3 ms·
If you lived on Long Island, and didn't know where humans came from, but you knew about how big the earth was, would it be rational or in accordance with Occam'
by perl4ever 7y ago
If you lived on Long Island, and didn't know where humans came from, but you knew about how big the earth was, would it be rational or in accordance with Occam's razor to assume homo sapiens originated in your vicinity? Most people would in fact be wrong if they even assumed humans originated on their continent.
I feel like people get sidetracked into talking about evidence, when the issue is that life originating on Earth should not be the default assumption. I feel like someone more lucid than me could make a good Bayesian sort of argument.
- Avshalom 7y agoIt's not exactly the default assumption though. Historically the default is that life was magicked into existence or came here from a previous world or some other creation story. The current abiogenisis story of molecules->proteins->cells->Life is relatively recent. The other thing is that because we have a fairly... ?linear record of evolution: if life did originate somewhere else it got to Earth in something like prokaryotic single cell form 3.5 billion years ago. Which means we can't use the idea of panspermia to tell us anything. It's neither predictive or explanatory. It tells us nothing of how or where life did originate or how life got started on Earth or what or where we should look for or expect in the rest of the Universe. The current theory suggests life could pop up extremely quickly, which itself already implies life is likely to exist in the rest of universe on some level so panspermia doesn't even mean anything with regards to how likely life is anywhere else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BoiledCabbage 7y agoThe difference is that you've never seen evidence of humans living anywhere outside of Long Island. Clearly if you see humans living all over the globe they almost certainly originated elsewhere. But if humans only live on LI, then it's reasonable to conclude they originated on LI.