5 ms·
I'm sure there are complexities here that I'm not seeing, but...neat rows, uniform textures, little noise, no external interference, physical feedback, low risk
by Havoc 7y ago
I'm sure there are complexities here that I'm not seeing, but...neat rows, uniform textures, little noise, no external interference, physical feedback, low risk.
Relatively to say a self driving car that needs to deal with dogs running into the road in questionable weather at decent speed this seems comparatively easy.
That's not meant to be condescending - I know for a fact I can't program a lettuce harvester at all let alone a better one. Just seems like there is a weird difficulty differential at play here.
- toper-centage 7y agoThis feeling will only become more common as we start exhausting all possible applications of machine learning.
- nexuist 7y agoThere are quite a few human jobs that deal with "neat rows, uniform textures, little noise, no external interference, physical feedback, low risk." Think: gift wrapping, cookie cutting, sewing, etc. As it currently stands, people still work these jobs in large quantities even though we have the technology to automate all of them out. It is certainly comparatively easy to self driving cars. But that's the point: while we haven't solved level 5 autonomy yet, we do seem to be solving these lower level problems at or above the same skill level as trained professionals, and the amount of problems we solve with machine learning technology appears to be increasing at an exponential rate. It's logical to extrapolate from here that AI will be able to solve even harder problems in the future, including those our best researchers still haven't figured out. A job at its core is applied problem solving. When AI services and physical robots can solve every problem in a better way than humans against every metric possible, there won't really be a need for humans in the workforce.
- visarga 7y ago> When AI services and physical robots can solve every problem in a better way than humans against every metric possible, there won't really be a need for humans in the workforce. That logic assumes humans want to share equitably the ownership of robots and their benefits.
- zizee 7y agoI often see this pessimistic prediction, and I don't get it. What benefit would someone have to not pass on cost savings to consumers if they had a super effective robot to do something? And regardless of their motives, how would they stop it from happening? Patents have limited lifetimes and and techniques developed will be quickly replicated/democratized. Perhaps someone could corner the market for a while, but not indefinitely. In the end, the result of automated production will be downward pressure on prices, with consumables trending towards $0. With this in mind, it strikes me that the pessimistic predictions stem from the idea that there is a secret cabal of the "wealthy" who take great pleasure* in keeping their fellowman down. Today, by many measurements people living in wealthy countries have a standard of living so far superior to that of kings of old. Has the secret cabal been just lying in wait until now to strike? * sure, some percentage of billionaires are probably sociopaths, but I'm sure most are not.
- monkeydust 7y agoThis is exactly the fear of many at the moment. A solution being talked is to tax robots (or automation to be more specific). Expect more research to come out from Academia over next few years. Even Bill Gates has been advocating its consideration: https://qz.com/911968/bill-gates-the-robot-that-takes-your-job-should-pay-taxes/ https://qz.com/911968/bill-gates-the-robot-that-takes-your-j...
- ahje 7y ago1) Even if the cost of products approaches 0, consumers will still need some kind of income to attain them. UBI could help in that regard, but it's still a far way off. 2) The transition period might not be that pleasant. A lot of people will be left without any means to provide for themselves while the rest of society struggles to adapt. 3) Removing the need for labour will be a major game changer to our society. A lot of people will be left with a feeling of having no purpose and nothing to do. Fostering a culture of creativity to fill people's waken hours sounds like a good thing, but I fear there will be a lot of social unrest if people don't have anything to do.
- black_puppydog 7y ago
- soup10 7y agoWe're seeing a new wave of low hanging fruit getting pruned, but complex problems still require complex solutions and no amount of gradient descents will change that any time soon.
- keithnz 7y agoI would think the lettuce classification is not the only hard part. Having worked on fruit sorting machines where each fruit is rotated under a vision system and various measurements and classification are made, in a completely controlled lighting environment.... it's not trivial, especially getting it to the level of commercial viability. Making the robotic cutting mechanism / vision / control system would also be challenging.
- taneq 7y agoThe real killer is reliability, not so much in terms of percentage of produce spoiled but in terms of how often it gums itself up and needs manual intervention. And in a production environment, the numbers add up really quickly and you need a lot of nines. A human doing the job takes 2 seconds per lettuce and can probably work a full 12-hour shift without intervention. Adding some leeway for pauses and breaks, call it 10 hours of uninterrupted production, that's 18,000 lettuces. If your failure rate is only 0.005% that's still one failure per robot per day.
- keithnz 7y agoexactly. In large fruit packing lines if the plant came to a stop, it would cost a lot of $s per minute of downtime (some lines involved 100s of people, incoming trucks, out going trucks etc that all get frozen). Some crops are very time sensitive and delays in the whole supply chain are problematic. Though the good thing with free form robots like that is you can buy a certain amount of redundancy. Some problems though are disastrous, like if the robot starts automatically destroying the lettuces for some reason (unforeseen mechanical failure which is undetected). I have watched this happen a number of times with the automated machines I worked on..... nothing quite like debugging problems with that kind of pressure :)
- leggomylibro 7y agoIt does seem like that, doesn't it? And there's a lot of money and potential for social good in agriculture. Makes you wonder why there aren't already loads of commercial solutions like this, especially since self-driving cars are right around the corner. I guess it could be because (iirc) there are products that already fill the niche, like combines that can navigate along GPS waypoints. But I bet it is also extremely difficult to get the last couple of 9s that you need for commercially-viable accuracy and precision in an ML model, even with ideal conditions.
- dehrmann 7y ago> combines that can navigate along GPS waypoints The easy things to mechanize and automate have already been done. > I bet it is also extremely difficult to get the last couple of 9s that you need for commercially-viable accuracy and precision in an ML model, even with ideal conditions. With how much food never makes it to people, I bet 95% would be good enough for a lettuce picking robot. The problem is it's $50,000-$500,000, while the humans are $8 per hour.
- IanCal 7y ago> The problem is it's $50,000-$500,000, while the humans are $8 per hour. It depends how active you can keep it. £500k financed over say 10 years at 5% is about £5k/mo, a 25y+ human in the UK working 40h workweeks costs about £1600/mo (bare minimum, assumes no overheads or illnesses just the legal minimum + taxes/etc).
- dehrmann 7y agoAnother thing to consider is specialization and seasonality. If the robot is over-specialized in something seasonal, it'll sit idle most of the year. Laborers, on the other hand, move from farm to farm and crop to crop.
- mikepurvis 7y agoThere are a lot of companies working on robotic farming; two that I'm familiar with from the ROS community are Iron Ox and Deepfield: http://ironox.com/ http://ironox.com/ https://www.deepfield-robotics.com/en/ https://www.deepfield-robotics.com/en/ Deepfield gave a great talk at ROSCon a few years ago about their data management platform for monitoring plants over time, see: https://vimeo.com/187696092#t=1025s https://vimeo.com/187696092#t=1025s