8 ms·
Robot uses machine learning to harvest lettuce
- jedberg 7y agoLook, more simple but labor intensive jobs being replaced by automation. Our society will definitely need to solve this problem sooner than later. Soon we won't have any jobs left that can be done without an education.
- kodachi 7y agoThat is something I thing about frequently. On one hand, I think it's great to have self-sustaining homes/neighborhoods that require minimal manual repetitive work. Then I think that there are lots of people who know nothing but that. knowledge". If you lose the ability to adapt and learn (something we all probably do as we age), then you are left out.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoThis is why retraining programs are often inneffective and why i support ubi and andrew yang
- TrainedMonkey 7y agoThere is another side of the coin - to make universal basic income work cost of foodstuff, healthcare, and construction (and thus housing) needs to be pushed extremely low. This kind of automation enables it. There is no argument that automating these jobs will incur tremendous human suffering by taking away jobs. However, in the long term I don't want anyone to be 'harvesting lettuce'.
- barry-cotter 7y agoOr we could expand wage subsidies like the earned income tax credit. That has the advantage of not causing labour supply to drop precipitously and would cost much less than UBI so it could be implemented far sooner. And if the math on UBI comes anywhere near working out you passed the point of being able to afford wage subsidies long ago.
- hutzlibu 7y agoBut harvesting lettuce can be fun - in your own garden on your own time of course. Not back destroying wage labour...
- Havoc 7y agoYep. Logic next step is UBI. What of all the poor countries with millions of uneducated that need UBI but the country doesn't have a upper end to carry the UBI? I don't see how that's gonna work :(
- jedberg 7y agoGlobalization has been bringing up living conditions across the entire planet for 50+ years now. Presumably that trend would continue such that they could get the eduction they need, possibly through foreign aid or through sharing the bounties of the natural resources in those countries. But you're right, it will be a hard problem to solve if we continue to separate wealth by country. At the end of the day we'd need a planetary economy to really deal with it.
- hrobok 7y agothey can migrate to america and help vote in ubi, I suppose.
- mc32 7y agoIt depends on the adoption curve. Right now farmers are having a hard time finding summer hands to harvest some types of produce. Fewer teenagers and adults want to work as farmhands, so this is a net benefit in this industry.
- p1necone 7y agoIf we completely automate food production and house construction perhaps they'll become cheap enough that it doesn't matter
- barry-cotter 7y agoFood production is already plenty cheap in the developed world. In the 50s in the US middle class people still worried about the price of milk and butter and the working class did not have the option of eating out for every meal. Even Mexico, a middle income country, has an obesity problem rather than a malnutrition one. In areas with high demand the constraint on building housing is zoning, not cost of construction. You can build in masonry up to eight stories high as long as you have elevators. With steel frame much higher obviously. Everywhere the cost of housing is substantially above construction plus land costs the reason is zoning.
- flukus 7y ago> Food production is already plenty cheap in the developed world. Even a lot of that is hugely inflated at the various steps to get to the consumer, in developing countries basic staples can be astonishingly cheap by western standards. Even semi-developed India you can have a decent diet for roughly $4USD a day: https://www.numbeo.com/food-prices/country_result.jsp?country=India https://www.numbeo.com/food-prices/country_result.jsp?countr...
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoDefinitely for far less. In one of the most expensive private universities in Pakistan, in the cafeteria you can eat three "home-cooked meals" for $4USD/day. I.e. on top of the ingredients you are paying for cooking/cleaning labor and space. You can eat for maybe half that at home.
- Rch_East 7y agoThis is a good thing: we are already significantly over the carrying capacity of the planet. A managed decline of population down to a couple of billion engineers, and robots for everything else, would mean a much better quality of life for the average human, and much better outcomes for the environment. Then, when we expand beyond Earth, we can grow the population again. Technological developments have always driven the human species forward - all of this is nothing new. The difference now is the extremely high populations (enabled by technologies invented elsewhere in the world) in some countries with excessive unemployment levels. Genetic engineering and molecular biology will also enable us to identify the genes which contribute the most to useful traits, and to expand access to those genes to a greater portion of humanity
- hutzlibu 7y ago"A managed decline of population" So. What do you propose?
- Rch_East 7y agoGlobal access to education, contraception, and abortion for women, for starters. Redirect foreign aid away from food aid and towards this purpose. If you feel that your family cannot support a child, it should be within your power to control that. Many women simply do not have that choice.
- Waterluvian 7y agoHow did we do it so far? It wasn't long ago that most of us didn't have an education.
- tootahe45 7y agoThis stuff has been said for years, but it's almost 2020, when do you consider soon? If anything, more jobs will be created as we can mass produce goods at home without going through China et al. In fact in my country, they can't find anyone to pick the fruit even for very decent wages (even if the picker sucks). On the issue of skilled work, if i was a male with no skills or family, I'd be becoming a truck driver right now due to all the doom and gloom which already has led to shortages. The truth is, a lot of these automation problems are very hard to solve.
- inflatableDodo 7y agoThis sounds cool. I've been spending some spare time designing an outdoor solar pumped hydroponic waterflume system intended to connect to the top and bottom panes of a residential window, that uses robotic gates between looping sections for growing leafy greens suspended in the flowing water by floating planters that progress slowly from the inlet at the top to the outlet at the bottom of the window as they progress from seedling to full plant. The design can also be disguised as a 'garden water-feature' in a range of styles from '70s sci-fi to minature Roman aquaduct. edit - am intending to publish an open source git repo of the thing, should I get any further than my current mass of sketches.
- toper-centage 7y agoSo, like an extremely slow Lettuce printer?
- inflatableDodo 7y agoIt depends. How fast are lettuce printers, generally?
- abacadaba 7y agoWhat's your price range?
- inflatableDodo 7y ago200,000 - 250,000 kg, of 6 month lettuce futures.
- cwkoss 7y agoVery neat idea, I'd love to hear more about this. How would you control the position of plants within the flume? Personally, I've been pondering a solar-pumped hydroponic system which uses bell siphons under a big 'deer scarer' like off-balance tipping vessel to periodically flood-then-flush a number of sequential gravity-fed zones.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoNot to be flippant but isn't it machine learning using the robot, not the other way around?
- jefft255 7y agoNot really, the robot uses it in the sense that the machine learning algorithm will detect cabbages and tell if it's ready, and that information will be used by the robot to perform harvesting. Of course, you can have end-to-end control of the robot via machine learning (they seem, for example, to use another camera for blade control), and at this stage you could be right but in the robotics community we always say that a robot uses machine learning, not the other way around.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoIf you think of machine learning as the mind and the robot as the body...does the body use the mind or does the mind use the body?
- inetknght 7y agoWhy does it have to be a one-way use?
- SubiculumCode 7y agoIt was more of a comment on how we use language about a machine and its intelligence compared to how we use language about a human and a human's intelligence. To be clear, my comment was not taking a position on whether the dichotomy of mind and body, machine and algorithm actually exists or is meaningful, but of perhaps a bias that we have in how we describes machine that exhibit some intelligence. I think it is more common to speak of our minds as controlling our bodies than vice versa, but we don't seem to naturally extend that to machines with intelligence.
- jefft255 7y agoEven if that was true, the « mind » of most robots consist of mamy algorithms, some of which are not based on machine learning i.e. SLAM and path planning.
- sam0x17 7y agoobligatory: my cabbages!!! But no this is an extremely cool application of machine learning. It's interesting that many of the low-paying professions are actually extremely difficult to automate -- a robot that can harvest lettuce is much scarcer than a person who can harvest lettuce.
- devy 7y agoGoogle has been collaborating with Japanese farmers in this field as early as 2016[1], and put up a case study to demonstrate their GCP AI offering. [1] https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/how-a-japanese-cucumber-farmer-is-using-deep-learning-and-tensorflow https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/how-a-japanese-cu...
- ipsum2 7y agoCollaborating seems like a strong word to use here. Google wrote about a farmer using Tensorflow to identify good cucumbers.
- Havoc 7y agoI'm sure there are complexities here that I'm not seeing, but...neat rows, uniform textures, little noise, no external interference, physical feedback, low risk. Relatively to say a self driving car that needs to deal with dogs running into the road in questionable weather at decent speed this seems comparatively easy. That's not meant to be condescending - I know for a fact I can't program a lettuce harvester at all let alone a better one. Just seems like there is a weird difficulty differential at play here.
- toper-centage 7y agoThis feeling will only become more common as we start exhausting all possible applications of machine learning.
- nexuist 7y agoThere are quite a few human jobs that deal with "neat rows, uniform textures, little noise, no external interference, physical feedback, low risk." Think: gift wrapping, cookie cutting, sewing, etc. As it currently stands, people still work these jobs in large quantities even though we have the technology to automate all of them out. It is certainly comparatively easy to self driving cars. But that's the point: while we haven't solved level 5 autonomy yet, we do seem to be solving these lower level problems at or above the same skill level as trained professionals, and the amount of problems we solve with machine learning technology appears to be increasing at an exponential rate. It's logical to extrapolate from here that AI will be able to solve even harder problems in the future, including those our best researchers still haven't figured out. A job at its core is applied problem solving. When AI services and physical robots can solve every problem in a better way than humans against every metric possible, there won't really be a need for humans in the workforce.
- visarga 7y ago> When AI services and physical robots can solve every problem in a better way than humans against every metric possible, there won't really be a need for humans in the workforce. That logic assumes humans want to share equitably the ownership of robots and their benefits.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoThis actually has a chance to make lettuce safer by cutting down on how much lettuce is handled by humans. https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/02/health/e-coli-lettuce-explainer/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/02/health/e-coli-lettuce-explain... It is does that, this could be a case of machine learning literally saving human lives.
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoContamination of produce has been due to using contaminated water for irrigation or washing, or infested storage. It has nothing to do with there being a human picker or not. The article you cite essentially points this out.
- isegrim 7y agoOn a related note—YC funded a few years ago a cool-looking startup working on a robotic greenhouse, Iron Ox [0]. [0] http://ironox.com/ http://ironox.com/
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> Although the prototype is nowhere near as fast or efficient as a human worker, it demonstrates how the use of robotics in agriculture might be expanded, even for crops like iceberg lettuce which are particularly challenging to harvest mechanically. I'll be the sour one again, but we've had robots who are nowhere near as fast or efficient as humans for at least 60 years now and they keep getting better. And they're still nowhere near as fast or efficient as humans.
- barry-cotter 7y agoRobots keep on expanding in the range of areas where they are as fast and efficient as humans, or better. Industrial automation is why the value of US manufacturing keeps growing while employment has dropped or held steady.
- soheil 7y agoNot sure if ML is the answer given there are much more efficient machines that already do this at scale [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjAXX-PCwjI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VjAXX-PCwjI
- flor1s 7y agoNice video. The article somewhat addresses this: "These previous approaches include using a belt‐driven band saw‐type mechanisms or water jet cutting. These approaches have limitations, most notably that the outer leaves of the lettuce can be easily damaged when harvesting and there is a lack of reliability in stem cutting height and quality." Seems like the solution discussed in the article does not really improve upon this significantly: "As the project stands, the damage rate, caused by cutting the lettuce stem too short, is too high for supermarket standards, although the harvested vegetables were perfectly edible. The most recent sample size of 69 lettuces was enough to confirm this as the next problem to address (hundreds of lettuces had been harvested over previous iterations). Future versions of Vegebot will need to address and improve the damage rate, perhaps with visual feedback from the harvested lettuces dynamically adjusting the force threshold at which the cut is made. In parallel, the end effector needs to be made lighter to achieve a human‐level cycle time, possibly by manufacturing with carbon fiber, or by using an alternative, stronger cartesian arm design."
- dghughes 7y agoA similar machine exists for white asparagus. I believe it was custom made by the people who own the family farm. The link below doesn't give much info. I think it uses electrical resistance in the soil to determine if the asparagus spear is ready to be picked. https://www.futurefarming.com/Machinery/Articles/2018/4/Sparter-Worlds-first-selective-asparagus-harvesting-robot-273538E/ https://www.futurefarming.com/Machinery/Articles/2018/4/Spar...
- a_bonobo 7y agoI think this works extremely well in custom applications, small family farms etc. - here's another beautiful example from a small Japanese cucumber farm https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/how-a-japanese-cucumber-farmer-is-using-deep-learning-and-tensorflow https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/gcp/how-a-japanese-cu...
- Animats 7y agoThere are lots of experimental picking robots. Apples, especially. None are yet commercial technology, but several prototyepe apple-picking robots are getting reasonably close. The machinery is still too slow and too fragile for routine use. Machine learning for weeding is in production. "Recognize weed, kill weed" targeted weeding is available from John Deere and others now. Picking, not yet.
- est 7y agosomewhat related in 2016 https://futurism.com/world-first-robot-run-farm-harvest-30000-heads-lettuce-daily https://futurism.com/world-first-robot-run-farm-harvest-3000...
- benj111 7y agoIt interesting to think what this could do for farming. Imagine one of these to a field continuously driving around. First weeding, killing pests, targeted watering, then when you get to harvesting you can be so much more targeted. If you have an order for 100 lettuce of x weight, the robot can remember the 100 that most closely match that weight, and go an harvest that 100 only, replanting a seed in the space. Or you could plant at double density and harvest every other one young. It could measure nutrients and moisture in every square metre of soil, recording what grows best where in each patch of a field. The amount of precision it could bring is amazing, potentially organic, and at least much improved efficiencies and carbon emissions.