4 ms·
Controversial hack to effect change in US Copyright system
Hey Hacker News.
I guess I often think like a hacker or a mathematician, in that I consider the simple component parts, and imagine them in different combinations, and try to extract general principles of things.
Something about copyright has always seemed very anachronistic to me. I mean, I know it's the law, and yet it's so hard to enforce, ever since the means of copying has become electronic.
In fact, a monopoly over intellectual property seems somehow inherently wrong to me. Never mind the fact that long-lived software patents are harmful in such a fast-moving industry, or that worked composed after 1930 will likely never enter the public domain, thanks to lobbying of the Congress every few years by special interests to extend the term of copyright. Never mind the efforts by the RIAA that bear a resemblance to extortion. The very principle that someone should have absolute say over who in the world can make a copy or derivative work of something they have released, seems to be flawed. If you don't think so, read on.
Certainly changing the situation by argument is not going to be easy. Lots of people may argue one way or the other, but policy is usually decided when issues come to a head.
I am considering doing an extremely controversial hack in order to highlight the problems with the copyright system. From what I know, the hack is completely legal, because of the very law that is in place. It can generate a lot of money for anyone who reads this and decides to do it, and at the same time if enough people do it, it will gain media attention and lawmakers will have to rethink copyright policy. But at the same time I AM NOT RECOMMENDING IT TO ANYONE because I am not a lawyer. Check with your lawyer before attempting this. I am just thinking out loud at this point and this is not legal advice or encouragement to action :)
Here is the hack:
A pyramid scheme is illegal, because it exists solely to make money from new people signing up. A multi-level marketing scheme on the other hand is legal, and the major difference is: there is a product, and the focus is on selling the product, not on signing people up.
Well, you say, why not turn a pyramid scheme into a multi-level marketing scheme by simply selling "air" as the product? Well, the product has to be something that people want. Enter... COPYRIGHT.
1) Make a copyrighted work of actual value. Say, a computer program, a recipe, an e-book, or just a nice painting.
2) Sell copyright licenses in the following way: if any person buys ONE copy of your work, they then can get commissions if they refer buyers to you. That is the ONLY way to become an affiliate.
3) Any affiliate can get commissions up to, say, 4 levels deep for copies their buyers helped sell to others, etc.
Remember, due to copyright law, you have absolute say as to who has a license to copy the book and who hasn't. You simply set the rules to make it a multi-level marketing scheme.
Except what is the difference between this and a pyramid scheme? How much does it cost to copy the book? Practically ZERO. Unlike Amway, Mary Kay, Herbalife and other companies that have done MLM with actual products, this has almost ZERO transactional cost and negligible cost per item sold, and the marketing is viral. The copyright law currently applies equally to electronic copies that cost $0 to produce and tangible physical copies.
The economics of this MLM scheme are exactly the same as a pyramid scheme. If someone challenges the legality of this, you just point them here: http://www.copyright.gov/title17/ and explain that you as the copyright owner are the sole arbiter of who can sell your copyrighted work and how, and you are at liberty to compensate whomever you wish for selling your work with a commission.
I AM NOT A LAWYER. PLEASE CHECK WITH A LAWYER BEFORE DOING THIS. But it seems to me that selling copyrighted works this way is completely legal. But should it be legal to make what is effectively a pyramid scheme? If not, then perhaps the very principles of copyright today needs to be rethought. And the hackers can trigger it.
Anyway, just a thought.
(Copyright 2010)
- absconditus 16y agoI do not think that this scheme would be effective toward your goal and it may be illegal, but I am interested in the discussion that it might incite.
- philipkimmey 16y agoAn interesting idea in theory, but I'm pretty sure this has been addressed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine
- EGreg 16y agoSure, that is fine. You can give away your copy to someone else. However no one who did not buy the book directly from me can become an affiliate. The system still works like an MLM scheme with a $0 cost per item.
- itsnotvalid 16y agoHowever this only apply unto the a copyrighted work without explicit license. By only allowing the use of the copyrighted work with a explicit license that prohibits this, you can cancel out this effect (which is what EULA is for) I AM NOT A LAWYER. PLEASE CHECK WITH A LAWYER BEFORE DOING THIS.
- EGreg 16y agoThe point of this hack is to prompt a rethinking of the copyright law, by testing what happens when it is used to create an MLM scheme that has all the economics of a pyramid scheme: You simply make an ebook, sell it, have an affiliate program whose only condition is to buy the book, and make it a multi-level affiliate program. Here is the question: is the proposed scheme LEGAL (as I believe it is) because of the law's current thinking about copyright licensing, or is it ILLEGAL, because its economics are exactly the same as those of a pyramid scheme (minus the initial cost of making the copyrighted work), and thus may have the same undesirable consequences? And if it should be illegal, then let's trace it back to WHY copyright enables it to be legal.
- iwwr 16y agoThere are already such schemes in place. They sell a booklet called something like "How to make a lot of money" for $500 and then if you get enough stupid people to buy the book, you're in the money. If everyone below you thinks the same, you make more money. The people at the top end up realizing "the dream".