3 ms·
While the asteroid will of course never be worth the quintillions it's worth on paper, there's no doubt it will be worth something. Otherwise, why are people st
by mcv 7y ago
While the asteroid will of course never be worth the quintillions it's worth on paper, there's no doubt it will be worth something. Otherwise, why are people still spending money to dig up gold out of the earth?
But gold isn't that interesting. The only reason it's valued the way it is, is because everybody has agreed it's valuable. But there are many other rare metals and minerals we can mine from asteroids that would be immensely useful. In smartphones and other electronics, for example.
At the moment, rare earth elements are often mined in terrible destructive ways, sometimes under atrocious circumstances. Fairphone is the one phone company that's trying to do something about it, but on their own, they're not going to have a lot of impact. Off-world mining would allow us to leave our Earth intact while still enjoying the smartphones and other electronics that these materials enable.
- DonHopkins 7y agoWhat's much more valuable than the gold is the infrastructure required to bring that gold back to earth. Harvesting sand and helium from space might be more valuable than gold.
- tshannon 7y agoThe sand comment had me perplexed, until I did some googling: https://www.npr.org/2017/07/21/538472671/world-faces-global-sand-shortage https://www.npr.org/2017/07/21/538472671/world-faces-global-...
- mcv 7y agoA lot of Dutch companies get their sand from the bottom of the sea, though. Plenty of sand there.
- DonHopkins 7y agoApparently desert sand is no good for making concrete, because it's been smoothed and rounded by the wind. I'm guessing moon sand wouldn't have such a problem. Although you'd have to solve the problem of re-entry into the Earth's atmosphere. How practical are space elevators?
- pessimizer 7y ago> The only reason it's valued the way it is, is because everybody has agreed it's valuable. The only reason why gold is valuable is because it is easily and arbitrarily divisible, can be worn as a status symbol to advertise your wealth, and it has a goldilocks scarcity where the amount you have to carry to do human-scale business is not smaller than a dime, but also not heavier than a large cat. The last is becoming less and less true with as population size grows (I can't buy a 5-pound bag of sugar with gold), but the slack is taken up by fiat.
- growlist 7y agoIt does have some pretty unique properties e.g. ductility - imagine gold foil as cheap as aluminium foil. I'm sure we'd find plenty of uses from that alone, not least better heat shielding.