5 ms·
> There is vast swathes of them around where I live in Scotland and there is no bio-diversity there at all. Um, you do know that forests have stages? Right?
by bsder 7y ago
> There is vast swathes of them around where I live in Scotland and there is no bio-diversity there at all.
Um, you do know that forests have stages? Right?
Evergreens tend to be one of the first stages. Evergreens generally grow quickly and tolerate fairly crappy soils. "waterlogged soil with high clay content" (from the article) is a REALLY crappy soil for trees. The littering of needles generally helps add some level of nutrients back to depleted soils (an acidic humus is going to be vastly better than completely leached out waterlogged clay) It's why you plant evergreens on strip mined areas to help reclaim them.
After the evergreens, the deciduous trees start coming in from the edges--but this takes decades.
Now, it's possible that Ireland/Scotland don't have enough deciduous trees (or, in the case of Scotland, the climate may simply not be correct--Scotland has a lot of land that's really crappy for growing anything much at all) to start the process and those trees need to be added to their planning. Fair enough.
However, I don't see any discussion or acknowledgement of any of this in the article.
- soVeryTired 7y ago> Um, you do know that forests have stages? Right? Calling you out for the needlessly confrontational tone here. It turns what could be an informative post into an agressive one.
- rorykoehler 7y agoThese forests are essentially tree farms. There is no bio diversity and no deciduous trees growing in from the side. The forest will be felled for wood long before a deciduous tree would have time to grow. It's a travesty. Come to Ireland and see for yourself.
- bsder 7y ago> These forests are essentially tree farms. Then the real problem is that this really isn't "afforestation" at all and what trees are being planted is irrelevant.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> Um, you do know that forests have stages? Right? Right. From the article, the stages are: > The trees mature in about 30 years ... and are then felled, making way for a fresh plantation. > When machines chop down swathes of forest, a controversial process known as clear-felling, the landscape is devastated, said Stewart. “It looks like Hiroshima.”