3 ms·
Assuming some worst case scenario, how many people would need to be on another planet for the species to survive? Would 1 million be enough to support the neces
by dalke 16y ago
Assuming some worst case scenario, how many people would need to be on another planet for the species to survive? Would 1 million be enough to support the necessary technical infrastructure independent of the Earth?
If it isn't independent of the Earth then what's the urgency? Would having the same number of people on/in Earth, inside an independent ecosystem ("Biosphere III", perhaps?) be sufficient safety net? That would be a lot cheaper.
The presumes that the author's stated goal of species survival is the only goal in advocating the colonization of other planets.
I believe there are gaps and omissions in the text.
"most recent 2 millennia living as farmers" -- that should be about 6 millennia.
"there is no evidence that modern humans have ever gone extinct on a continent or a large island." -- what, the Vikings on Greenland aren't modern enough while 1602 is?
"Detection of a large asteroid on a collision course with Earth would no doubt precipitate a frantic scramble to retrofit existing missiles to deliver a nuclear explosive to deflect it toward a less terrifying trajectory." -- except I thought there were more effective ways than nuking it to another orbit. Nuclear weapons have a lot of energy but not a lot of momentum. A mass driver, or a gravity tow, or a number of other techniques seem more appropriate from what I've read.
"which each killed more than 200,000 people provide powerful reminders of the vulnerability of our species to natural disasters." -- not at all. That's 0.003% of the species. If anything, it shows the vulnerability of an human but the resiliency of our species.
I can even argue that having more people, including those living in dangerous places, means more chances for survival. If we all uniformly lived away from Vesuvius, from tornado alley, from tsunami prone areas, and instead only lived in the safest, then we increase the chances that an unexpected event (asteroid, anyone?) at just the wrong spot can destroy everyone.
That's only hand-waving, which is what the author does all over the place.