4 ms·
The Fight for the Future of YouTube
- wilsocr88 7y agoIn the subtitle of this article, the author asks "How 'neutral' should social-media platforms try to be?" I asked a similar question in a blog post[1] using different terms. Should "platforms" just be flat platforms, or should they curate their content like a publisher? If they don't, can they make money? Can they pay content creators decently while still remaining a platform, or is that something only a publisher can do? I don't know that there's a good answer. [1] https://wilsocr88.github.io/#0/7 https://wilsocr88.github.io/#0/7
- basch 7y agothe world has already decided that they should be curated. the question is now, "at what level we make the distinction." no product does client side spam determination anymore. everyone agrees that spam, fraud, phishing have no legitimate place. we have a dial, and even on the "free speech" end of things, people agree it shouldnt be turned up far enough to allow all noise.
- stcredzero 7y agothe world has already decided that they should be curated. the question is now, "at what level we make the distinction." Why should it be at any level besides that of legality, or those levels analogous to movie ratings? everyone agrees that spam, fraud, phishing have no legitimate place Those are issues of non-consensual activity. What YouTube, Patreon, PayPal, Facebook, et al. have done includes the suppression of content people want to see and are even willing to pay for. They've even gone farther and not let them pay. By going against the consent of the public, they've moved themselves in the same immoral direction as the spammers, fraudsters, and phishers. They're doing what large swathes of the public don't want done to their access to data. (Merely in order to get advertising dollars from other large corporations, I might add.) It's just that they currently look more legitimate, as they slowly creep in that immoral direction. we have a dial, and even on the "free speech" end of things, people agree it shouldnt be turned up far enough to allow all noise There are disingenuous actors who want that power over almost all the relevant discourse, and wish to turn that dial in such a way that they hold the power. It doesn't matter if they've convinced themselves they'll wield it in a "good" way. No one should have it. That's what Free Speech is all about.
- RealWorldPolice 7y ago"Merely in order to get advertising dollars" What else would you expect from an internet advertising company?
- stcredzero 7y agoStopping short of misrepresenting what they're doing. Stopping short of arbitrary enforcement. (Which means keeping employees from (apparently) arbitrarily using company mechanisms to further their own ideological ends.) Stopping short of meddling in payments handled by another company. (Which looks a bit too much like tortious interference.) If the companies were merely driven by profit motive and getting ad dollars, it would be fine. It's the manipulation of the public discourse which people object to and feels slimy.
- samlevine 7y agoIf my email provider decides to stop delivering my email because the person emailing me is a crank I'm going to get another email provider. Because they're a platform for email, not a publisher of email. I don't want a YouTube that is a publisher because at that point it ceases being my tube and starts being their tube. This defeats what makes YouTube so special.
- basch 7y agoYour email provider blocks thousands of emails it thinks you dont want. Youtube blocks copywritten material on upload. Those are things a publisher does (reduce noise, detect plagiarism.)
- cmoscoe 7y agoThe author seems to, at several points, conflate political bias with truth. While there may be some correlation there, to me it would seem more valuable to point people towards factual, reputable, meaningful content regardless of whether it's left or right wing (if the user seems to be looking for educational or editorial content). Letting videos cite sources could go a long way there. If, on the other hand, a user seems to be looking for trolling videos of one political persuasion or another, why not let them go down that rabbit hole? That can also be fun.
- tastygreenapple 7y agoI wonder if Youtube is prepared for the massive censorship demanded to create a safe space. It's not helpful that the progressive grievance hierarchy isn't robustly formulated, if a woman and a black man are mad at each other, it's not clear who has more victim points which is important for determining 'the right side of history'. I don't envy Youtube creating a moderation engine that attempts to place inconsistent people.
- einpoklum 7y agoThat's not the point. The point is for YouTube to censor views the government and/or large corporations doesn't like and start getting traction.
- chmod775 7y ago> In the course of the spring, YouTube drafted a new policy that would ban videos trafficking in historical “denialism” (of the Holocaust, 9/11, Sandy Hook) and “supremacist” views (lauding the “white race,” arguing that men were intellectually superior to women). Cool. So YouTube will force that group of people off their platform and magnify the intensity of their echo chamber in the process. To many of those "problematic" videos other people have created detailed responses explaining why they are misguided. Now the other group won't see those rebuttals because they're on a different platform. Thanks to what passes for a "good" recommendation engine nowadays people are already mostly subjected to content they already agree with - instead of content that might challenge their views and make them a better person. This will continue until nobody's opinion is challenged ever (and doing so won't be socially acceptable in any case). I hope to never see the kind of society this leads too, but I fear we might be entering the endgame sooner rather than later.
- Joakal 7y agoSpeech has always been a slippery slope. For example, they could start ghosting and demonetising videos critical of governments/companies. What's the acceptable limit to speech on Youtube? Will the users care?
- jakeogh 7y ago1, 2 and 7 are common knowledge. http://s3.amazonaws.com/nasathermalimages/public/video/pretext.mov http://s3.amazonaws.com/nasathermalimages/public/video/prete...
- chmod775 7y agoThey are really not. They may be considered "common knowledge" in your circles. You can find plenty of detailed rebuttals to the theories you subscribe to and I invite you to seek them out and consider the other side of the argument.
- jakeogh 7y agoCertainly. I have checked that box. The magnitude of bad/false information around that Tuesday exceeds the verifiable by orders. Your other responses (I strongly agree with) tell me you haven't really looked into it.
- stcredzero 7y agoAt first, the site was moderated largely by its co-founders; in 2006, they hired a single, part-time moderator. The company removed videos often, rarely encountering pushback. In the intervening thirteen years, a lot has changed. “YouTube has the scale of the entire Internet,” Sundar Pichai, the C.E.O. of Google, which owns YouTube, told Axios last month. The site now attracts a monthly audience of two billion people and employs thousands of moderators. Every minute, its users upload five hundred hours of new video. If YouTube is now sized at entire-Internet scale, and is the overwhelming dominant player in next generation video news and commentary, then what YouTube does becomes a Free Speech issue. Something the size of YouTube should rightly be a Platform. It cannot be a Publisher at this scale. Wielding the power of a Publisher at such a scale is concentrating too much power in too few hands. In a way, the days of the Printing Press were far superior to today's era of YouTube. Printing presses can be crafted by determined DIYers. Network effects couldn't suppress an independent press, but in 2019, YouTube just has to hold onto its Network Effect and wait until the energy and seed capital of potential competitors runs out, or they're at least reduced to 3rd-rate irrelevant zombie sites.
- bcheung 7y agoThis makes sense to me. The question to me is should platforms like Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc be subject to common carrier laws / net neutrality laws? The Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that hate speech is protected as free speech. "Hate" is also very subjective as well. If it is controversial even in the slightest, then someone, somewhere, is going to be offended and think it is hateful.
- t34543 7y agoI think offending people is really important to the development of society. Opposing viewpoints are really important to fostering discussion and stimulating minds. Universities must be the bastion of this: free speech must come before all else. Uni is a purpose built institution to grow minds.
- peterlk 7y ago
- ralusek 7y agoFor those who are looking for neutral alternatives: bitchute.com minds.com I really commend YouTube for holding out a long as they have. It can't be overstated how important they have been in being the only real media source for liberal/libertarian alternative thought to the censorious leftist orthodoxy...but the writing is on the wall. YouTube, please continue to hold out as long as you can, and thank you.
- einpoklum 7y ago"executives at YouTube began mulling, once again, the problem of online speech. On grounds of freedom of expression and ideological neutrality, the platform has long allowed users to upload videos endorsing noxious ideas, from conspiracy theories to neo-Nazism." They're not "mulling" anything. YouTube, and Google's search engine, are engaging in effective censorship of non-mainstream political content (both left and right wing, by the way) - for a couple of years now. See this report already in 2017: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2017/07/27/goog-j27.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2017/07/27/goog-j27.html and everyone knows how for, what is it now, a couple of years or so, YouTube pushes mainstream news media items when you watch over political content - videos which used to have almost no views, and are now artificially massively popular.