3 ms·
> Forecasting is definitely pseudoscience, but EM-related precursors are a fairly hot (and controversial) research topic at the moment. It's not pseudoscience
by bsder 7y ago
> Forecasting is definitely pseudoscience, but EM-related precursors are a fairly hot (and controversial) research topic at the moment.
It's not pseudoscience because it can be disproven--which is generally what happens.
The issue that everybody forgets is that predictions have FOUR outcomes, not two.
You have the one everybody remembers: "I predicted X and X happened".
You have the one some people remember: "I didn't predict X and X didn't happen."
You have the one that people rarely remember: "I predicted X and X didn't happen."
You have the one nobody remembers: "I didn't predict X, but X happened."
The problem is that for rare events, the "predict X and not X" and "didn't predict X but X" have to be REALLY low probability for a measure to be useful.
- gpm 7y agoDidn't predict X but X can be high probability and it still be a useful predictor. Reporting even 10% of earthquakes hours in advance would be useful. Predict X and not X is a huge issue though, as you suggest.