6 ms·
All of these announcements rely on suppliers purchasing "renewable energy certificates", which are like carbon offset certificates (as I understand it). I am q
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
All of these announcements rely on suppliers purchasing "renewable energy certificates", which are like carbon offset certificates (as I understand it).
I am quite dubious of this as on paper the UK is far from producing enough renewable electricity.
- frenchman99 7y agoIt's better than nothing, but the real change comes from suppliers producing renewable energy and most importantly carbon-free energy. Renewable energy can be bad for the environment too, it's not magic. If we found a way to make renewable oil, it wouldn't be environment friendly.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoRenewable oil would be carbon neutral, I suppose. At the moment the 'renewable mix' includes biomass, which is similar. Interestingly, I recently saw a British supplier advertising not only renewable but vegan electricity... Because standard renewable includes animal waste biomass. Is this going too far?
- ljf 7y agoI saw that too - I wouldn't say it is going too far - if people want to pay for it and it doesn't harm others - then why not? Since energy generation is a 'free market' in the UK - why shouldn't there be more niche suppliers?
- NullPrefix 7y agoBiodiesel is a renewable
- imeron 7y agoIn my country they consider heating with wood "renewable energy". This is essentially cheating on the subject.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoWood from managed forests is renewable energy, and arguably carbon neutral as well.
- yakshaving_jgt 7y agoIt's renewable, but where does that burnt carbon go?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt goes back to where the tree extracted it from: atmosphere. That's why it is usually considered carbon neutral.
- ljf 7y agoTrue - but the management, production and transport of the wood pellets that go on to be burnt, produces more co2. Plus burning stuff isn't that great a way to make power, especially wood - if you have ever tried to heat a house with wood verses a coal fire you'll understand. Right now the wood pellets are just a way to skirt the rules - I doubt they'll be part of the mix for long, as solar/wind drops in price, along with cheap and reliable storage.
- abraae 7y agoIt's absorbed by new trees, planted to replace the ones cut down.
- pdpi 7y agoIt's not cheating, it's conflating renewability with pollution generation. Forestry is a well-understood topic that has made wood one of the most widely-used renewable resources in the world. Burning wood still produces large amounts of carbon dioxide/monoxide.
- Nyandalized 7y ago
- londons_explore 7y agoIt doesn't seem that dubious - it simply means there are lots of big businesses (steel/aluminium/glass/concrete factories) which don't buy any of these renewable certificates. It's a bit of a flaw with the whole system really - only companies with a public brand to protect will go renewable, which is far from the economically smart way to do it.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoMy point is that I am not sure that there is enough renewable electricity to meet the demand, and that certificates seem to be a bit massaging the numbers...
- nicoburns 7y agoIn theory this demand drives up prices for the certificates which then goes to renewable energy producers?
- NLips 7y agoYou don't believe there is enough renewablably-produced electricity to meet the demand for certificates? I suspect you might be over-estimating the demand for certificates!
- mytailorisrich 7y agoNot demand for certificates but demand for electricity overall. My understanding is that if you're producing through natural gas and someone else is producing through wind you can buy a certificate from them and then claim that your electricity is renewable. The UK's energy mix is still 50+% gas, and I believe nuclear is not considered renewable... So there is a serious limit to what suppliers can claim is really coming from renewable sources. Especially at night.
- alex_duf 7y agoI'm not a big fan of certificates but there is already enough renewable to power all eon customers. gas is 40%, wind 16.9% solar 4% biomass 6.3% [1] E-ON is about 13% [2] of the market share, just wind is enough to cover that and more (and 13% is assuming the grid generates energy just for customers, not industries, which it isn't) Point is, there is enough renewable energy on the grid, it's a matter of how energy suppliers are going to fight to package it to clients. If the fight becomes hard on their end, they will be incentivised to generate more renewable. [1] http://www.mygridgb.co.uk/last-12-months/ http://www.mygridgb.co.uk/last-12-months/ [2] https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/data-portal/electricity-supply-market-shares-company-domestic-gb https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/data-portal/electricity-supply-mark...
- mrweasel 7y agoCarbon credits/offset certificates really shouldn't be allowed to be included when talking about 100% renewable energy. In fact I don't think carbon credits should exists. We had the issue with sulfur dioxide in the late 80', early 90', but there where no SO2 credits, no offsets, just hard caps until the issue was resolved.
- icebraining 7y agoThey did exactly that with SO2: In the US, the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments established an emissions trading system to reduce emissions of SO2 from fossil-fuel burning power plants located in the continental 48 states of the United States. (...) Caps on emissions were implemented by issuing tradable allowances that in total equalled the annual cap level. To comply, sources were required to surrender one allowance for each ton of emissions. (...) https://www2.dmu.dk/atmosphericenvironment/expost/database/docs/us_emissioncaps.pdf https://www2.dmu.dk/atmosphericenvironment/expost/database/d...
- EliRivers 7y agoWithout commenting on the veracity of E.ON's particular claim, the UK does import renewable from overseas, so the UK could well consume more renewable than it produces.
- tialaramex 7y agoIt definitely does, because it produces loads of non-renewables and then exports them for a nice profit. But consuming more renewables than we produce doesn't make a big dent in overall supply needed. As I explain above E.ON's plan there is to rely on the stubborn British consumer to continue to pay more for worse from their competitors. Or not so much "plan" as just what they're resigned to having happen. The UK needs about 30-40GW of electricity. The import cables can move _maybe_ 5GW flat out if we import in every direction, although of those 2GW is ultimately from France which is nukes, so that's not renewable (it's green, but it isn't renewable) and another 1GW is Ireland, which is as likely to be burning peat (!) as running a wind farm. About 20GW peak comes from CCGT, ie huge plants that burn natural gas and then use that to spin turbines while also capturing the excess heat to "close" the cycle and improve efficiency. Deeply non-renewable. On a windy, bright summer's day that's still cool enough for people not to run all their air conditioning and fans, you might get the CCGT down to 5GW with the interconnects importing from most directions and some wood burners (which are technically renewable even though they aren't green at all) helping the wind + solar + nukes. More likely, right now for example as I write this, the CCGT runs full blast, 20GW of fossil fuel electricity. It's very clean by 1980s standards, only producing water vapour and er... carbon dioxide. Shame the carbon dioxide might destroy our civilisation.
- Angostura 7y agoYou're right to be dubious - but if these credits become sought after, expensive and rare because people are buying them up, the direction of travel is certainly beneficial. Hopefully EON will attempt to reduce its costs by investing in new renewable energy sources.
- johneth 7y agoFrom the article: > "Clean power is available on all its tariffs at no extra cost with most of the renewable energy coming from its own wind, biomass and solar sources" So they're already heavily invested(ing?)
- dmurray 7y agoOne problem is that when the credits can only be used for virtue signalling, the same energy generation gets counted twice. For example, Norway produces virtually all of its power from renewable sources, and then sells the credits to Germany. The Norwegian consumers know that they are using renewable power, because they can see the hydro dams, and the Germans know that they are using renewable power, because they bought the carbon credits. Even though they can see coal or gas plants that are "obviously" actually powering their grid. This doesn't work as well if you actually have cap-and-trade for carbon emissions, and fine countries that don't have the right amount of credits. In that case a country that sells all its credits ends up getting fined.
- montalbano 7y agoI'm (UK) with Octopus Energy on their super green tariff. They state that the electricity is from 100% renewable sources. No mention of renewable energy certificates; it's possible I haven't read the fine print closely enough but it does seem to be the real deal.
- cdmp 7y agoThe Super Green tariff uses power purchased directly from renewable generators (PPAs), not certificates (REGOs). It also carbon offsets your gas usage. Our other no-quite-so-super-green tariffs also provide 100% green electricity but do so using a mix of PPAs and REGOs. There's more info here: https://octopus.energy/blog/generators/ https://octopus.energy/blog/generators/ (I work for Octopus Energy)
- Iv 7y agoI am wondering if this is a way to offset the intermittence problem... Are you allowed to buy a solar power certificate to offset an energy consumption during the night? If yes, then it is meaningless indeed. However if this amounts to making sure that some renewable energy is produced every second some energy is consumed on Eon's network, then that's a very good policy.
- codeulike 7y agoFrom the Guardian: E.ON is one of the UK’s largest renewable energy generators and plans to draw from its own windfarms, biomass plants and solar projects to power the switch. It will also need to top up its portfolio by buying renewable “guarantee certificates”, which are sold by renewable energy developers to guarantee that a set amount of electricity has been generated from a specific project. So they are using certificates a bit. There are firms such as Ecotricity that supply purely renewable energy without buying certificates.
- growlist 7y agoJust a quick warning - I've saved hundreds switching away from Ecotricity. Personally I'd rather give the money saved to a tree planting charity myself, should I wish to do so.
- pidg 7y agoAs an Ecotricity customer I do wonder about this. My bills seem to go up every 6 months and are already pretty high. Then again, I used to be with Eon and their customer service is outrageously abysmal - dropped calls, 30+ minute hold times etc. With Ecotricity I get straight through to a local human every time.
- tluyben2 7y agoNot from the UK but how often does that happen that you have to call your utility company? I cannot say I ever had to do that and i'm mid 40s and home owner since 22.
- tialaramex 7y agoThese guys aren't exactly the utility company. So in one sense that's good, they aren't the ones taking the call when a tree falls on a power line, or some idiot hits a cable while digging a trench, or your whole street blacks out for no apparent reason. That's a problem for a Network Operator, a natural monopoly which will have emergency contact numbers and in my experience those are fairly good at answering, although obviously only calls about actual problems with their supply network. The "supplier" for a consumer is actually basically just a bunch of legal contracts, a spreadsheet, a marketing budget and a call centre. And you do end up calling them when things go wrong with that part, which is too often. I usually end up talking to them at least once near the start of a relationship because they got something important wrong, and when I move home or any circumstances change. It _should_ all be seamless but it often isn't. And ordinary consumers don't understand that it's just spreadsheets, they are genuinely distressed that a screw-up might mean their lights stop working, their food is ruined in the fridge etcetera. So this creates a reluctance to even risk using a different "supplier". Right now it's super smooth for me, I went to full "smart meter" billing, there's a wireless box somewhere telling what it'll cost when I remember to look and the money vanishes from my current account on cue, no action needed for years at a time (need to review the tarif design, ie mix of fixed and variable charges online every few years or you get a shit default deal). But a decade ago I spent months contesting charges with one of these suppliers because they had a meter reference down wrong in some database and couldn't get the fix to "stick" so I'd get next door's usage billed, I'd complain, they'd "fix" it, same next month, repeat.
- tialaramex 7y agoMostly they rely on the fact that extraordinarily most Britons still buy their energy from a local "incumbent" electricity supplier even though that costs more. Years ago residential customers in the UK were obligatory customers of monopoly government owned suppliers in each region. You could only buy (residential or small business) electricity from the same people who ran all the cables where you lived, thus a natural monopoly, which was government owned. Then there was an era of government very enthusiastic about the Free Market even where it has no obvious place (again: natural monopoly) and even more enthusiastic about moving debts and long term costs off government books created a new system. The actual power grid - the natural monopoly - is now run by a single for-profit company but the consumer buys electricity from any of dozens of pointless entities that exist only to buy and sell notional electricity and bill customers on top of that supply network, many created from the carcasses of the old monopoly regional suppliers. To bootstrap this situation consumers needed to start out with a supplier, and so they were all assigned the one that had previously been their monopoly supplier anyway, the "incumbent". What was expected to happen was they'd all offer lower prices to new customers (this happened) and everybody would switch and create a new equilibrium in which almost everybody got lower prices and was more willing to change supplier. Your actual electricity supply would always come from the boring reliable (but now privately owned) grid, but you'd pay whichever imaginary "supplier" charged a few quid less, or had a cool mascot in their TV ads or whatever. But almost everyone ignored it. Given the choice between paying an incumbent supplier £100 or finding out how to change supplier to get a cheaper £80 deal, almost all consumers just kept paying £100. If you can't leave (e.g. often short lease tenants even if the law says they can change supplier find that in practice they really can't) you're stuck paying £100 while a pro-Free Market politician struts about on TV saying how they've saved you £20. But the biggest impact is that because the incumbents control so much of the market and consumers don't care, you can offer almost anything, even seemingly unrealistic things like "100% Renewable electricity for all customers" and know you'll only get a handful of takers anyway. My mother switched to a tiny local "supplier", which promptly went bankrupt. Despite the fact that her power worked throughout (like I said these suppliers don't actually supply anyway) and she wasn't billed for that power (the bankruptcy appears to have made it difficult to even figure out what customers owe them) she found this traumatic enough that she now refuses to ever switch away from her incumbent again.
- oliwarner 7y agoBut it does contribute explicit demand for it. And there's only so far you can ship it. It's not international like carbon offsets.