3 ms·
The really concerning part is that legislation of this nature often receives bipartisan support in the Australian parliament. I don't recall if it was this bill
by roenxi 7y ago
The really concerning part is that legislation of this nature often receives bipartisan support in the Australian parliament. I don't recall if it was this bill or a different one, but the opposition released a strongly worded statement saying "we have concerns with this legislation", then voted for it ASAP. A thinner fig leaf of an excuse I have yet to see in politics.
- Silhouette 7y agoThis type of bipartisan support seems to be a recurring concern with the more authoritarian "national security" legislation being passed around the world. We have the same thing in the UK, where both of the big parties have tended to support intrusive government surveillance powers. Because of our voting system, the more liberal but smaller parties that would challenge such measures tend to be disproportionately under-represented at national level, so authoritarianism almost always wins. This leads to claims that most people support such measures, yet not so long ago we had a huge grass roots campaign against mandatory ID cards (and related measures like the database behind those cards) that ultimately succeeded in preventing their introduction, so clearly it's not really as simple as that. Certainly some reports based on polling that get brought out to demonstrate that public "support" for these measures have glossed over heavily loaded questions in the polls themselves. (They're not quite "Terrorism is a really serious threat and a nuke might kill everyone. Do you support stronger government powers to prevent bad people doing these bad things and keep your children safe?" but sometimes they get awfully close.) This is the reality of the politics of fear in the Western world today. Personally I'm slightly optimistic that things will turn for the best within the next few years. We seem to have widespread concern about "fake news" and unwarranted interference in democratic processes, to the point that now we see explicit "fact checking" becoming a common practice in media reporting of political statements and we're seeing big social media platforms trying to rein in the more questionable propaganda and stop their systems from becoming little more than a rumour-driven mob on a national or global scale. Maybe someone will finally notice that the threat from terrorism is actually pretty small, the threat from excessive government powers is actually pretty big, and in any case all of these resources might be better spent on other areas of government like education or healthcare or infrastructure projects that could make a much bigger difference to a lot more people anyway. We can hope...
- blackflame7000 7y agoCryptography is unknown to many and many fear the unknown.
- Silhouette 7y agoTrue. It certainly doesn't help that a lot of the elected representatives who are making these laws evidently lack even a basic understanding of the technical issues involved, so they are often guided by expert advice from those who entirely coincidentally are the main beneficiaries of the stronger powers being created.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoFrankly this story doesn't have any substantial to do with cryptography, rather it's about how the media in Australia just doesn't have much protection when anything labelled state secrets are involved. Stories about the raiding and seizing of journalists computers and other materials go back to 2000 at least, see links at end of https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/jun/04/federal-police-raid-home-of-news-corp-journalist-annika-smethurst https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/jun/04/feder...
- baybal2 7y ago> Because of our voting system, the more liberal but smaller parties that would challenge such measures tend to be disproportionately under-represented at national level, so authoritarianism almost always wins. Not because of the voting system, but the very inherent nature of the political process. You and me should be much more afraid of a lot of fools being turned into an organised political force than of typical "fascist intellectuals" ganging up on somebody. It is much more easy to coerce an insecure and ignorant person to do crazy things, than that of even most villainous man with intelligence whose crazyness will be at least limited by his instinct of self preservation. Minority juntas tend to be weak because everybody "have to look after their own backs," and different parties trying to prevent others from achieving monopoly on violence, or doing something stupid that has a chance to jeopardise them both. The long lull after WWII was all due to that "everybody having to look after own back" in both society and on the world stage. Four generations have passed since then, and all lessons of that time are now forgotten.
- incompatible 7y agoIt's just politics in a democratic system. Mainstream parties like the Liberals and Labor in Australia can't go far from what the Australian people will vote for. Apparently, the voters support measures against crime, especially terrorists or paedophiles. Presumably, Labor have done the calculations and think they will lose too much support if the Liberals are accusing them of being weak on crime.