4 ms·
What if someone's holy book contains text that dehumanizes people on the basis of religion?
by whatshisface 7y ago
What if someone's holy book contains text that dehumanizes people on the basis of religion?
- jngreenlee 7y agoSorry but if you're not a member of the tribe, you can't possibly interpret the tribe's book. (said in jest to point out the problematic response)
- dragonwriter 7y ago> What if someone's holy book contains text that dehumanizes people on the basis of religion? Then they probably aren't allowed to tweet their holy book.
- sverhagen 7y agoWhat if, as part of a developing story, a journalist quotes a government official making such statements?
- dragonwriter 7y agoIs it dehumanizing to report that someone else made a dehumanizing statement without endorsing the statement? I don't think so. You are essentially asking “will Twitter make use/mention distinctions in enforcing this policy”. While it is of course impossible to state for certain in advance, I don't see any particular reason to believe they would either be disinclined to or incapable of doing so.
- iamnothere 7y agoMy guess is it will depend on whether or not the journalist is considered part of the mainstream media.
- goto11 7y agoI guess you can't post those quotes on twitter then.
- rsj_hn 7y agoBingo. In that case you have to pick a winner and loser. Then you suppress the loser and promote the winner. Which is the whole point. These issues of free speech have been around for a very long time, especially with regards to religious speech, which is at the bedrock of free speech, and the Western liberal tradition espouses free speech principles not because it didn't realize someone might get offended, but because it's better than the option of having powerful people/institutions pick winners and losers and decide what is acceptable to say. Under current rules, if enforced across the board, a modern Martin Luther's 95 tweet stream would be banned because it hurt someone's feelings or criticized their religion. Exposes of Jehovah's Witnesses would be banned. Atheist tracts would be banned. The whole system is unworkable, which is why it wont work -- it wont be enforced across the board. What will happen is that Twitter will adopt de-facto 'protected religions' that cannot be criticized -- say Islam -- and then it will pick the losers -- say Christianity.
- rubidium 7y agoNo. It's only if it dehumanizes the other. Criticism of the thoughts, ideas, practices are perfectly fine. Dehumanizing the practicers of any particular religion is what's not fine. You're over-reacting to what the linked post from twitter actually says.
- rsj_hn 7y agoDefine "de-humanizing". If you look at how previous twitter anti-dehumanizing policies were enforced, this was used to ban NPC memes -- which were not memes against a person but against ideas. It was used to ban people who said things like "men can't get pregnant" -- which is an idea/belief.
- jbattle 7y agoI really can't follow you. I spent a few minutes googling and it looks like 1) Twitter punishes 'dehumanizing tweets' 2) One author on kotaku argued that the NPC meme could be considered 'dehumanizing' 3 ???
- throwaway98434 7y agoCriticizing a religion is not the same thing as dehumanizing its followers. Dehumanization is a defense mechanism which helps us avoid feeling the pain of realizing that humans sometimes do (subjectively) abhorrent things. It's seductive to define such people outside the bounds of humanity as it allows us to excuse treating them poorly. It is nearly always a mistake to do so, because people are, in fact, people.
- elliekelly 7y agoThis is the important point everyone seems to be missing. If you look at the example tweets they all have some aspect of making the [Religious Group] out to be less than human: rats, virus, maggots, etc. People can still freely express their distaste for any and all religion on twitter so long as they don’t dehumanize the people who follow that religion.
- loudtieblahblah 7y agoApplication will be different from stated intent. How much you want to bet ? haven't we all seen this in practice long enough now to know how this little routine goes?
- elliekelly 7y agoThis kind of attitude with respect to rules and regulations drives me nuts. Guess what? Every time you have a human applying a rule you’re going to get results that aren’t entirely consistent. Have you ever managed a team and given the exact same task with the exact same instructions to two people? Did you get the exact same work product in return? I very much doubt it. Rules & regulations should be written, evaluated, and revised the same way code is. Code doesn’t always run as we intended but we (usually) don’t crucify the developer. We learn from the misunderstanding, fix it, and then re-evaluate when the next inevitable misunderstanding comes up. We get feedback and we iterate. That’s exactly what Twitter is doing. Their first policy didn’t work out as planned and this is their next iteration based on the feedback they received on policy v1.0.0 And will Twitter update this policy yet again once they’ve had time to work out some of the kinks? You can bet on it.