4 ms·
IBM now has control over systemd, and as other users here point out, also pulseaudio, dbus, gnome, wayland, and a significant share of kernel. IMHO this is a g
by einpoklum 7y ago
IBM now has control over systemd, and as other users here point out, also pulseaudio, dbus, gnome, wayland, and a significant share of kernel.
IMHO this is a good time for the Debian project to reconsider the decision to rely on systemd. If you also think so, consider letting them know.
- _delirium 7y agoIs there really any likelihood of that happening? If Torvalds got cold feet about systemd and started making it less integral to the upstream kernel (or at least more walled off as an optional subsystem), there's a chance Debian would take that as an opening to move in a non-systemd direction. But as long as the upstream kernel imports more and more systemd-related stuff and treats it as the default/expected configuration, and then things like desktop environments follow suit and depend on it, Debian would need to maintain what amounts more and more to its own fork of the rest of the Linux world to do otherwise. When this was last discussed, most Debian developers didn't think it had the dev resources to do that.
- bonzini 7y agoThat makes no sense. As long as Linux is concerned, systemd is totally irrelevant: it is not "integrated" in the kernel in any way and cannot even be considered a subsystem.
- PlutoIsAPlanet 7y agoDon't be stupid and hysterical, no one wants to use the joke of an OS called Devuan. systemd is an open source project and it isn't just Red Hat that work on it.
- dang 7y agoComments like your first sentence here (and also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20381009 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20381009) are bannable offences on HN. Would you mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the spirit of this site to heart when posting here? We'd be grateful.
- hansendc 7y agoIf you think employing open-source maintainers gives a company "control" over a project, you haven't met many maintainers. In any case, IBM is very respectful of the health of the open source projects on which it depends. While the vestiges of Red Hat may become less and less attractive as a place for a maintainer to work over time, I do not expect IBM to exert any control over any of these projects in any meaningful way any more than it has over the areas that its current employees maintain. Look at SCSI in the kernel, or even RCU, both maintained by IBMers (two examples among many). (I worked at IBM in its Linux Technology Center for over a decade)
- LeoPanthera 7y agoAren't all those things GPL? Can they not be forked in the case of a sudden change of direction that Debian, or anyone else disagrees with? What do you mean by "control"?
- NikkiA 7y agoredhat holds most of the expertise on those projects, so forking them, while possible, would be hard. Debian and Canonical would probably have an easier time developing something from their own expertise rather than relying on a 'once things get bad' fork. Forks historically only really work if the fork comes from within.