all.
- jddj 7y agoThis projection of what OP meant doesn't speak to the reality. Malaria was an issue in the US [1] and southern Europe [2] prior to the 1940s, and Australia has always had and continues to have issues with the Dengue and Ross River viruses. If the claim is instead that CRISPR was sitting there waiting to be implemented for decades, if only some rich people could finally see a use for it in the face of global warming, a charitable take on that idea would be to call it far-fetched. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/malaria/about/history/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/malaria/about/history/index.html [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC547919/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC547919/
- est31 7y agoThere are possibly many remedies against NTDs, without needing any gene drives or CRISPR or anything. We don't know because we haven't tried. Sure, to some degree you can blame developing contries for e.g. not deploying rabies prevention well enough (which were deployed in the west decades ago, making rabies in the west irrelevant while it still persists in developing nations), but mostly it's the west's fault for not researching cures.
- thrownaway954 7y agoSomeone mark this comment so that when I'm gone, in 20 years, you can look back I know that I called it... 5 years after this is implemented you will have these genes passed over to humans. people will start to become sterilized and dropping dead in the streets. watch... seems like whatever we do to another species comes back on us 5 fold.
- FerretFred 7y ago> self-destructing mosquito The mind boggles at what that might look like, but if the mosquito is just going to disappear, that will negatively impact on a whole host of other species. https://www.orkin.com/other/mosquitoes/mosquito-predators https://www.orkin.com/other/mosquitoes/mosquito-predators
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoMy understanding is that, while many species will happily eat mosquitoes, there's no species where mosquitoes are their primary food source. That doesn't mean that eliminating mosquitoes would be consequence-free, of course. It could definitely cause problems for the species who lose a part of their diet, and/or the other prey they eat more of to compensate. But they're not a keystone of the ecosystem like, say, bees are. Also, apparently all of the really dangerous, disease-carrying mosquitoes are invasive.
- godelski 7y agoThe other question is: those predators that (might) actually depend on mosquito, do they depend on the ones were talking about eradicating (which is only a small subset)?
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoAlso true. I'm not sure.
- pvaldes 7y agoThe only valuable reason for having a few sterilized rodents would be to grab and monopolize the laboratory rat/mice market. Rodents have short lives and there is an unlimited supply of wild specimens in the nature.
- cf141q5325 7y agoI know its a joke, but you are never testing stuff on wild specimens. Labrats are standardized inbred strains like BALB/c. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BALB/c https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BALB/c
- alltakendamned 7y agoLook, I hate mosquitos with a vengeance, I'm quite allergic to them and each bite results in multiple days to weeks of misery. That said, I remain very skeptical of this approach as other species are dependent on these little nasty ones, and I don't believe we have a good grasp on what the second-order effects will be when we start eradicating species with such a large presence.
- vikramkr 7y agoOne could argue that the ecological impacts are worth it to eradicate malaria. We've done worse for less gain
- godelski 7y agoThey're really only talking about eradicating the mosquitoes that bite humans. Which is an extremely small subset. There's a comment further up that has more detail.
- keiru 7y ago>Will X even work? Why is this so often a question for things that are clearly possible? If this or that particular method doesn't work, well, ok, but I'd find it hard to believe that never in history would people be able to spread genes through a population. Computer viruses, cloning, facial recognition, atomic bombs, genetic engineering, cryptocurrencies. These are things there were weakly (or un-) regulated until they came into existence. Now, you might ask yourself if jetpacks might be a socially viable for of mass-transportation, not if they are technically possible. Years are wasted asking if something is possible before preparing for it, and precautions and regulations are created post-hoc by lawmakers for stuff that was sure to come. Does anybody know of a good "turned out to be impossible" situation?