4 ms·
I have been following Libra very closely, and have read their white paper twice. There have been a few good discussions here on HN when it launched [0], but I
by simonebrunozzi 7y ago
I have been following Libra very closely, and have read their white paper twice.
There have been a few good discussions here on HN when it launched [0], but I think most of these have been very biased against anything Facebook-related.
I find the launch of Libra a really interesting "experiment", with potentially big negative or positive consequences for the entire world.
Right now, it's really hard to judge on the technical merits (e.g. the Move language, or the architecture, or how they're going to transition to a truly permissionless and decentralized consensus).
However, I think that it's wise to follow Libra's evolution with attention, as it might, and probably will, have consequences in our lives.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20210791 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20210791
- hajile 7y agoWhen you're talking about controlling money, politics matter more than "technical merit". Libra is invite only and they invited their business friends. Libra consortium is based in Switzerland, so the businesses involved have guaranteed essentially zero government oversight. Libra's owners have complete control over how much currency, the currency exchange rate, and even inflation rates (note that inflation is actually a tax on wealth). I can't regulate it. I can't get my government to regulate it. I can't get a non-partisan consortium to regulate it (eg, Bitcoin). Businesses proven to put profits first have complete control. I have everything to lose and nothing to gain. I don't care about the technical merit; everything about this stinks. EDIT: and all that is before the privacy aspect. While accounts may be "anonymous", Facebook can use their data to identify you anyway. I don't like these big date companies tracking my friends or website visits. I certainly don't want them tracking my money too. There's also the wrongthink aspect. Recent leaks from different companies seem to show them exerting political power and banning dissent. My political opinions may align with their now, but I'd bet anything that sooner or later, I'll disagree with them on something. I don't want my financial stability based on a platform that punishes me for thinking or believing "the wrong thing" (which could just be saying something critical about the companies in control). Libra giving economic power to companies is straight out of fascism.
- dmix 7y ago> Libra consortium is based in Switzerland, so the businesses involved have guaranteed essentially zero government oversight. Do you really think a massive US company using some Switzerland corporation is going to protect Facebook and their investors against any regulatory scrutiny?
- hajile 7y agoYes. Facebook is undoubtedly incorporated in other countries as well. The US could pressure Facebook, but they could move servers elsewhere. Even if they didn't, the US would have to pressure every single company involved. More importantly, the US can't just audit bank records from another country. They can't go after Facebook unless they can prove wrongdoing. Offshore accounts protect a lot of bad people for this very reason. Edit: There also the long term issue. If their currency takes off, the economic power it gives also shields them. Remember too big to fail? We can hardly manage the federal reserve where the government is actually part owner. The situation here would be much worse.
- dmix 7y agoThe US just prosecuted Walmart in US courts for stuff their Brazilian HQ did in Brazil. I'm sure the US could find a way to do the same for Facebook and their investors for how they're using Libra inside the US.
- carlosdp 7y ago> Libra is invite only and they invited their business friends. That's a big assumption. They were able to get their business friends to sign on, probably because they are already friends. I'm sure they asked a lot of other groups that were more hesitant, it would have made the initial announcement much more powerful. Also important to note non-profits, NGOs, and universities are included, and they don't have to pay the $10m buy-in. > and all that is before the privacy aspect. While accounts may be "anonymous", Facebook can use their data to identify you anyway... The way Libra is designed, that would probably be a lot more trouble than it is worth. Tracking methods without direct trackers (like 3rd-party cookies) work because there are many data points. Like in browser fingerprinting, you have user agents, JS feature availability, history, etc. With Libra, you only have an account address and transactions to other anonymous account addresses. One dimension of data like that would be very very hard to trace back to the user, without direct participation from many many merchants. > There's also the wrongthink aspect. Fair, however afaik only 1 of the 28 current companies (Facebook) has this attribute.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> with potentially big negative or positive consequences for the entire world. What are some of the biggest positive consequences potentially offered by Libra in your opinion?
- carlosdp 7y agoLiterally what they say it's designed for: giving access to the digital economy to the 500m+ people in emerging markets that have internet + phone, but no banking services.
- fbi-director 7y agoIt's dauntingly scary that people seem to have already forgotten that FB is known and has been ousted for abusing every bit of power and information they are given. And now you're excited that there's another aspect of your personal info, perhaps the most important part that they'll get (some kind of) control over? Increasing their power as a company overall as well.. Really mind blowing!
- carlosdp 7y agoI don't have to have a Facebook account to use Libra, I don't have to give them any additional information unless I use their app.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> giving access to the digital economy to the 500m+ people in emerging markets that have internet + phone, but no banking services. I don't really understand the flow. They are paid in cash for working their low wage jobs now. How is the cash going to become Libra? Through... what is basically a banking service? Which they don't have access to now?
- dx87 7y agoMight be like how people without a bank go to various businesses that will cash their check for a fee, except they'll give the business cash and get Libra transferred to their account.
- jammygit 7y agoFacebook is enough of a problem without letting them control part of the money supply too