5 ms·
Honest, but leading, question in return: Offensive to whom? 90% of the population? Wouldn't that block out the Church of Satan's distributed materials (that is,
by falcolas 7y ago
Honest, but leading, question in return: Offensive to whom? 90% of the population? Wouldn't that block out the Church of Satan's distributed materials (that is, coloring books)?
To 80% of the population? Wouldn't that be the Book of Mormon?
To 60%? The Quran?
I think this part of their answer is a great response: "Of course, the simplest reason is that it's not up to us to decide what the rest of the world should or shouldn't see. Bad news, it's not up to you either. Worse news, it's still true even when we agree. Which is probably most of the time."
- NullPrefix 7y ago>Offensive to whom Offensive to those, who can make enough noise about it.
- josteink 7y agoWhich would typically be privileged people, non-ironically complaining about other people’s privilege.
- djsumdog 7y agoPeople don't have privilege. People toss around that word a lot and it's used incorrectly, as it is here. Say you walk into a store and are followed or stopped quite often for a receipt check. If you're black in certain parts of the world, this is quite common, but much more rare if you're not black. The privilege is a result of a system. You cannot say x people have privilege, and likewise people get offended when people yell at them for having privilege saying, "It's not something I choose." Is one person from one ethnic group responsible for all the ills cast upon others? Are we responsible for the debts of our fathers? Privilege is a result of a system, and it is a system that grants privilege and socialite (and often subconscious) level, and that system of beliefs is what needs to be changed. So fighting against privilege involves changing the narrative of the system we live in. It takes time and it takes diligence and it takes careful and critical thought. It's not as easy as throwing a word or blame around.
- traderjane 7y agoThat sounds like silly word play. It'd be like if I said "Tom has power." To which I guess you might reply, "People don't have power. Societies have power, structures have power, and positions have power... but people don't have power." Okay, sure. But Tom still has power. We are all responsible for the debts of our fathers, except the bill comes in the form of the physical world we inhabit. Who thinks they exist away from the past, except as rhetorical play about conquering old challenges?
- smsm42 7y ago> People don't have privilege. I don't know. If you have the power to shut down a whole product line for a trans-national corporation with a single complaint, isn't that a kind of privilege? I certainly can't do it, you probably neither. But some people can. If you have a power to decide what is allowed to be spoken and what gets you removed from the platform, who is allowed to speak and who should be met with violence if only they dare to show up - isn't that a kind of privilege? If you can riot, destroy property, assault people and send them to the hospital - with full impunity and vocal support of major parts of the press and community, that would loudly denounce this conduct in everybody else - isn't that a kind of privilege? Some people seem to enjoy it.
- msbarnett 7y ago
- gwbas1c 7y agoI think you misunderstand the concept of Social Privilege: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_privilege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_privilege
- Zaskoda 7y ago> Offensive to whom? This is exactly the comment I clicked through to add. Without someone to be offended, nothing is offensive. When a service provider crosses the line and polices a piece of media, they are now responsible for defining that line moving forward. That's an insanely hard task. Most people who want "offensive" content taken down do not understand the complexity of what they are asking for.
- lucideer 7y agoSlightly more pragmatic reframing of the question: > "Why do you host harmful content?" To which your returned question would be similarly open-ended: Harmful to whom? Define harmless content. Etc. ... but probably a little more "down to earth" in terms of discussing the bounds of such definitions. The root of being "offended" may often be grounded in an agenda to silence and control, but it's typically defended by referencing potential harm. So that's usually a good place to start overturning such arguments.
- sdinsn 7y agoI disagree. Both "offensive" and "harmful" are up to debate based on arbitrary views / moral codes.
- zbyte64 7y agoIs that useful though? The following requires a moral code to say it is bad: Directly advocating for sexual violence against another group.
- sdinsn 7y agoYou don't need a moral code. The pragmatic argument is that throughout history and across cultures, the rise of large civilizations was enabled by basic rule of law. Protecting people against violence brings stability and maximizes productivity.
- lucideer 7y agoThis is exactly what I said in my comment. I just think debating the former is meaningless (even if two parties agreed, their shared conclusion wouldn't be useful as offending someone isn't implicitly harmful). Whereas debating what's harmful, while similarly arbitrary and subjective, at least has the implied goal of actual harm reduction.
- sdinsn 7y ago> This is exactly what I said in my comment. Ooops, I think I replied to the wrong comment
- stcredzero 7y agoCheck out their MFFAM policy. Search for, "What is the "MFFAM" policy?"
- tubbs 7y agohttps://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/about/faq#BecauseFuckNazisThatsWhy https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/about/faq#BecauseFuckNazisT...
- smsm42 7y agoThe policy is a bit of a misnomer though - as I understand, that's them funding the fight - by donating the money that would otherwise be their profit - not the "morons". But I think that's a very acceptable way to handle the problem.
- Elidrake24 7y agoIt's a tough question isn't it? One we've tried to answer a good many times as a species. The last sincere attempt may be considered to be the Universal Declaration of Human Rights; that an individual may live freely regardless of race, color, sex, religion, political opinion, etc. That seemed contradictory at the time, bit it was always predicated on the idea that no one could ever affect the ability of another to live their life in a free way. It's just funny to see the same old argument brought up the thousandth time with maybe a slight context change to the last.