7 ms·
The claim is that G2A acts as the equivalent of a fence. Let me explain. Many crooks want money. A lot of illegal activities generate what looks like value but
by tialaramex 7y ago
The claim is that G2A acts as the equivalent of a fence.
Let me explain. Many crooks want money. A lot of illegal activities generate what looks like value but it's hard to turn into money and unless you do it's useless. A stolen television is valuable but why would I pay 60% of retail price to some geezer in a lock-up at 2am for what is obviously a stolen TV? The Fence buys stolen things from crooks for a fraction of their value, then operates a seemingly legitimate business which sells those things to ordinary punters to collect the difference.
Being a Fence is a crime. "Receiving stolen goods" we call it in most places. You're guilty if you know or should reasonably have known that the goods you got were stolen.
The argument against G2A is that logically the stuff they're buying for cheap can only exist if it's being obtained by crooks. A week after a game is released for $25 the _only_ reason somebody wants to sell 100 codes for $5 each is that they used stolen credentials to get those codes and are cashing out.
- buildzr 7y agoMany of those codes are readily available via legitimate means - indie games often get published in bundles and the codes get resold, GPU makers and developers often do giveaways with free game keys, etc. There are many cases in which the keys are obtained in perfectly legitimate ways. I mean, it seems like they are removing games purchased fraudulently, Steam notifies you when one of your games is removed for this reason, yet despite many G2A purchases I'm yet to have a game removed, is there any evidence that this is actually as rampant as is claimed?
- eridius 7y agoReselling keys from bundles is also a problem. I don't have a link handy but I was reading just the other day some indie developer complaining that they're seeing more keys from Humble Bundle being redeemed many months after the bundle that had them than actual sales on Steam, and they claimed G2A was the cause (being a means by which people could sell their old bundle keys that they didn't want). More specifically, they said this practice serves as a very strong discouragement from indie games ever participating in bundles again, because the bundle economics depend on many (most?) of the keys either not being redeemed, or being redeemed by people who would otherwise not purchase the actual game. But when people who want the game are able, many months later, to pay a fraction of the price for a key sourced from a bundle, this really hurts sales for the game and makes the bundle a net negative instead of the positive it's supposed to be.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> this practice serves as a very strong discouragement from indie games ever participating in bundles again, because the bundle economics depend on many (most?) of the keys either not being redeemed This isn't exactly a compelling argument in favor of having the bundles around.
- eridius 7y agoWhat do you mean? Bundle terms usually forbid redeeming of the keys by anyone other than the bundle purchaser, but that generally can't actually be tracked (I know Humble Bundle always tells me that the steam keys should only ever be redeemed by me, but ultimately they're just keys with no technical means of enforcing that restriction). The fact that people are breaking these terms and selling the keys doesn't mean the concept of bundles is flawed. In the absence of marketplaces like G2A key reselling isn't a big deal because you really need the marketplace to find someone else who's willing to pay for it.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThe fact that people are breaking the terms of sale doesn't necessarily mean the concept of bundles is flawed. The fact that the economic viability of bundles depends on the bundled products being purchased almost exclusively by people who don't want them does indicate that the concept is flawed.
- mattmanser 7y agoNot at all, I have bought a few bundles, I've no interest in playing all the games, just a subset of them. That subset is going to be different for most purchasers.
- eridius 7y agoI'm not talking about like "buy Awesome FPS 2, get Awesome FPS 1 in a bundle for $1 more", I'm talking about bundles that collect a bunch of disparate games. People buy these bundles because they only want a few of the games. And then companies like Humble Bundle sell bundles where you don't even know what they contain until you buy them, so it's entirely possible to buy a bundle where you end up not playing any of the games in the bundle.
- fiblye 7y agoA lot of those game bundles intentionally underpromote the bundles so that they get maybe 100 sales, then they resell the keys for higher margins with no cash going to the dev. If a bundle company asks for 10000 keys and their bundles are clearly only selling 200 units each, their bundles are just a front for the real money. Legit operations return all unused keys. Dirty operations (the vast majority of bundles) will block your emails the minute you mention returning keys.
- lonelappde 7y agoWhy do devs do business with a huge number of fly by night minor bundlers with no reputation?
- fiblye 7y agoBecause a lot of them have reputations for having released successful bundles in the past. That's precisely why you shouldn't trust them. :)
- lonelappde 7y agoI'm afraid to say it, but would blockchain tech improve provenance tracking of these codes and reduce fencing?
- smsm42 7y agoBut unlike stealing the TV, if somebody stole a bunch of codes, isn't it the same as pirating the game? However the devs claim it's actually worse than pirating - it actually costs them more when codes are resold. Why? Where the additional cost is coming from?
- baddox 7y agoI'm sure there is at least some time costs dealing with fraud claims or chargebacks from their payment processor.
- cas8 7y agoIf I use a stolen credit card to buy a code for your game, eventually there is likely to be a chargeback/refund processed when the credit card owner/company realizes that it was fraudulent. Chargebacks/refunds can sometimes be things that have real penalties associated with them and that can require time investment from you the developer to deal with. Another, less concrete cost is that of incentivizing bad behavior. If I cannot sufficiently move a certain type of stolen goods, I'm less likely to attempt to steal that type of good again in the future. However, if people choose to pirate a game instead, the bad actor is not rewarded and might realize that he can no longer move that type of product.
- smsm42 7y agoYeah true but the problem with chargeback happens regardless of whether somebody bought the codes or not - unless they bought the codes with stolen credit card, and then the store selling it, not the developer, gets the chargeback. So I don't think this scenario applies here. Developers usually have publishers to deal with things like credit card charges.
- Tyr42 7y agoBut paying the people who steal the cards can only encourage them.
- Jnr 7y agoProbably because banks will do chargebacks for those stolen credit card purchases and developers will have to deal with that. Many years ago I experienced something like that with Paypal where someone bought a license for my software and then immediately made a chargeback claim. And on Paypal unless it is a physical delivery with a tracking number, buyer always wins. I lost some time while communicating with Paypal about the chargeback.