3 ms·
Most of the additional costs associating with the banking system would still have to be paid if bitcoin were to provide the same services. But also, there's no
by perl4ever 7y ago
Most of the additional costs associating with the banking system would still have to be paid if bitcoin were to provide the same services. But also, there's no reason that they should account for exactly 1000 times the cost of printing the money. I think you can expect you've gone down the wrong track when you believe numbers are exactly what is necessary to justify your argument for no particular external reason.
The only costs that are reasonable and appropriate to include, it seems to me, in an apples-to-apples comparison, are the costs of actually creating the money and regulating the supply.
So, ok, over and above the negligible amount to create money, it's plausible to include the cost of the Federal Reserve system, since that is what keeps the money supply stable, analogous to the mining algorithm.
The M2 money supply (a bit arbitrary, but for this comparison it's somewhat generous to the opposing view and anyway, I guess they don't publish M3 any more) is something like $14.5 trillion. The cost of the Federal Reserve is something like $5 billion[1] So the "maintenance" cost for a dollar is something like 3 cents every hundred years. To me, that seems de minimus and it also seems a person with some common sense would expect that without doing an analysis.
If you want to be obstinate about this, I suspect you will argue that bitcoin as it currently exists provides the facility to do transactions which I am not including the cost of with dollars, and my response is that the throughput of bitcoin is negligible and therefore not appropriate to equate with the capacity of the real financial system.
[1]https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2017-ar-federal-system-budgets.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2017-ar-federal-...